Mr. Bentley's Homemade Ice Cream

Name: Mr. Bentley's Homemade Ice Cream
Address: 1035 N Collier Blvd suite 308, Marco Island, Florida, 34145, US
Telephone: (239) 970-0608
Rating: 4.3

Ice Cream

Hours:
1035 N Collier Blvd suite 308, Marco Island
(239) 970-0608

Recent Reviews

4.3 (34)

Write a review

February 2024

Drove all the way from Sarasota to try the ice cream bc I read it is handcrafted and made without red and blue dye. What a treat! Jennifer and Val were simply delightful. They shared the history of the parlor and a bit about the local history. The ice cream was delicious! We sampled a few flavors before deciding on the lemon sorbet and Creamsicle. Both were awesome. The flavors change regularly but they have both staple flavors and unique twists. Although it is quite a ride for...read full review

December 2023

Read about this new ice cream shop in the Marco paper, and wanted to try it. Came here after driving on the island to do the annual Christmas light tour. The flavor selection is great, they have the standards and some unique selections. They don't make it here, but it is from Naples Ice Cream shop. Super good and creamy. We tried several flavors, and they were all very good. Cute and clean inside, not super cluttered. Service was excellent! Will definitely be back!

August 2023

Overall, wonderful experience. The icecream was very tasty, and probably the best I tried on the island. But what really stood out was the customer service. Susannah, the morning worker was very friendly, very helpful, and super welcoming.

More Reviews(34)