Pizza Restaurants near Earlham

“What a nice find in a small town. I love these local places that server good food and have great staff working. Our food came out fast hot and most importantly, TASTY! Other members of my party had the recommended pork tenderloin and they all said how good it was. I had the Philly steak sandwich, I was very happy I did. Great bun and flavor from that sandwich and the whole meal/experience left me happy to leave an extra large tip. It seemed after 6 it got louder and made it harder to have a conversation. If you stop in earlier you will have a quite experience. If you stop in later in the evening it seems you will have a party like atmosphere. It's nice that you can get both in the same place.“

“We stopped in the evening of 3/17. We got a large sausage, mushrooms and onion pizza with a side of garlic cheese bread. Hands down the best pizza I've had! The staff was very helpful and positive. Large pizza and cheese bread,softdrinks was under $30. We will go back.“

“Had a wonderful experience at 1738 Casey's in Adel on October 17th,2022. I ordered pizzas 3 hours ahead of time. Got to the store right as they pulled them out (note: time requested). Had a few other items on the counter for the register that was workin. She was so patient and kind with me as I went to grab my pipping hot delicious pizzas. When I got back to her counter I checked the pizzas. I asked her about more marina sauce cups for my bread sticks and she was more then happy to get me more. Great job!!“

“Had a visit to this location recently. Clean, fast service and very friendly staff. I ordered some (seemingly new on the menu) chicken wings. They looked great and the texture was great. Only disappointment was that they were very salty and overpoweringly sweet at the same time. Might be a fault from the supplier.“