Friendly people and good food. My wife and I received a gift certificate and finally decided to use it. We were very pleased. My wife had the eggplant parm 12" grinder and I had the sausage parm 12" grinder. From the first bite to the last we both enjoyed our grinders. The first thing that you will notice when you pick it up is the weight. They were heavy! The flavor of the sauce is perfect. My wife said she had 4 big pieces of eggplant and plenty of red and green peppers. The flavor was very good. My sausage was stuffed and overflowing with sausage and peppers. I really enjoyed this grinder. Who knew that I have such a great choice for grinders right around the corner! On a side note, I caught a glimpse of the thick pizza. It looks just like the pizza my grandmother used to make. I can't wait to try some of that. Sorry no pictures, we were too hungry and with the smell of these two grinders filling the truck, it's amazing that they made it home.
Reggie
Pizza was great and cooked to my specifications. Felt welcomed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
holly mclin
The BEST old Fashioned Pizza around…Staff is so Friendly and sauce is delish!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean Kafka
Foods great , kinda tight spot and location wish they were still at the old
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Michael Browning
My first time trying Renaldo's was in November 2023 and I've ordered two more times since then. For my most recent order, I got a large (16") pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and "cinnaknots". I think the pizza is some of the best I've ever had. I think everything about it is soooo good: the dough, the cheese, the pepperoni are all fantastic and I love the sauce. I don't normally even think about think about sauce on pizza but it's really that good here.I try garlic knots everywhere I go that offers them. Let me tell you, these are the best I've ever had!The cinnaknots are also delicious. My only complaint is that I wish they offered a half dozen option via doordash like they do for the garlic knots.I will be ordering again!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Frank W.
My wife and I dropped off some used clothing and other items at the nearby Goodwill outlet so we settled on Renaldo's for lunch. I purchased a pair of slices and a bottle of soda for $6.50 plus tax. The slices were large and the service friendly, but the pizza itself was pretty ordinary.
Kevin Witkowski
Best Apizza in the area. Great crust and ratios of toppings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenshin 20
As much as I hate giving bad reviews to people and places, the food was horrible and dull and simple; the bread was burned, and there was almost no cheese, even if I asked to pay for extra cheese.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Richard Kulasenski
Not the Renaldos of the previous owners that's for sure. Thick, doughy, undercooked, horrible sausage... and I picked up a bag of pepper biscuits while I was there...they had the texture of stale soft pretzels.. went into the trash (as did the leftover pizza). Will never go back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Vincent P.
I haven't tried too many items here because the old-fashioned pizza is too good to pass up. Order a half sheet or a whole sheet, this pizza is amazing. Similar to a Sicilian, this pizza is delicious with a thicker crust and a sauce with slight kick to it. New owners were polite and prompt and delivered the same old-fashioned that everyone expects.
Terrible meat lovers pizza. Everything was thrown together sloppy. Don’t go here.
Jane M.
Delicious! The best garlic knots I've ever had with amazing pizza and an even better cost.
B H
Very tasty pizza! Will be ordering again
Lisa Haury
I had high hopes for the gluten free pizza but it was just okay. Way too heavy on the sauce, minimal cheese and the spices in the sauce overpowered the entire pizza. Don’t think I’d try them again.
Andrea Zak
We ordered a gluten free cheese and mushroom pizza tonight from Renaldo's. We will definitely be ordering again!! The pizza was the best gluten free one we have ever had! It tasted amazing. Sam knows her stuff and truly cares about her customers. She takes a lot of time to clean and prep areas to ensure there is no cross contamination for her customers. I highly recommend trying it out! Sam, thank you for such a positive, wonderful experience and all your help!! You are the best!
Friendly people and good food. My wife and I received a gift certificate and finally decided to use it. We were very pleased. My wife had the eggplant parm 12" grinder and I had the sausage parm 12" grinder. From the first bite to the last we both enjoyed our grinders. The first thing that you will notice when you pick it up is the weight. They were heavy! The flavor of the sauce is perfect. My wife said she had 4 big pieces of eggplant and plenty of red and green peppers. The flavor was very good. My sausage was stuffed and overflowing with sausage and peppers. I really enjoyed this grinder. Who knew that I have such a great choice for grinders right around the corner! On a side note, I caught a glimpse of the thick pizza. It looks just like the pizza my grandmother used to make. I can't wait to try some of that. Sorry no pictures, we were too hungry and with the smell of these two grinders filling the truck, it's amazing that they made it home.
Pizza was great and cooked to my specifications. Felt welcomed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The BEST old Fashioned Pizza around…Staff is so Friendly and sauce is delish!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Foods great , kinda tight spot and location wish they were still at the old
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
My first time trying Renaldo's was in November 2023 and I've ordered two more times since then. For my most recent order, I got a large (16") pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and "cinnaknots". I think the pizza is some of the best I've ever had. I think everything about it is soooo good: the dough, the cheese, the pepperoni are all fantastic and I love the sauce. I don't normally even think about think about sauce on pizza but it's really that good here.I try garlic knots everywhere I go that offers them. Let me tell you, these are the best I've ever had!The cinnaknots are also delicious. My only complaint is that I wish they offered a half dozen option via doordash like they do for the garlic knots.I will be ordering again!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
My wife and I dropped off some used clothing and other items at the nearby Goodwill outlet so we settled on Renaldo's for lunch. I purchased a pair of slices and a bottle of soda for $6.50 plus tax. The slices were large and the service friendly, but the pizza itself was pretty ordinary.
Best Apizza in the area. Great crust and ratios of toppings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As much as I hate giving bad reviews to people and places, the food was horrible and dull and simple; the bread was burned, and there was almost no cheese, even if I asked to pay for extra cheese.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Not the Renaldos of the previous owners that's for sure. Thick, doughy, undercooked, horrible sausage... and I picked up a bag of pepper biscuits while I was there...they had the texture of stale soft pretzels.. went into the trash (as did the leftover pizza). Will never go back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I haven't tried too many items here because the old-fashioned pizza is too good to pass up. Order a half sheet or a whole sheet, this pizza is amazing. Similar to a Sicilian, this pizza is delicious with a thicker crust and a sauce with slight kick to it. New owners were polite and prompt and delivered the same old-fashioned that everyone expects.
Restaurantji Recommends
Terrible meat lovers pizza. Everything was thrown together sloppy. Don’t go here.
Delicious! The best garlic knots I've ever had with amazing pizza and an even better cost.
Very tasty pizza! Will be ordering again
I had high hopes for the gluten free pizza but it was just okay. Way too heavy on the sauce, minimal cheese and the spices in the sauce overpowered the entire pizza. Don’t think I’d try them again.
We ordered a gluten free cheese and mushroom pizza tonight from Renaldo's. We will definitely be ordering again!! The pizza was the best gluten free one we have ever had! It tasted amazing. Sam knows her stuff and truly cares about her customers. She takes a lot of time to clean and prep areas to ensure there is no cross contamination for her customers. I highly recommend trying it out! Sam, thank you for such a positive, wonderful experience and all your help!! You are the best!