24 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elkton

“Great all Around! Food was great, service was great, atmosphere was great. Why didn't I stop here before???Dietary restrictions: Salads Are on the menu!Kid-friendliness: Was quite a few kids running around. Great, casual atmosphere“

“First time hearing of and eating at Mellow Mushroom. The staff is very amazing and friendly and pizza is top notch! And this is coming from a New Yorker:).The hours of operation were convenient. I was looking for a place to eat late at night and this place popped up a few block from my hotel. If I visit St Augustine again, I will definitely eat here and will eat at other Mellow Mushrooms in other states.“

“Lizzy the bartender was great, persoanble and attentive. Food great as well.“

“We come to St. Augustine every year and ran across this place on accident. We had to make sure and grab some before we headed back home. It definitely did not disappoint! We try a lot of different pizza places and this one is at the top! Wish we were locals but this will be a stop every trip we make here. DELECIOUS. AUTHENTIC. ❤️“

“Pizza was hot and tasty! Salad was fresh. Friendly staff, quick service, relaxed dining environment. I will definitely go back!“

“I’m not sure where to start, but this restaurant really blessed our family this evening. Long story, but they went above and beyond to help our family. They were super kind and we are so appreciative of their willingness to help us. Our food was also really good! :)“

“First time at Carmelo's. The Pizza was Great as well as the service. Our server Bee (like Bumble Bee) was extremely friendly and attentive. Will definitely be back and highly recommend.“

“We enjoyed dinner there last night. Very casual place with friendly staff and delicious food! The cocktails are great too!“

“Fantastic pizza pie. Highly recommend.“

“best pizza around and the subs are awesome as well“

“Fabulous pizza… some of the best I have ever had! Can’t wait to go back!! Truck was parked at Muggsy's.“

“Absolutely delish! The food was wonderful, fresh and perfect proportionally.. the drinks great, our wonderful waitress Ireland helped us pick out a bottle of wine that paired beautifully with our dinner.. she was very attentive. Great server!! Thank you!! Please make reservations and do not miss out on this local awesome restaurant!!“

“We came from out of town just to come back to pizzalleys! TWICE!!!!! In ONE day. Sam was our waitress at first and then Isabella and Kevin the second go around. We couldn’t be more happy and pleased with both experiences. Great food, drinks, atmosphere and customer service. Ask for any of them!!“

“Best Italian restaurant in St Augustine by far. Food was delicious, staff was fantastic and the owners are from my home state of NJ. What more can you ask for ?? My wife and I will definitely be coming back !!“

“We are staying at the RV park across the street, and decided to order from here! I am so glad we did, we ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was awesome!! Great sauce, great spices, Was really damn good! Reminded me of The good old New York slices!!“

“Best pizzas ever ! Such a nice crew, i love everyone at US1 S“

“Ordered baked pasta dishes. One lasagna and one spaghetti and meat sauce. Was good, hot and fresh. Was not “OMheck this is the best pasta ever” good but it was flavorful and tasty enough I would eat there again. Garlic knots were very soft, good and baked fresh. A few outdoor dining tables. I’d recommend.“

“I've been in Florida for almost a month and honestly this is the first place that got my order right the first time!!!!!!!! and it was sooo good 😊 better than Carmelo's Domino's st Augie's and Pizza Hut 💯 chicken is off the cain as well“

“Well, DJ CHIP HERE ya know i love great food !! it was time that we made a post about the food mafia food truck as everything from Amici is beyond your expectation and so was the food mafia truck the lobster roll ….the double Smashburger, the extra large cheese dog and the onion rings that we had absolutely unbelievable the quality of the food, the friendly staff. It was a fantastic experience. Hats off for the food mafia truck and Amici‘s once again you have to go try. You’re missing out if you don’t. thanks Freddy & Jen“

“So I stopped in here the other night and the young lady at the counter said they had some of the best wraps and boy was she right. Got the chicken Caesar salad and boy was it hefty. Came back the next night and got the steak and cheese wrap and again I highly recommend this place for their wraps.“

“Hey, I’m not sure if this email will find anyone but I have a small concern.I’ve ordered 4 or 5 times and the pizza is really good…. But tonight I feel like the ball was dropped. I ordered half veggie and half meat and it looks like they just put the bare minimum of toppings on the meat side.The in house employees were all very busy and by the time I realized the pizza was “skimpy” I was already home.Please let me know what can be done to fix this.I’m not a fan of public reviews soI tried to find a management email address online but I had no luck“

“The staff here is lovely and they have some great food and drink deals throughout the week. The food didn't knock my socks off but it was still tasty and better priced than most Italian restaurants in the area. What I would order again: - Gusto Meatball Parmigiana - Gnocchi Alla Romana“

“This is the second and last time we’ll be getting a pie from this establishment did not make as ordered, sauce too salty paid for extras and didn’t receive them and this for a pickup, and price way too high“

“Had the individual pan pizza, perfect for one and great price! It seemed Laura was by herself but she provided excellent, friendly customer service👍🐻“