Italian Restaurants near Bay Lake

“Pizza and Pasta this good just hits different after a day at Disney. It was prepared quickly, and was very tasty indeed.Chicken Alfredo : 10/10Cheese Pizza : 10/10$4 Mac : 7.5/10It feels like catering quality. The crust and cheese are excellent, the only improvable would be the sauce.The 16" Cheese Zah is very sufficient for three adults.Staff was friendly.We spent $45 with a tip to feed our family of five, but we shared.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly. Open concept leaves a lot of room to spread out and be a kid.“

“Pizza and wings were delicious!“

“We are from Lakeland and always drive up here to enjoy the food and atmosphere. Our waiter Moe this evening was very nice and Ethan, the host, was also kind and great to talk to. The food here is delicious and the people are nice. We got the 4 for $40 deal which is an amazing promotion going on for the summer. I highly recommend this place! Shoutout to both Moe and Ethan! Definitely tell Moe I say dankje, which is thank you in Dutch. We will be back soon.“

“The food was terrific and our waiter Paolo was great!“

“Great food and good service“

“We always enjoy lunch at this I-Drive location. The food is delicious and May, our server, is always amazing. May is extremely attentive and personable. Good job Carrabbas and May! Can’t wait to go back.“

“Good food! Nice staff. Pizza and chicken parmigiana absolutely delicious“

“Sam (our server) and Angeline (our Sommelier), along with a very nice young man (been there about 8 months) who brought us in (sorry I didn’t catch his name) made sure we wanted for nothing. We asked for suggestions and they delivered all the way through dessert!! Professional, engaging, and genuinely nice people! Oh, and the food!!!!“

“Another great evening at Maggiano’s. I really cannot get enough of the cosy atmosphere and the friendly staff! Will be back!“

“An amazing meal- the food and drinks were delicious, the atmosphere of the restaurant is beautiful- and the service was truly one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. Federica, Andrea, and Edoardo were an amazing trio!!! They all made sure we had the best time and put so much care into their work from service to drinks to food and beyond. Thank you so much for an unforgettable meal ❤️❤️❤️ we can’t wait to come back!“

“The food was amazing. We had the appetizer trio of Calamari, meatball and pasta. It is large enough to share. We both had veal dishes, one with prosciutto the other with mushrooms and lobster. Also a side of sauteed spinach. It was so fresh and perfectly cooked. Lastly the ricotta cheesecake. A must. Robert, our server really made the night. He was personable and fun. This is a special restaurant that is definitely worth the visit.“

“Carrabas is always our go to for Italian near by. The food the atmosphere is great. Today we had a gentlemen by the name of Mo who was not only great but was very humble and nice. He made sure our food was to our liking and made sure we had our food in time. If places had more people like him it would be great.“

“Brian was our server and he was phenomenal! He went above and beyond for us and his customer service skills were on point! Not only that the food was good and came out quickly and correctly. The menu was easy to understand and the design and vibes of the restaurant were on theme and not overwhelming.“

“Just the best food ever, come with an appetite!!“

“Pizza deliciosa! Excelente ubicación también la muchacha q atendió super amable“

“My favorite restaurant in Winter Garden. Decided to do Italian for Thanksgiving and it was outstanding. My favorite is their Pork Osso Bucco and they did not disappoint. Service and owners are always on point. Thank you for enjoying my first Thanksgiving being waited on. Always recommend this place, never a bad meal. Thank you Dorina“

“My wife has never been a huge pizza fan and always found various places had doughs that were too heavy or toppings that just didn’t have flavor. Being from the northeast originally, I have a fondness for great pizza and being Italian, well it is something of a challenge to find really great pizza places.However, Sal’s Pizza Bar has got the formula nailed down to a science! We are so lucky to have such an amazing place near our home now that we can order from and bring home that “crunch”!The eggplant pizza is my wife’s favorite and I love the “Grandma slice”. However, order anything because Sal doesn’t have a bad item on his menu that we have tried!Thank you Sal and the team he has assembled! Let’s get a few more Sal’s around the OTown area because he has something huge on his hands!“

“27th May 2024.We had a slight problem with a meal that I had to return, but Desirea Smith, our server, resolved the issue in the most professional way, Olive Garden needs to give great credit to her.Even though we had a slight problem, the restaurant still deserves 5 stars.“

“I could literally cry because of the service I was shown by Dexie!I’m came to Orlando to visit my grandmother for her birthday (she’s in a nursing home)I said you can have whatever you’d like for lunch and she chose Olive GardenSpecifically, she wanted thin spaghetti noodles, even though it’s not on the menu I did not know what to do, but after speaking to Dexie, she told me she would make sure she substituted it out for me and she was SO helpful and sweet.She definitely went above and beyond and made this a great birthday for my grandmother, and I appreciate her so much“

“Fantastic food and friendly but professional staff. We had tiramisu and wine one night and then the meatball appetizer and lobster ravioli the following night. All was delicious but the meatballs with the polenta was a delicious new twist.“

“Visited Orlando for the weekend golfing at Bay Hill. Fresco's was recommended by the folks at the Lodge. Glad we stopped in for dinner. The food is excellent. It will be my goto on future Orlando visits.“

“This was my first time every trying there food and I tell you it's the boom ??. Delicious food,customer service is outstanding, employees are nice and greeted me as I walked in. Place it nice and clean. I loved my whole experience in Antonio's house of pizza 100/10 definitely recommend!!!!!“

“We had such a great dining experience! The food was so fresh and high quality. Teresa and Emily were so accommodating and went above and beyond to make our evening special. They even brought out a special treat and balloons when I mentioned it was our daughter’s birthday. We couldn’t have had a better evening. Thank you!“

“We have been to this location at least three times now, but have been to flippers many many times in very the years at the other locations, like old town and the one that was near Disney.The staff is friendly, the food is always so good, and the place is always so clean.I really enjoy the toscana cheese bread.For people that need gluten free they have that option too, it’s shown in the pictures. I’m sure I do not have to point it out :)“

“Very nice Italian restaurant, great food, great staff, overall awesome experience and will come back“

“Host stand was great, room was very nice, table was comfortable. Food was very good flavor wise. Charcuterie App was well presented and plentiful, Carpaccio was delicious and Caesar was adequete. Pork chop was a bit small for a $47 “signature dish”, but delicious. Pasta dishes were very flavorful (Ametricana and Bolognese), but the difference in portion size between the two gluten -free pastas and the regular version of the bolognese was significant. I felt like I was being penalized for the extra expense of the GF pasta. Service left a lot to be desired. Male Server seemed hurried, and was quite forgetful of items (butter, Gf bread.) Another server (a woman) jumped in and assisted, she was slightly better. Saw the manager touch all of the tables (with the exception of ours.). He certainly stopped by the table(s)of locals, as did the Chef......if you are going to do table touches, hit them all and don't be selective. Unfortunately the above will make this a one time visit for a table of locals......overall tasty food, disappointing service and the value just isn't there.“

“The food is amazing.The bartenders are friendly and efficient. My friends and I try to go at least once a month for happy hour .“

“Service was great, small but very comfortable and the best REAL Italian food. We will definitely be coming back.“

“I really enjoy Flippers their pizza are amazing! My favorites are veggie and honey and hog , but all of the pizzas are delicious. The only thing that bothers me is the outside delivery vendor their service is not the best. I wish Flippers would go back delivering the pizzas; I understand it saves money but the company they use are rushed and the pizza come messed up.“

“Went to a private event here. The staff and food were all great. The ambiance was nice as we had a private room with space for about 50 people. I had the filet which was a bit over done for medium. The Cesar salad was better than expected. Overall I'd return.“

“Huge RAVE for La Piccolina - Winter Garden. We went to celebrate my father’s birthday and everything was wonderful. The food was delicious, so flavorful and generous portions! On top of our delicious meals the service was excellent! They went above and beyond, surprised my daughter with a fun make her own pizza, which was so fun and a sweet surprise. This place is authentic and caters to hospitality! Thank you for making our dining experience so wonderful! We can’t wait to come back.“

“Delicious food, served fresh. Relaxing atmosphere. Inside and outside dining and stress free carryout!“

“7.2 ? Decent Flop, My recent visit to Pie Fection left me with mixed feelings about their pizza. The crust, while decent, lacked the desired crispiness and chewiness, though it served its purpose well. Unfortunately, the sauce was disappointingly sparse, leaving each bite wanting for more of its tangy flavor. However, the cheese was a standout feature—ample and perfectly gooey, it added a delightful creaminess to the pizza. Overall, while it had its moments, there's room for improvement. Consider it for a quick fix, but if you're seeking pizza perfection, you might want to explore other options that could be much cheaper as a medium pizza will run you about 27$. FOLLOW ME on Instagram for more pizza reviews @ Zach_Reviews_Pizza“

“My wife and I stopped in for date night, we sat in the lounge area and were a little disappointed to see children sitting at the bar. Our server Jake was attentive, friendly, and a joy. With the exception of one of the appetizers all of the food was fantastic. The wait wasn't too bad for a busy night, everything was very clean and presentable both insode and out, and all of the staff was friendly and accommodating. Even as we waited to be seated and the greeter wasn't busy with taking reservations she would wipe the fingerprints from the glass doors.Parking: It was a busy night amd we did have to circle the building twice to find parking.“

“Fantastic restaurant. I have been coming here for years and it is always friendly and welcoming with fantastic freshly cooked food.So friendly for families. I highly recommend this restaurant.Kid-friendliness: Super friendly for kids all over.“

“Ahhhhmazing! The sauce is so fresh you can literally taste the tomatoes. We had italian sausage, pepperoni, sweet peppers with onion. Literally best pizza hands down. Our son got the pepperoni because he doesn't like anything else and finished off 4 pieces. Freshest vegetables and the crust was perfect.“

“By far one of the best experiences I have had at a restaurant. The charcuterie tray had the most wonderful tasting meats, olives, cheese and goodies you could want. The half chicken with sweet potatoes was to die for as was the lamb. I definitely recommend this place to everyone. The manager was exceptional and made sure we had a delightful experience“

“We arrived for dinner at 10:15 at night and everything was perfect, the food was delicious as always and the service was excellent!! It's nice to go a while before closing and everything is delicious and they serve you in a good way... Super recommended!!!“

“The service was awesome , food was delicious for the most part I ordered a chicken piccata which was specially made by the chef it was on the saltier side and was the same cost as the Veal 38$ for a chicken piccata is a little ridiculous. Otherwise the rigatoni bolognese was absolutely delicious as well as the fettuccini Alfredo and the fried calamari .“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Carrabba’s and was fortunate to be served by Mario, who made the experience truly exceptional. From the moment we were seated, Mario’s warm and welcoming demeanor set the tone for the evening. His professionalism and attentiveness were apparent in every interaction, ensuring that our dining experience was nothing short of outstanding.Mario’s knowledge of the menu was impressive, and his recommendations were spot on, guiding us to delicious choices we might not have considered otherwise. He was attentive without being intrusive, always there when we needed him and providing service with a genuine smile.What truly stood out was Mario’s ability to anticipate our needs before we even voiced them, demonstrating a level of care and commitment that is rare to find. His enthusiasm for his work was evident and infectious, making our meal more enjoyable and memorable.Mario is a shining example of excellent customer service and a true asset to Carrabba’s. I hope his hard work and dedication are recognized and appreciated. Thank you, Mario, for making our night special. We look forward to returning and hope to be served by you again.“

“It's that annual tradition of eating NYPD Pizza. One of the many perks of vacationing in Orlando is that this pizza place is here. I wish that they were open past 9 pm. Still found time to get this delicious pizza. Pepperoni for my 13 year old niece while four adults split a Queens Deluxe with black olives added. First time trying this one, and it's excellent.“

“Amazing setting, music, and food. Everything is very presentable, and fresh.“

“Love this place… perfect combination of atmosphere and great food.“

“Visiting Orlando, Oreganatta was close to my hotel. We decided to try it out. It was great.“

“Can’t believe this hidden Jem was right under our noses all the time!! Highly recommend this truck!!! Food excellent! Staff is awesome!!! Can’t find this good anywhere in Orlando !“

“We got the best service of our lives here!! Laura was absolutely phenomenal. So kind, prompt, and went above and beyond to make our dinner special. Customer service has gone so downhill, so we were so surprised by the level of service we received. Thank you so much!!! We appreciate everything!“

“Me and my mom had lunch here and you get sit yourself, someone will come up and take your order. The young lady was very nice she pointed out some items that were out to give us heads up. I’m plant-based and my mom is up and coming vegan so we got a 18” pie (pizza) that had All Vegan cheese, Sausage, Sauce, bell peppers, Black Olives, Onions, Tomatoes, Mushrooms Which came up to a little over $50 something dollar Pie (pizza). They charged $3 for every topping and depending on the size of the pie it ranges from $3-$5 per Topping even the premium items like (Vegan Sausage, Vegan Pepperoni, Vegan Cheese, Vegan Sauce). Honestly the price was a little ridiculous but the food was good nice crispy bottom it was giving brick style texture and taste. Also I asked for roasted tomatoes and Bell peppers and I didn’t taste anything roasted nor did I taste the vegan sausage to be honest you don’t see it you need a magnifying glass ? to see it. Lol not joking I was expecting big chunks but it was crumbles. When I finally tasted the sausage it was a bit dry. I’ll still come back I just know what to get and what not to get.“

“Really good Pizza, location could use an update.“

“The Stuffed Veal Chop is to die for. Excellent food and service. Our waiter was super nice. Forgot his name.“

“An impromptu Breakfast reservation which turned out to be an amazing and a little overwhelming experience , highly recommended , thank you“