Buttermilk Bakery

1198 N Orange Ave, Winter Park
(321) 422-4015

Recent Reviews

Kristen Blackford

This has quickly become one of our favorite places to go for baked goods!! Everything is made fresh daily. We’ve gotten a pretty good range of the sweet and the savory items on the menu now, and haven’t been disappointed yet!There is a small sitting area out front and off to the side of the building (which you can only access from the back parking lot- so you have to walk to the front to order, and walk back around to get to the side seating, which is also where the pick up window is.)If you do order to stay, you can ask them to heat anything up and they’ll bring it to you!Would be great if there was more parking! And I’ve never seen a bathroom, although I haven’t asked.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Pastries, Croissants, Bakery, Daily Pastries

Asmaa Elkorazati

Thir pastries are to die for and is worth the drive! They offer savoury and sweet pastries, which are both equally delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Pastries, Croissants, Daily Pastries

Jeanine E.

Was really craving pastries for breakfast so we came by over the weekend, not too busy when we had stopped by for a Saturday at 11 thankfully. The place is quaint- with limited space. There is no indoor seating so definitely not an option on bad weather days which is a shame. They do have an outdoor patio with wooden tables and chairs that have some shading from a tarp above (doesn't cover every table). With it being tight inside, there's really only enough space for 3 people inside at a time. The pastries are as good as they look... they were delicious and just what I was looking for! Perfectly crumbly croissant with beautiful layers. Definitely cannot wait to try more! The passion fruit tea was also pretty good, just be aware there is no sweetener added so it can be pretty pungent! There is no espresso, only drip coffee and cold brew so couldn't get a cappuccino or latte which was a bummer. The service was spot on for the type of establishment, they were taking orders quickly while also not rushing us as there's a lot of choices, and were very thorough with our orders and giving us a generous amount of napkins and utensils. FYI There is a parking lot in the back for customers and the entrance to the outdoor seating area is through the parking behind the building.

Surina Samaroo

One of my go to spots for pastries! I always get the savory ones and they never disappoint. Get there early because this is a popular place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Willa Reed

Great place, lots of goodies to choose from. Just be patient trying to find parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Pastries, Croissants, Bakery, Daily Pastries

Cesca T.

This is place is very intimate, and was quite bustling on the morning we swung by to grab some pastries. But it is truly worth the long wait in line, and the cramped quarters! Everything we tried was fantastic, and the pastries and baked goods they are making are quite intricate, not so easy to find elsewhere. And certainly not this expertly crafted. I was truly impressed. But beyond impression, everything we tried just tasted delicious! Rich, decadent, yet light, and airy. That guava poptart is the stuff pastry dreams are made of! Lovely, hip, and excellent pastry.

Echo L.

Pastry of the year, period. They are so specialised in their croissant making, and every single pastry item we tried is not disappointed. The pastries are made to perfect with flaky texture outside and chewy texture inside. The plain croissant tastes just as great even on the day after our purchase. Our favorite is the sun dried tomato with cheese. The savory filling very well mixed and combined with pastry texture very well. There is no indoor seats. Service is fast. Will come again and even make a trip to have these amazing pastries!

Gabriella V.

Absolutely amazing. I usually hate savory breakfast foods but I had a ham and cheese croissant and it was absolutely amazing. I also had a lemon lavender poptart and a monkey bread croissant so amazing. Some of the best baked good I have had in years. It was crazy fast and you can actually watch them bake everything as you order. Super great and really cute outdoor area.

Kai Kai T.

Unusual flavors croissants, and you won't be disappointed. Must try the sun-dried tomatoes provolone and everything croissants.

Nick V.

Line can get very long and it's hot inside. But damn: it's delicious! We go get coffee down the street tho as the specialty here is baking not beans.

Jenny Minutillo

It's a pick up and go place. We got two pastries right as they open around 8am; one savory and one sweet. Both were excellent and oh so flaky ...and I was having a hard time choosing ?. But, I know it doesn't matter what you get, they'll all be perfection. Can't wait to go back and get EVERYTHING ?!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Pastries, Croissants, Bakery

Sheila E.

Yum yum yum, this muffin was so good I came back another day. Also not featured in this photo-Ginger Lime Scone, out of this world-must try if you like citrus glaze.

Ashley P.

Tried Buttermilk for the first time today and I loved everything we tried. Both my partner and mom adored everything and I can't wait to try more the next time we plan to visit. The staff was so kind and I'm so glad we finally go to try this beautiful place! The outdoor seating was a fun touch as well.

Miranda R.

Wow wow wow! I stopped by because of a pop up market I saw on social media, so I really went in with no expectations but was absolutely floored! They have such an array of both sweet and savory pastries, it was hard to choose. We went with an everything bagel croissant, which came as a square with the most perfect spot of egg in the middle, the caramelized onion, beer cheese, and bacon croissant bake which was a little loaf of croissant pieces melded together with these rich flavors (definitely our favorite), and for a sweet ending we tried the chocolate covered strawberry donut with had the best crispy fried edges! Inside is small, just big enough to order, but they have a sizable patio with tables and chairs along the side. Parking is either free street parking, or there are some lots around the back of the businesses along the block. Definitely this place a try! At 12 on a Sunday they still had lots and lots of pastries, which isn't always the case with people waking up earlier for weekend plans.

Debbie Solorzano

I really enjoyed my pastry and the line was out the door. The only problem I had was that the quiche I was given was raw. I was so excited I took a bit out of it, only to realize the egg and bacon were not fully cooked. I was disappointed because there was no instructions to preheat and I am pregnant with twins so consuming raw stuff is concerning to me even if it was just a bite. I put the quiche in the oven after my bite and then it tasted delicious after and fully cooked after. I tried to call but couldn’t reach anyone. I know they get really busy but I still think be mindful when packaging so quickly what your putting in the plastic containers.Other than that thou the pastries I got were very tasty

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Pastries, Croissants, Bakery

Load More