Paul & Eddy's Pizza

$ • Pizza

1919, 1630 Whitney Ave, Hamden
(203) 230-9396


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Paul & Eddy's Pizza

I ordered 2 slices to go, I noticed the box was light but was in a hurry. When I later opened the box, I saw they were very small and paper thin, no joke, the dough was completely overstretched. I can see in the pictures that's not how they usually make their pizza, so why did you sell these to me. I was out on business and didn't have time to go back or get something else. Just disappointed. If they were upfront about it I wouldn't be writing this, it's the fact that they full review

I was looking for a new pizza place and I was in Hamden, Connecticut which is about a half hour's drive from where I live, so I was choosing blindly. I bought two pizzas from Paul and Eddy's, the staff was friendly, and headed home and with anticipation tried my first slice. Delicious just the way I like my pizza, slightly charred, tasty.
Perfect in every way! Will definitely go back.

Just bought a pizza there. When opened the box the pizza looks great. However, when I put a slice on the plate we discovered that the whole bottom of this pizza is a pure charcoal! Not even single patch of a brown color- all black. I can not imagine that someone can put this thing in a box for takeout!

More Reviews(118)


Monday 11AM - 8:45PM
Tuesday 11AM - 8:45PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8:45PM
Thursday 11AM - 8:45PM
Friday 11AM - 9PM
Saturday 11AM - 9PM
Sunday 12 - 8:45PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.