28 Best Pizza Restaurants near St. Augustine Beach

“I have a lot of affection for this place. Warm atmosphere, top quality food without a lot of pretentiousness. The house made pasta is a must. Not to mention a rare place that has wild boar ragu sauce on the menu. If you know, you know. Love love love.“

“Food was pretty good. My husband loved his antipasto salad and my big CD was good except the noodles were way overcooked and mushy. The young man at the cash was super friendly and lovely to deal with the smell in the restaurant is amazing. Next time I’ll try the pizza.“

“First time hearing of and eating at Mellow Mushroom. The staff is very amazing and friendly and pizza is top notch! And this is coming from a New Yorker:).The hours of operation were convenient. I was looking for a place to eat late at night and this place popped up a few block from my hotel. If I visit St Augustine again, I will definitely eat here and will eat at other Mellow Mushrooms in other states.“

“We’ve been here several times for dinner. We usually have Bre as our waitress. She’s been great. Always takes her time to answer any questions. Our drinks are always refilled and we always know if there’s any delays. In highly recommend Piesanos. Ask for Bre, you won’t be disappointed.“

“Beachy, casual, but dont let that fool you. Ordered a burger and was delighted with top quality. Not your average burger for sure. The grated cheese on the fries was a nice touch. Will be back for sure. 10/10 recommend for a quick bite in the vilano beach area. Kayla and Jon seated me and made me feel at home. If you walk by this place hungry, don't hesitate. Worth a stop, would be an understatement.“

“We traveled from SC with our grands to visit family and had to stop here! The pretzel and homemade beer cheese was terrific! We got the daily special of a slice and a drink, and ordered a deep dish pepperoni Chicago pizza to go! We thought we would eat it the next day, but it was gone that night! If you're ever near, stop by!“

“This was the best pizza joint we’ve experienced in a while! My family and I loved it! The pizza was great. We got it by the slice…they know exactly how to heat up that slice, too. We tried the garlic knots…YUM! And, at the recommendation of our airbnb host we tried the pizza pinwheels…AMAZING! Everyone who was working there was working hard, but they were so nice if you had questions. It was a great experience . Oh, and we got cannoli to go…once again, we were not disappointed.“

“We stopped in for a late lunch based on reading reviews and were not disappointed. Fabulous pizza, reasonable prices and friendly service. We tasted some of their mac-n-cheese specialties [they're great by the way], but were too full to order any. Even though we are not from St. Augustine, we may need to find an excuse to drive back!“

“First off our server Brandi, was absolutely amazing and professional, friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable!!! She helped us pick the best meal possibly for everyone. The outside view is beautiful and aesthetically pleasing and gives a beach vibe. The food and drinks were absolutely amazing and very tasty!!! The brussel sprouts, as a side item is recommended for sure as they are sweet and savory and fried. Also make sure you get their amazing fries too!!!Vegetarian options: Can replace tortilla with lettuceDietary restrictions: Gluten Free Pizza“

“I ordered 4 XL pizzas on Christmas eve. They had my order ready in 35 mins! They we very nice and helpful when I came in to pick it up! The pizza was delicious! The dough was really good, and loved the cheese and sauce. Nice to have good pizza this far down on anastasia “

“I am so impressed by Garrett. He is culinary trained chef going above and beyond what you might see in a typical pizza parlor. You are lucky to have this chef using his skills in this area. You can speak to him and customize anything. Find his shop outside Muggsy's bar.“

“We do not visit St. Augustine nearly as much as we used to due to the surplus of tourists. My husband's colleague suggested this restaurant when we visited overnight. My hubs is not a fan of seafood but his colleague and myself are so we chose the happy medium. We put our name down for another restaurant and stopped here for drinks and an appetizer while we were waiting. We were greeted immediately by a host. We decided to grab a drink at the bar and then decided to sit at a table so we could indulge in an appetizer and be comfortable. The bar was packed but the restaurant tables were empty for the most part. We decided to split the Frito Misto so hubs could have the veggies. It tasted fresh and was actually enough for the three of us. I was hoping to visit here again but just noticed they were permanently closed. It truly is unfortunate because I really thought the food and service were great.“

“Great little corner store with delicious pizza, and very competitive gas prices! Seems a bit weird but it's a great combination! Any time we need ice, or stuff for family gatherings we walk down to Carmelo's and they have it all! ?“

“We are staying at the RV park across the street, and decided to order from here! I am so glad we did, we ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was awesome!! Great sauce, great spices, Was really damn good! Reminded me of The good old New York slices!!“

“The friendliest and happiest wait staff ever! It appeared everyone that came through the door were locals as they knew the waitstaff. We had a large thin crust veggie pizza. The pizza was excellent only to be outdone by the tiramisu. We will definitely miss be back.“

“Great vibe! Friendly service! Tasty food! We enjoyed a passion fruit margarita, ahi tuna meal, wood fire pizza, and topped it off with key lime pie! Ross was our bartender/server. He was fun and made great recommendations. Megan helped us plan a private event in the back room. She was lovely to meet/work with! Will be recommending to our friends!“

“We came from out of town just to come back to pizzalleys! TWICE!!!!! In ONE day. Sam was our waitress at first and then Isabella and Kevin the second go around. We couldn’t be more happy and pleased with both experiences. Great food, drinks, atmosphere and customer service. Ask for any of them!!“

“Ordered baked pasta dishes. One lasagna and one spaghetti and meat sauce. Was good, hot and fresh. Was not “OMheck this is the best pasta ever” good but it was flavorful and tasty enough I would eat there again. Garlic knots were very soft, good and baked fresh. A few outdoor dining tables. I’d recommend.“

“As a loyal customer of Domino's Pizza, I've grown accustomed to their reliable service and mouthwatering pizzas. Although there was a rare slip-up with my order, the manager swiftly rectified the mistake by generously offering a credit for my next purchase, reinforcing my trust in their commitment to customer satisfaction. Their drive-thru convenience never fails to impress, consistently delivering quick and tasty meals that keep me coming back for more. Domino's remains my undisputed go-to for fulfilling my pizza cravings.“

“Outstanding food and had all 15 of my pizzas ready for my daughter's sweet 16 birthday surprise party on schedule. Great price and great service. Lady at the cash register to the guy that helped me load up.Grandma's pizza was the favorite. It went quick.Thank you Romanos“

“Ordered online and had it delivered, pizza was hot upon arrival and the delivery woman was polite. Pizza was as expected for Dominoes, my kids devoured it as did the adults. We will be ordering from them again. Only lost one star as we ordered via the app and it said delivered when it hadn't arrived to us, it arrived closer to 10 min after it said delivered.“

“As delivery pizza goes, you're not going to find anything better in St. Augustine. Their delivery area is the largest, covering most of the city, from just North of the airport, all the way down to SR 206, and from the beach to I95 and beyond. Everything is made fresh, the kitchen is clean, and the delivery is FAST! Open every day of the year until 3AM, including ALL holidays.I recommend the pepperoni rolls, which is pepperoni and provolone cheese rolled up in dough. After baking, they're brushed with garlic butter, and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. I also like the BBQ chicken pizza with bacon and onions added.Vegetarian options: Just don't order meat on your pizza. Boom!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza available.“

“So I stopped in here the other night and the young lady at the counter said they had some of the best wraps and boy was she right. Got the chicken Caesar salad and boy was it hefty. Came back the next night and got the steak and cheese wrap and again I highly recommend this place for their wraps.“

“Hey, I’m not sure if this email will find anyone but I have a small concern.I’ve ordered 4 or 5 times and the pizza is really good…. But tonight I feel like the ball was dropped. I ordered half veggie and half meat and it looks like they just put the bare minimum of toppings on the meat side.The in house employees were all very busy and by the time I realized the pizza was “skimpy” I was already home.Please let me know what can be done to fix this.I’m not a fan of public reviews soI tried to find a management email address online but I had no luck“

“Everyone in our party was delighted with their food selections. Shrimp-plump and perfectly done. Meatballs-both large and tasty. Sweet sausage-fennel heaven! And the fettuccine Alfredo-bliss in every bite! For dessert, the limoncello cake was outstanding!Our meal was enhanced by excellent service: attentive without being disruptive. They have a number of dining rooms, each with its own unique decor. Truly a wonderful experience“

“A tasty Mango Cart Draft & Flying Hawaiian Wings! Absolutely DELISH!Everyone here is sure friendly, service is out standing & these wings... No wonder they win so many awards! Yum! Cool backyard patio, Dodge Ball, Gaga Ball, & Corn Hole!Vegetarian options: Salads, Califlour Crust, Bruchetta, lots of things to chose fromDietary restrictions: GF available can accommodate non dairyKid-friendliness: amazing backyard!Wheelchair accessibility: several ramps“

“Traci our waitress was awesome! Being an Italian from NJ, NY area, we were looking for great food, we found it here! Atmosphere is great, coming back Friday. Met with the owner Tonino, very happy we stopped in for dinner. Great place to eat, drink, and listen to music. Bella serata di Gusto! Grazie mille!“

“Just stopped in for a bite to eat. My family wanted to out of the madness downtown. Could not have picked a better spot. This is a hidden gem. Our food was fresh and hot, the price point was excellent. A young man named Mason served us and truly made the experience special. He is a wealth of knowledge about St Augustine. His family has been there for generations. Nice, polite and brought a small town feel to the place. We will be back EVERYTIME we are here in town.Stop in, ask for Mason he will always steer you in the right direction.“