Jersey Mike's Subs

1801 W Tennessee St #4, Tallahassee
(850) 765-0712

Recent Reviews

LaLa Handy

The open sign is on at 9:02 I walk in two people see me don't say anything but I walk and stand to order behind the guy who walked in before me for them to tell me that they're closed already

JamesS

I can't share my experience because they ain't nowhere near Tyndall!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

casey selecky

Ordered through door dash and got a call from dasher because Jersey mikes was saying they gave my food to someone already. We never got any food. Someone got on the from Jersey mikes acting like it my problem. I told him he needed to make sure they confirmed order before the dasher leaves. So they remade order but when got only half was there and we waited another 45 mins for food. So really slow service and don’t care about customers at all.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joshua Nicholson

Took 45 minutes for them to do 3 sandwiches. The guy on the hot grill was just screaming and yelling about hating his job. The entire time he burnt my sub. 2. It looks like a burned victim's face. Didn't listen to any of the options that we Wanted extra on the subs. Asked us 4 times if it was regular or giant. Didn't even get our receipt.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Austin Gross

Ordered online. I got a chicken Philly, added mushrooms for a 1.70 up charge. I did not get the mushrooms I paid for. Overall pretty good but when I request mushrooms for an additional charge, I expect them.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Steven Bunch

They make everything fresh as can be, which is good, but the guy forgot to print my ticket or whatever tf happened, and I waited 35 min or more, for a half a cheesesteak...and there was as much bread, if not more, than there was filling.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

C F

I spent $30 on two sandwiches via online order and both were wrong. I get there and still have to wait 30 minutes for my second sandwich because "the bread was being baked". My first sandwich had been sitting in the bag since I arrived. I get home, and nothing I asked for was on the sandwich. The meat was wrong and everything. I happened to see the grill cook making the second sandwich and asked him to remake it because it was also wrong. No one even care to look at any of the instructions left on the online order. This location gets every order wrong and I will not be returning. In general, do not go to any place that prepares food in this town unless you're willing to watch them make it. They will cut corners and are only there to get a paycheck. Please shut this location down or hire completely new staff. Trash.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dale Conley

Took at least 20 minutes to get sandwich. Asked for bread to be toasted but it wasn't. Someone came in after us and got their sandwich before us. Ours was left on grill too long and Philly cheese steak was overdone. Such a shame. Jersey Mike was our fav sandwich place. Not after this experience. ?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Grace Clark

I would give zero stars if I could. The people "slept in and didnt bake bread" and yet chose to keep their online ordering system open for people to order. I ordered about 6 sandwhiches for my office and we are still waiting 2 1/2 hours later for our order and cant even get someone to answer the phone at the location. Probably wont ever come here again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Gaitanis

Tried to eat here today, but the 2 employees didnt seem interested in taking our orders. Gave up and walked out after 10 minutes with no one in line in front or behind us and our order still hadn't been taken. Won't be back to this location.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rawwb Noles

Extremely poor customer service. I placed an order through Jersey Mike's app. There was an issue with the order. I spoke with the manager, Jarvis. I asked him to put the order again, he very abruptly responded with "We don't do that here." When I asked him for clarification, he responded with "As I said...". This type of behavior was very uncalled for and very unprofessional.

Service: 1

Jared G.

Food here is very good but the service is terrible. I was the only one on the restaurant with 4 people working behind the counter but I waited almost 20 minutes to get my sandwich. They sliced the meat then proceeded to have a conversation with my half made sandwich just sitting there. Then some person came in screaming profane language, proceeded to cut me in line, and get their food before me. Definitely do not come here if you are in a rush. Not the first time this has happened either.

Luke Skonieczny

I went to this Jersey Mike's location 10/25/2023 and everyone was so helpful and nice to talk to! Specifically Aiyanna and Kyorn were so awesome and helpedme immensely, and I can't recommend this location enough for great service and subs!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 8 Club Sub Regular

Optropic

Always busy but worth the wait!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Glenda Howard

I have been to the location numerous time and the food has always been pretty good. I just pick up a Philly steak and it wasn’t edible. Apparently the grill needed to be cleaned because it had burnt pieces all in my sandwich and made my whole sandwich taste burnt. I paid almost $12 for a sandwich I couldn’t even eat, very disappointed.

Food: 1

Service: 3

Load More