“Pizzeria is at the end of the building, attached to the Whistle Stop bar itself. This pizza (deluxe and chicken/bbq) was the best we’ve had in all of the keys! It was super delicious, along with the meatballs as starters. Went during post memorial day holiday weekend so I can’t judge on the speed of service, but our food and service was extremely quick. Our waitress was very friendly as well! Definitely a hidden gem any foodie traveling the keys shouldn’t miss.“
“FORGET COMING TO THE KEYS FOR SEAFOOD- as a self proclaimed pizza connoisseur this place is where it’s at!!!Indulged in the hot honey pepperoni pizza, it was cooked to perfection, had great flavour to the sauce & loved the cuppa style pepperonis, add that fresh basil & hot honey drizzle for a touch of heat & sweet … yummo!Now for the pie - absolute perfection! Had both the banana cream & burnt cheesecake - let’s just say I’ll be returning again before I leave!!!!!Fair price for all items, super friendly owners, lots of seating both inside & out with a cool wall mural adorning the walls, ample parking out back, only wish they were open 24-7! Lol“
“I stopped in with my parents because my mom wanted an Avocado toast snack while we were driving from Miami south beach to Key West. Alex greeted us and was so authentically kind and welcoming. She suggested the house special Almond Croissant (we ate 3!! Haha) and we all enjoyed diff warm coffee drinks which were perfect for the warm but windy weather. She suggested a great local beach that was 45 minutes down the road and was very personable and welcoming. Great dirthy chai, great yogurt parfait and croissants for a delish pit stop. Also the decor is FAB.“
“Great meat lovers pizza.Pizza crust was light and crisp. All the ingredients were tasty and fresh. My son got the kids spaghetti and meatballs and it came with a big delicious fresh meatball. Standard selection of bottled beers.Offering takeout and dine in.“
“Absolutely amazing, so glad we stopped here! Cutest little restaurant with classic arcade games and 80's paraphernalia up front, 80's music on the radio, the coolest menus in 80's looking folders, the outside area is creative, colorful and comfortable- from start to finish, the atmosphere is awesome! The food was mouthwateringly delicious. We shared the Mozzarella Caprese appetizer which was beautiful and so tasty. My husband had the Veal Saltimbocca (recommended by our waitress) and devoured it. I had the Cavatelli alla Vodka Rustica which was delightful! Topped it off with the layered chocolate cake. Yum! Highly recommend and we'll be back!“