50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Kissimmee

“Visiting Disney and needed a night in to rest —- great menu - delicious, hot and fresh food. Lots of vegetarian options. Great pizza and tasty sauce! Look forward to trying more next time we visit.“

“OMG. Had a large and a medium deluxe between 3 of us and without doubt the best pizza by far but boy are they big. Highly recommend this place as the staff are just as attentive. We will be back…“

“Melhor pizzaria de orlando . Parabéns para a atendente Marília. 👏👏👏“

“REAl NY NJ PIZZA plus everything else is made well. Place is also clean. You gotta go.“

“OMG. Had a large and a medium deluxe between 3 of us and without doubt the best pizza by far but boy are they big. Highly recommend this place as the staff are just as attentive. We will be back…“

“The service was quick and the food was delicious! The guys working were super sweet and friendly. Best pizza we have had in a while!! Highly recommend. Listen to your server’s recommendations, we did and don’t regret it one bit!“

“We had a wonderful experience! The pizza was delicious, fresh, and full of flavor, and the whole atmosphere was great. I especially want to recognize Alfredo, who took care of us. He was very friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. His customer service really made our experience even better.

We’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this place!“

“Awesome pizza and service.“

“Great service and quality food!“

“Love it’ this spot is our Friday go too“

“The food & service was excellent. We had a great chat with the owner, and she was so pleasant. Will definitely be back when we are in town.“

“Friendly staff, clean restaurant and food was great. Pizza made to order if you don't want what's already available. Salad bar had great options and desserts are also available. There's also a mall arcade for kids or adults inside.“

“Great people and great food made from scratch... Delicious“

“Pizza was very good. We were happy to find gluten free pizza in the area. However, we called and placed an order and confirmed that the online pricing was accurate. When we arrived, we were charged MUCH more than the online pricing. They happily fixed the price of the wings ($12.99 online and rang me up for $19.99 when we got there) but we were also over charged for 2 gluten free pizzas by several dollars. The staff working was pleasant and I did not ask for them to fix the prices of the GF pizzas nor did they offer to, but I made them aware that we were overcharged for those as well. The website is not old, it was updated 2 days ago so there should k out be any discrepancies (and certainly not big ones) Very good food, nice workers, just check your receipts. Would eat there again but would make sure pricing is accurate.“

“The food was amazing! Staff was very welcoming and attentive. Highly recommend going if you’ve never been. 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽“

“Best cheesecakes around . Very nice staff and the owner is amazing. Will definitely be back .“

“Located on Market Street, Upper Crust Pizza Cafe is a beloved, laid-back neighborhood staple that serves up fresh New York–style pizza, subs, and classic Italian comfort food. Whether you are grabbing a quick slice on the go, picking up a full pie after a day out, or dining outside on the sidewalk patio, it delivers a straightforward, reliable counter-service experience right in the center of town.
​What Makes It Shine
​Authentic NYC-Style Pizza: Known for its crisp yet chewy crust, well-seasoned tomato sauce, and generous cheese-to-topping ratio. Pies are available by the slice or as full custom pizzas, making it great for both quick lunches and group dinners.
​Diverse Italian Staples: Beyond pizza, the menu features hearty specialty options like stuffed calzones, strombolis, fresh pasta dishes, meatball subs, and crispy garlic knots that serve as excellent crowd-pleasers.
​Fast & Convenient Counter Service: The easy ordering system and casual setup allow for quick turnaround times, making it one of the most accessible and hassle-free dining options along the main strip.
​Pleasant Outdoor Seating: Front patio tables offer a great vantage point for people-watching and enjoying the lively downtown atmosphere on pleasant afternoon or evening days.
​Areas for Improvement
​Limited Indoor Seating: The interior dining space is cozy and compact, which can lead to quick table turnover or limited seating availability during peak lunch and dinner rush hours.
​Standard Pricing: While fast-casual in style, prices sit slightly higher than typical chain pizzerias due to its central downtown location, though portions generally remain generous and satisfying.
​Final Verdict: Upper Crust Pizza Cafe delivers exactly what you want from a downtown pizza joint—delicious, high-quality New York–style slices, friendly counter service, and a relaxed, unpretentious vibe. It remains a top choice for a casual, satisfying bite in Celebration.“

“Very good food , great service . Had gnocchi, veal Marsala and chicken special . Meal comes with garlics knots and a salad . Nice to meet Vito but I still miss Bruno“

“Great food with friendly staff and large outdoor eating area is fantastic! Definitely recommend large pizza selection!“

“Amazing burgers, pizza and of course beer!“

“Really friendly service. Great tasting pizza with an awesome crust. Best in Kissimmee by far!“

“Amei, comida divina e atendimento excelente 💕“

“This morning around 11:30 I ordered the 24" Deluxe pizza with extra sausage...this literally had to be one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten! Five Star pizzas are normally good, but today's was excellent! Great job guys!! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“They always come through on the best food, no matter what we order! Amazing staff, even better food!“

“Went here for the first time after my appointment with Verizon and ordered two gyros for total of $22 and they were AMAZING, so delicious and filling! I’m happy poinciana has a gyro spot now I love them so much they’re my favorite food! Definitely come try them out!“

“Had a bad experience with long wait times and service. But after I spoke to manager Josh wanted me to come back to give them another chance. He gave us a gift certificate to return. That was extremely nice of them. We definitely will be back.“

“This is one of my favorite pizza spots in Kissimmee, however my experience recently was very disappointing. I ordered for pickup and had to pay upfront due to the amount (which is standard in some places), but I thought it sounded like too much $$$ and wondered if they raised their prices. When I got there, we figured out it was a mistake on what was rung up, the kind kid took accountability and apologized, tried to offer me a refund on the excess money I was charged. He called over the older lady that was there (I’m assuming she was in charge), explained to her his mistake and asked her if she could issue the refund. ‘NO’ was her response! ‘You already charged it, you should’ve done it right the first time’ is what she said to him, then she walked off. How unprofessional and disrespectful!! The only reason I didn’t cause a scene was because I felt really bad for this young man, my pizzas were already in the oven, and it was only $5. But it was MY $5 nonetheless, and without a refund, that’s STEALING! He felt so bad and offered me food to offset the money owed, which I just took, cuz honestly I didn’t want to make it worse for him. The young man who helped me and the guy who made the pizza were great to me, and made up for this shitty experience. But that old lady needs to be retrained in customer service skills, and be mindful of how she talks to and treat the employees. Because if she had caught me on the wrong day, I could’ve easily said F-that, I want a FULL refund for that error, and if she refused, I would’ve called the cops for theft!“

“Excellent New York style pizza. Reminds me of my college nights at Niagara University and ordering pizza by the slice with a side of blue cheese dressing.YUM!!“

“It was by far the best food I have ever eaten!!“

“I go here at least three times per week and it’s awesome….great Cappuccinos, bagels and everything else on the menu along with great customer service from everyone behind the counter, especially Nosaiba, who always greets me by name and a smile! Y’all are awesome!!!“

“What a great place founded by accident and it is probably the best pizza I’ve had in the area a very long time and I am a pizza. Also, his staff is wonderful the beautiful Woman, my food is so sweet and so nice exactly what you would want for customer service“

“Great food and family owned.“

“Geraldo, the manager, is amazing. Made my order correct by personally making and delivering. Great pizza. Thanks, Geraldo!“

“We came on a whim after a full day being a tourist and didn’t want to cook dinner…. The reviews did not fail us. Pizza, YUM. Garlic knots will be something I dream about after going back to Wisconsin. Our group has declared this will be a repeat stop! Soooo soo good!“

“Excellent for families with family members who are picky eaters but very hungry! My toddler loves it here! Friendly staff, food pretty good actually.“

“Pizza was good. Large choice of toppings and flavors. Kayla was friendly and helpful. Would definitely eat here again.“

“Mari served us and the pizza and appetizer was amazing! She was very attentive and super polite!!“

“As always the pizza was great and the soda cold. Marco’s is our go to place.“

“atendimento impecável, comida saborosa e sempre fresca.“

“5 stars! The morning crew at Hungry Howie’s always provides fast, friendly, and professional service every time I come in. The team keeps a great attitude, makes sure orders are correct, and the food is always fresh and hot. You can tell they work hard.“

“Very clean, well presented and Covid compliance setting. Outdoor dining plaza is cool and Pizza is delicious!“

“I ordered five empanadas two of them are all beef. Two of them are two cheese which has cheddar and Monterey Jack and the other one was pizza.
The pizza one was not bad. It reminds me pretty much besides the texture of the dough. It just reminds me of eaten like a hot pocket.
And as for the Monterey Jack and cheddar, it was very stringy cheese pole. I ate it hot the way it was, but then I realized when they cool down a little bit, it was easier to eat from my preference to break the cheese without the pull tasty, but I would’ve loved maybe minced up hatched green chilies and jalapeños just to give you a little kick and spice inside
The beef one would be my personal one always the general I would say it wouldn’t be my empanadas that I usually put other ingredients like green, Spanish olives , chopped up pieces of onion and other ingredients..
The frozen piña colada was really good. I could drink a gallon of that stuff, but then I would have an empty wallet.
And that is the only sad part of today’s economy and restaurants. Everything to eat out is a little bit more higher price. I do wish that the city of Kissimmee did not have to charge such high rent to the café at the lakefront they could then adjust their prices to be a little bit more like local restaurants nearby be more competitive in price….
I like their desserts drinks and food just can’t eat it often as I would love to like other restaurants so come on Kissimmee city trap the rent and taxes for these people at the lakefront to keep things more affordable for the community…. Then we will be able to go more often than just as a treat when we have money….“

“Pretty consistent for a Pizza Buffet. Pizza was constantly coming out fresh which was great. The only one comment I do have is about the interior. Parts of the interior seems a little dated and seems to be a little run down. Besides that, I'm mainly there for the food, so it got the job done for me.“

“Absolutely loved my experience at Sabores a Tu Mesa! The cuisine was incredible and the authentic flavor in the Bandeja Paisa was unforgettable. Every bite took me straight back to Colombia and reminded me of the richness and comfort of our food. The drinks were perfect, and the pan con bono is an absolute must try!

A special shoutout to Boni/Buni, our waitress, who was an absolute pleasure. Even though they were close to closing time, she still took the time and care to make sure we had everything we needed and never made us feel rushed. That level of hospitality truly made the experience even better.

Whenever I’m back in the area, I will definitely be coming back. Highly recommend!“

“Was recommended this by a friend and was not disappointed The panzarottis were amazing! Would recommend trying this to anyone good for kids and adults great price for what you get“

“The ONLY and best NY Pizza in town. I am from NY and know 😉. I leave work order and pick it up. I can be around the neighborhood and wait and service the same. Staff very friendly and always with a smile. I can be at home 30 min away and have two places I go to this location. Customer like me very happy and thankful🤗🥰🤗“

“Si quieres comerte una pizza estilo boricua con un sabor del otro mundo pasa por Pizza Mania en word food truck Kissimmee“

“This pizza place serves consistently tasty food. The crust is perfectly baked, the sauce is flavorful, and the toppings are fresh and generous. Orders are prepared quickly and accurately. Friendly service and great quality make it an easy choice whenever I’m craving a satisfying slice.“

“Bayne was an excellent server. Pleasant, prompt, professional. Very attentive and kind!“