8 Best Ice Cream Shops near Pawcatuck

“Yum, yum, yum, yum ,yum! Toppings galore. Wish they had more picnic tables, instead of just the one. I also know there is not much room there... but they could squeeze another or two. Staff is always polite even when I know they have to be a bit overwhelmed by lines. BLIZZARDS ARE LIFE! #ProudFatGirl“

“We hired Pompelmo Gelato to cater dessert for our wedding and I cannot recommend them enough. Melanie was kind, professional, and excellent at communication. We went in to the shop for a tasting and were blown away with how delicious all the different flavors were. We had a hard time narrowing it down to only four flavors. The gelato cart was adorable and a huge hit to all our guests.“

“Best breakfast in the area! This cute little store front has you feeling like you’re back in the 50s. Counter service and three small booths. Breakfast lunch and ice cream is all they serve. Great small town feel as well. We love this place and will definitely be back! Highly recommend the smothered home fries.“

“This place is absolutely phenomenal! I work across the street and a bunch of us order lunch here at least twice a week. They have the best burgers I have ever had, and their fries are SO good. Their hot chocolate is made from scratch, and while it does take a while to prepare, it’s some of the best hot chocolate you’ll ever have. I absolutely recommend this place, everything is perfection. Oh, and make sure you get the Thai-Chili sauce on your french fries. It’s made in-house and is so friggin good!“

“This little Mystic gem has the delicious ice cream creations around! I had the PB & fudge sundae and my wife had the caramel lovers sundae. OMG delightful! The ice cream is fantastic, the service is quick. Not a lot of seating and it is always packed but the line moves quickly. It gives you time to make the perfect choice. The ambiance is cute, like a country ice cream shop. I love good ice cream and this place knocks it out of the park! A must try and you won't be disappointed!“

“When my family and I go out for ice cream ... This is the place. Have a silly picture taken out front. Sit on the riverfront and enjoy your desert in the sun. The flavors are so so good ... Black raspberry w chocolate is my favorite... Great service and super friendly staff.“

“Hands-down, the greatest ice cream I’ve ever had in my life! Everything is homemade, friendly service with a smile, and simply put, the most delicious, flavorful ice cream ever. Between my husband, kids, and I, I was able to taste four different flavors, all incredible. You can taste the quality of the ingredients. A definite stop on your visit in Mystic.“

“Homemade ice cream & great flavors! Also, they have dairy free options. I had pistachio & black raspberry, they were delicious. The pistachio ice cream was full of nuts and great texture. Clean place to sit down and eat. And the owner was very friendly. We will see you more often!“