4.3
Superb
407 Reviews
606 Market Street Suite 160, Kissimmee
Customers’ favorites
- Tomato Spinach and Ricotta Cheese
- The Upper Crust Stuffed Pizza
- Market Cheese Pizza Slice
- Slice of Cheese Pizza
“Located on Market Street, Upper Crust Pizza Cafe is a beloved, laid-back neighborhood staple that serves up fresh New York–style pizza, subs, and classic Italian comfort food. Whether you are grabbing a quick slice on the go, picking up a full pie after a day out, or dining outside on the sidewalk patio, it delivers a straightforward, reliable counter-service experience right in the center of town. What Makes It Shine Authentic NYC-Style Pizza: Known for its crisp yet chewy crust, well-seasoned tomato sauce, and generous cheese-to-topping ratio. Pies are available by the slice or as full custom pizzas, making it great for both quick lunches and group dinners. Diverse Italian Staples: Beyond pizza, the menu features hearty specialty options like stuffed calzones, strombolis, fresh pasta dishes, meatball subs, and crispy garlic knots that serve as excellent crowd-pleasers. Fast & Convenient Counter Service: The easy ordering system and casual setup allow for quick turnaround times, making it one of the most accessible and hassle-free dining options along the main strip. Pleasant Outdoor Seating: Front patio tables offer a great vantage point for people-watching and enjoying the lively downtown atmosphere on pleasant afternoon or evening days. Areas for Improvement Limited Indoor Seating: The interior dining space is cozy and compact, which can lead to quick table turnover or limited seating availability during peak lunch and dinner rush hours. Standard Pricing: While fast-casual in style, prices sit slightly higher than typical chain pizzerias due to its central downtown location, though portions generally remain generous and satisfying. Final Verdict: Upper Crust Pizza Cafe delivers exactly what you want from a downtown pizza joint—delicious, high-quality New York–style slices, friendly counter service, and a relaxed, unpretentious vibe. It remains a top choice for a casual, satisfying bite in Celebration.”