41 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gainesville

“The scenery and the food are amazing! Love the staff here.“

“I ordered a pepperoni pizza and received a cheese. The delivery driver just left the pizza on the porch. No knocking or calling. I didn’t know it was out there. It was cold by the time I realized it was there. I get pizza from here all the time and it’s normally amazing. this was the worst“

“The gluten-free crust is something I’ve been missing for the 13 years I have been gluten-free. It is thick and flaky and absolutely delicious. I would love to know the recipe! I had Vegan cheese, spinach, tempeh and pepperoni. I was surprised they even had gluten-free pepperoni! It was the best pizza I have ever had and I just wish I lived in Gainesville so I could get it all the time! My only negative is that I wish they had more seating and more comfortable seating. I don’t usually like to sit outside to eat, but they do have a big area out back for that. Thanks again! When I come back to Gainesville in a few months, I will definitely be coming by!“

“Great pizza and excellent wings!“

“Fabulous!!! It was my first time there. My daughter and I went to check it out since she recently just moved there. Absolutely LOVE the front patio. Even with the traffic on Archer, it was a great atmosphere. Our waiter was fantastic. So pleasant and nice. The people making the food were great as well. I paid cash and noticed there was no tip jar. Can you please put one, they truly do deserve it for the service and speed they prepare everything. Great job to all of them!!!!“

“Moved to Fl in "02" from L. I. Peppinos has the best Pizza by far in G'ville. So happy you opened and two minutes from home!“

“I always have a great experience at Newk’s whether dining in or carrying out. My favorite thing to order is the Newk’s favorite salad. The app is very easy to use and allows customization. The rewards program is also good. The staff are always friendly and provide service with a smile!“

“Dining in, taking out, take and bake always a delicious meal. I’ve had a little of everything over the years and always delighted with every bite! Can’t beat their lunch specials, the rolls are amazing, can’t say enough. If you haven’t tried them, YOU are missing out on some great food!“

“Recommend the thin crust.... At their best, it's my favorite pizza in town. Unfortunately quality control is not flawless a little bit below par, so five star if you're listening tighten up on that or next time you'll get four stars LOL“

“Literally the best pizza in Gainesville hands down“

“My husband and i have been eating five star pizza since we started dating almost 10 years ago and it’s hands down one of the best pizza places we have found. Although if you really want a good experience and the best they have to offer you have to go to the five star pizzas on tower road in Gainesville FL. None of the other locations have ever been able to meet the expectations that the tower road store set for us. Plus they just started a loyalty program with text offers and loyalty points which is something we always wished they had but honestly it didn’t factor in on my choice the pepperoni rolls and large pepperoni pizza well done with Garlic or cinnamon rolls and 2 liter of Dr.pepper are my go to every time and they have never let me down on tower road, we make a point to look for five star pizza where ever we go so we have tried them all through out florida, at least north central fl, haven't found them anywhere else.

Vegetarian options: Salad cheese pizza veggie pizza“

“Ate at Leonardos last night and ordered a Big Leo. Thought something was missing in the toppings. Couldn’t determine at restaurant. Had a piece for lunch today and found out not a spec of sausage on the pizza. Come on guys, you’re not giving them away.“

“First visit tonight. Best pizza I have ever had! And the wings were amazing also! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The food was absolutely fantastic.“

“We had my mother’s celebration of life yesterday. The Tower Road Piesanos catered our event. There are no words to express my gratitude to Tim and Mischa for their outstanding service. Tim worked very hard to make everything perfect - even putting up with all my requests. The food was over the top. To quote my cousin “ We want to Chris Ruth last night and this tenderloin puts them to shame. “. Thank you for making mom’s send off perfect. Amy“

“Yummiest bagels and nicest staff around“

“Best NY pizza in Florida!“

“One of the best spots in town. I think the reason I choose this over other places so often is because you simply get more bang for your buck, which is increasingly important. I Want to recommend the pasta in particular. Pasta at so many eateries is overpriced. You've got to pay over $20 a person to get something decent. But you can spend $15 here at I Love NY Pizza on something that tastes great and is big enough to feed multiple people. That's tough to beat!“

“Delicious! The Vegan Bagel Sandwich was perfection 👌 The service was amazing. Very nice people.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Great pizza at a great price!!!“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“AMAZING! their gf pizza is superb“

“The Jersey! Whoa! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!“

“I went in and ate alone. I had Nonna's Spaghetti with a garden salad. The best Spaghetti I have eaten at a restaurant. The foccia bread was seasoned just right with rosemary. The honey balsamic glaze was delicious. I drank a glass of Moscato with my meal. I had flan inhouse and took home tiramisu. The waitress Sharmenda was absolutely wonderful. I will be back with my family. Thank you all so much for a fantastic experience.“

“Great pizza at a great price!!!“

“The food here has always been pretty decent. The prices seem to stay the same for the most part. You can always find some good deals on their website, and we get great customer service when we go. One thing I will say is the inside definitely could use some work when it comes to cleanliness as the tables are always sticky and the floor is not very clean.“

“Blonde girl is super nice and helpful/professional! So is the rest of the staff working the front on: 02/26/2024 at evening time: drove from miami to buy a car in Gainesville so, had to stop for food. Thanks for great pizza and great service.“

“Pizza is crisp and slices are big. Also they usually have a fun/different pizza to try!!! Good wings sauces as well!“

“This Dominos does every order so perfectly. We've tried other Dominos and they just are not the same.
It's amazing, the staff is fabulous and the delivery is on point.
It's extra awesome how you can earn free rewards. Way better than any drive through.“

“A nice gentleman named Gary took my order and gave good help when I asked him about what deals and coupons the store has. He even reccomended I install the Domino's app, I did and it's very good! It already gave me a conditionally free pizza.“

“Good food good customer service“

“The pizookies were so good, definitely lived up to the fame! the service was also amazing, my waitress Dina was super friendly and quick with our orders, she gave me and my friend great recommendations and was overall really helpful! I will definitely return for great food and service.“

“Wow! What an amazing greeting upon picking up at window! Pizza and Lava cakes were just what I was craving.

I didn’t get the employees name, but man! I got the best smile! The order was placed yesterday around 5ish.

Please recognize your team in their quick and friendly service. It’s hard to find these days!!

Ohhh? And why is the Lava cake so tiny? It’s been many of months that I’ve ordered and it’s now half the size of what it used to be.“

“First time here and we loved it!! Sarah was awesome! All 4 of us loved our dinner! Great wine! A Must stop in Gainesville!!“

“I’ve ordered from this place probably 10 times or so, and I definitely recommend it. They’ve only messed up my order once, and promptly made it right as soon as I called them about it. And they’re very efficient with delivery. The food is great too.“

“The owner cares about the customers experience and I appreciate that!“

“This particular branch of Pizza Hut has seen some outstanding improvement lately. I asked one of the employees about it and they told me that there is a new manager. The next time I went in I met her and could see that she was completely dedicated to the customer. It was great to see. I believe her name was Isabella Rose. Excellent job young lady! Keep up the fantastic work. My wife and I love your restaurant and are so grateful for the improvements that you have made, the focus on customer service and the special little touches like the holiday decorations. Good job! Keep it up!“

“I give them 5 stars even though there was a set back due to something that was out of their control and DoorDash took an 1 1/2 to deliver my food and my that time I just asked them to let me pick it up! Nicole was so willing to help and even took some things off due to the wait and was so kind to even remake the pizza for me great atmosphere!“

“Super awesome delivery. I finished mowing and left a note outside asking him to leave it on the front porch. The last thing I expected was a reply on the note saying that my lawn looked great! Made my day!

Also, I've always ordered from this Papa John's (usually carry-out), but I've always had a smooth experience here.“