50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Siesta Key

“Everything about this place says "YES!" Our server was amazing, pizza was delicious, and the atmosphere was perfect. The bar was meant-to-be, and in the space shared with the Blase Cafe there is a stage with live music. Music phenomenal, beer menu vast. We were here on a weekend with lots of imbibing, but through the week and even before 7 p.m. or so on the weekend this would work for families as well. Highly recommend.Parking: Parking spaces are scarce. I highly recommend taking one of the many free trolley services and save yourself the hassle. They're clean, fun, and you get to meet a bunch of great people on the ride.“

“I came here based on reading the reviews and it's in a good location in downtown Siesta Key. I ordered the full Greek Salad which is very reasonably priced at $9. They didn't know if the dressing was gluten free so I didn't have it but otherwise the salad was delicious. My grandparents loved their salads as well. The staff is friendly, service is fast, and there is seating inside and outside.“

“We came to Sarasota for Mother’s Day weekend and coming here was simply the BEST way to end our weekend!! The food and the customer service from ALL the staff members amazing!!! everyone was so friendly, professional and accommodating and I wish I could give them 6 stars!! My kids won’t stop talking about it. For Mother’s Day they gave out complimentary wine or a dessert and Eric who was simply amazing also gave my kids a sweet treat, a very tasty cannoli. We are definitely coming back?!!!“

“Found this amazing pizza on Sunday while driving through Gulf Gate! Delicious, fresh ingredients and reasonably priced- go try it if you are looking for something more exciting than your average pizza!!“

“Stopped in for dinner. Amazing food and atmosphere staff are friendly great mid week deals, good price for high standard food. I cannot say enough about how enjoyable our dining experience was!“

“Went to Bavaro’s tonight for dinner and can’t say enough good things. The ambiance, the service was top notch, the chairs so comfortable and the food was absolutely delicious. Our server Steven (I hope that was his name) was beyond professional and I couldn’t ask for better. Prices are fair and the wine list is inviting. We started with the fire grilled broccolini which was cooked perfectly and absolutely delicious. Had a lovely super Tuscan with my penne with vodka sauce and shrimp. You could literally taste every delicious layer of flavor in this sauce. My boyfriend had the wild grilled salmon and we split the roasted broccolini for an appetizer. Completed with two home made delicious cannoli’s to go. The salmon but it was cooked perfectly and a huge piece of salmon (like 8oz) Will definitely be back and absolutely encourage anyone looking for real authentic Italian to check it out.“

“Great food and great service! Thank you Lizzie!“

“Great place if you are hungry and it is late or if you like to enjoy adult drinks. Reminds me of Applebees. The tuna tartar had a fishy flavor… the pretzel ? looks wonderful but very very bland. I would not come here again. Service friendly, bathrooms were clean. The pizza was fine.“

“? this place.. great service from Joseph our bartender.. absolutely yummy HH ? and appetizers were awesome ? will be definitely be visiting again soon ! ?‍♀️?“

“Best pizza in Sarasota hands down..will be getting again tomorrow with friends!“

“My husband found this place for us while we were vacationing in Sarasota. The food was incredible. My in laws got the lasagne, my husband got the Ragu, and I got the risotto special that had prosciutto and burrata. This was easily the best meal we had while in Sarasota. The service was great, and we really enjoyed the atmosphere. We were so full we couldn’t finish our meal, and we sadly did not have a microwave at our hotel! Thank you for a great experience and even better food!“

“OMG! Best pizza! Transcended expectations! Deeeee-Lish!!!!“

“The best PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD IN FL. Try it for yourself and then let me know.“

“We (my family) loved the meals we ate here recently- the availability of personal pizzas made sure all could be satisfied and explore whatever they wanted to taste. The mixed green salad was so fresh, cold and nicely dressed with a citrus vinaigrette! Liked that a chicken breast could be added for protein and that the sliced radishes, cucumbers and strawberries were artistically arranged and tasted wonderful... Our server, Cameron, was friendly, knowledgeable and made excellent suggestions. The setting was clean, cool and music was at a reasonable level. Staff members were kind and polite. Outside of restaurant was clean and parking more than adequate. Good experience!“

“Met one of the owners(son) at a bni event, rushed to get food before they closed to try it, his mom(owner) was super nice and we had a conversation while my food was being prepared. What an amazing little place, i can tell you the cuban sandwich was AMAZING, im always tasting cuban sandwiches and this one was definitely on the high score. Please support this amazing family and go try their food. I will become a regular. Batido de mamey? Absolutely ????. Gracias“

“Amazing wine, food and service!“

“Delicious Pizza!!! Delicious Wings!! Delicious Salads!! Delicious Blackened Shrimp!!“

“I miss ordering lunch from this place. I used to love getting the fat Italian sub. But their hours changed and they don't do lunch anymore. Get yourself a business partner and have them run the day shift! Build up that lunch business again. Your food is more than good enough to do so.“

“My wife & I visited Joseph's for the first time this evening and it was a great way to kick off Super Bowl weekend! We each enjoyed Caesar salad, Chicken Parmesan entrees and red wine. The food, beverages and service by Cara were excellent! We also took home two cannolis for dessert and they were fabulous! We will return soon with friends and neighbors and look forward to trying many more items on their great menu! Please be sure to visit Joseph's when you are in the Venice & Nokomis area, and you will be glad that you did.“

“Delicious food and great service at very reasonable prices! Their wings are the best in town, and the pizza is amazing too! Excellent selection of craft beers! Another thing that I really like is that they use environmentally friendly packaging. Thanks Origin!“

“great pizza, they take pride in their pizza!!!“

“Best wings ever! Dog friendly seating outside. Favorite pizza in Sarasota and a healthy roasted veggie salad“

“Great vegan pizza and regular cheese option for the kiddos! The cashew cheese was yummy! Also, don’t forget to try the fried artichoke app. And the espresso and tiramisu was excellent! We’ll be back for sure! Looking forward to trying it all!“

“I made reservations at the much further away Flavio’s on Siesta Key for a table of 11, such a silly mistake, I suggest you don’t do that-it’s stressful! Anyway, the staff at Flavios on Main quickly set us up and welcomed us. The service and food was impeccable! I was so impressed with how well they took care of us all. A huge thank you to the staff at Flavios on Main for the quick pivot. Menu was great, everyone was more than satisfied. They’re the best! ❤️“

“I love their pizza! Definitely one of my favorites in town and their cheesy breadsticks are awesome as well! Plus location is grand. You can get pizza and then ice cream right next door!“

“Our server Sam was the best! Great personality as with all your staff. The Bianca pizza is sooo delicious! We are Italian and from NJ. You are doing it right! Your entrees are also delicious! We will see you next Winter when we return. Linda & Tom Sellitto“

“Best pizza and Philly sub I’ve had so far in Sarasota“

“I’ve never had Brazilian style pizza before so was excited to try! We got the Portuguesa Especial and it was delicious. The toppings are unconventional, but the flavor is good, and the crust is crunchy. We ate inside and the place is really small but clean and cozy. The staff are very nice!“

“This place is incredible! I felt like I was in Italy as far as food and atmosphere goes. Hands down best pizza I’ve ever had and all the pasta is homemade. The place was full of Italians, true Italians which is always a good sign. Highly recommend!“

“We were looking for a good place to eat lunch. We found Mellow Mushroom, and it was way better than Mellow. It was extravagant. ? Never had better pizza before. We got the house special pizza, and mmmmmmm this was amazing. The style of the restaurant was unique, and the restaurant was very clean, even the bathrooms! Overall nothing bad to say. Straight gas?Kid-friendliness: ??“

“I had a great experience overall at Origin. They've got a great craft, beer selection, delicious appetizers, and the best wings that I've tasted so far in Sarasota. The place is a storefront and has some seating available outside, which starts creating a nice atmosphere before even entering. Inside, the place a good deal of personality. Kind of a small sports bar/pizzeria vibe. The staff is beyond friendly! Smiles and good energy with everyone we interacted with. The locals clearly love this place, which is a great sign. The meatballs appetizer is delicious. Tried the Warm Roasted Squash Salad, and while it's not what I'd gravitate towards, it was interesting to try. The wings were the best! Had their medium buffalo wings and man... their homemade buffalo sauce is unique and tasty! Will definitely come back for the wings. PS: if they offer you the PB&J craft beer... try it. Seriously. You'll be surprised how good it is. I took two to go .“

“Found this gem by accident on a little trip from St Petersburg to Fort Meyers. Wow! Yummy to the max! Great crust, very good sauce, excellent selection, friendly service. And don’t forget the desserts-wowza! Highly recommend! We will be back!“

“Great food and great service. Chef Joseph came out to greet us and talked to us about his special risotto preparation. It was nothing short of fantastic!“

“Great time with great friends.“

“Great service at the Drive thru or inside! The thin crust pizza is delicious and very reasonably priced! Great Caesar salad also!“

“Great food and great service!“

“Food was prepped quickly and was delicious. Grace was fantastic!“

“Great pizza, and excellent service“

“Wonderful atmosphere and wonderful service“

“Trying to find a good pizza in Florida is pretty hard work. Tonight I tried Salorzano's pizza and it was very delicious...from the thin but tasty crust to the sauce, cheese and toppings! Was just like New Jersey! I picked a great place tonight!“

“Our server Sam was the best! Great personality as with all your staff. The Bianca pizza is sooo delicious! We are Italian and from NJ. You are doing it right! Your entrees are also delicious! We will see you next Winter when we return. Linda & Tom Sellitto“

“I've been coming here for years and they never disappoint! Food is consistently really really on point and delightful. Priced fairly, the drinks are always good. The Sangria was exceptional! Fresh foccacia and olive oil is always delicious and not too heavy. Always very clean, big windows to the outside covered sidewalks and beautiful Palm Ave just add to the lovely ambiance.Kid-friendliness: It is an elegant more upscale restoration but definitely kid friendly. Nice meal choices for all.Wheelchair accessibility: All level, easy in and out. Plenty of room between tables.“

“Amazing! Delicious pizza, friendly staff, clean environment and out of this world cheesecake! will definitely return!“

“My family is never disappointed with the food or service!! My pizza is always hot, fresh and absolutely delicious. We adore the staff and the one time we had a mix up they were so quick to fix it. Don't always believe the negativety you see online about a place. THE KAREN is a growing pandemic. You can't treat people like crap and expect good service!! Well unless you are a Karen!! Be kind and tip well. This staff is worth it!!“

“Food was amazing. Highly recommend this place if you like wood fired crust and fresh ingredients.“

“Fantastic Italian food! Absolutely a must try!!!“

“Best Pizza ! Every Friday for 15 + years , great people , great food. , recommend to everyone ! YUM !“

“I can’t thank event coordinator Colleen enough for helping me organize our baseball team’s party! We had an amazing time today, it couldn’t have gone any better!! Our waitress Bo was also absolutely amazing!“

“Fresh herbs on wood fired pizza. So good! Alex (our waiter) went out of his way to ensure a stellar dining experience. A++++“

“The staff is amazing. We loved the atmosphere and the food was delicious!!“