I Love NY Pizza

$ • Italian, Pizza, Pasta Shops

980 Birmingham Rd, Alpharetta
(770) 442-9699


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for I Love NY Pizza

I've been going to I NY Pizza since he owned the Birmingham location! I followed him to this new location when I heard it was him since the pizza at the Birmingham location is lacking! Now honestly the pizza is not what it used to be which is very upsetting. My meatball pizza had like 3 meatballs on it as an XL. Will give it another chance but not impressed recently!

Placed an order through Grubhub for some ziti and garlic knots. Garlic knots come in an order of three. This is what was delivered to my house. At first I thought maybe the GrubHub driver ate the rolls, but you can see that there was only 1 roll placed in the box because of lack of oil stains. Never again.

This place is exhausting. They just cannot ever get it right, and this most recent fiasco will be the last. Used the Grubhub app to place a future delivery order for 7pm. The app confirmed a delivery would be made from 7-710pm. 715 rolls around and I call the restaurant. Supposedly the driver tried to deliver my food at 615 but no one was home.. well, there's a reason for that which would be the same reason I wanted it at 7pm! Soooo, the restaurant says they will remake...read full review

More Reviews(98)


Monday 10AM - 9:30PM
Tuesday 10AM - 9:30PM
Wednesday 10AM - 9:30PM
Thursday 10AM - 9:30PM
Friday 10AM - 9:30PM
Saturday 10AM - 9:30PM
Sunday 10AM - 9:30PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.