As an Italian who has lived all over the country, Tony's has the best pizza I've ever eaten!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
erin gilbert
Phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smoked Pork Loin E Arugula, House Made Rosemary Focaccia
Corey B.
I recently dined at this fantastic establishment, and it exceeded all expectations. The ambiance is inviting, with a cozy yet modern vibe that sets the perfect tone for a delightful meal. The service was impeccable, with attentive and friendly staff making the experience truly enjoyable. Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza. Each bite was a flavor explosion, from the perfectly crispy crust to the mouthwatering toppings. A definite 5-star experience that leaves me eager to return for more
Trish G.
Pros: Service was good, pizza was tasty and fresh. restaurant was clean and had a lovely ambiance cons: the salad was sparse and took a long time to get to us. The pizza took FOREVER. The restaurant was half full. We got in and immediately ordered, I looked at the menu online. It took over 45 mins for the pizza to even get in the oven. We watched as the owner waited until all the orders were in from the other tables and THEN he put our pizza in. People who came in 50 minutes after us got their pizza at the same time we did. So while I liked the pizza, I won't be going back unless I have 2 hours to kill and I would never order the salad again.
Keith M.
Tony makes real pizza. If you grew-up in NJ or NY, you know what I mean. He never disappoints. It is a small place; max party size is 4. Tony prepares everything, so go when you are not in a hurry.
Scott B.
Fabulous pizza AND atmosphere. The pizza is ridiculously simple and enjoyable. Don't over do it with toppings, just keep it simple. Get a bottle of wine and take home what you don't finish. Go with a small group. Tony's is a valuable institution and is basically a one man show with Tony working the oven and an assistant in the front. It's like eating at your Italian Uncle's house. Love it and can't wait to get back there.
Kevin B.
Quaint little Italian pizzaria. Wife and I ordered the standard margherita with pepperoni. Boy was it good! Thin, but not to thin crust. Crispy yet not tough. Full of flavor, not drenched in marinara. Priced very well. Expect a small wait as seating is somewhat limited. If you like authentic pizza pies, this is the place. You won't regret it.
Alex S.
I went to school in New Jersey and this is the best pizza I have had since moving to Idaho. Tony is the man. The inside is a nice quaint atmosphere perfect for people who take pizza seriously.
Chantel Reamey
Incredible all around! My fav local pizza, authentic!
Becky G.
I enjoyed a solo date with a delicious Margherita pizza and a glass of wine. Service was amazing!
This is the best pizza in the Treasure Valley in my opinion, and I've had most of it.
Ashley Letson
Pizza was the best we’ve had. The service was phenomenal. Can’t wait to come back!
Deanna L.
NO! DO NOT SUPPORT THIS ESTABLISHMENT We arrived as a family of 5 to be told that we WOULD NOT be seated because they only seat parties of 4 or less. We asked if we could divide up and sit at two separate tables and were told splitting is NOT allowed and that they only have 1 Chef. We asked how that would work if we had been two different families arriving at the same time, and were met with rudeness and emphatic NO, sorry you cannot eat here. SAD. DO BETTER!
Chad L.
Would give zero stars if I could. Showed up. Place is empty. One table sitting. We are 5 and there are 4 open tables inside and 4 outside. They say we only do parties of 4. We said we don't mind and we would be happy to sit apart and be a party of 3 and separately a party of 2. "No we won't do that." Ok so if we weren't together and yet arrived at the same time as two people and then three you wouldn't refuse them service right? " Well that's not the case. Ok so you are refusing to seat us. Yes. The owner was staring at us from the kitchen. Sorry. You deserve the crap review and you sure as hell won't see me ever again.
Paula Creed
The pizza was delicious, the crust perfectly cooked. Our server was very sweet and it wasn’t too busy when we went, so the food came out really quickly. Highly recommend.
As an Italian who has lived all over the country, Tony's has the best pizza I've ever eaten!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smoked Pork Loin E Arugula, House Made Rosemary Focaccia
I recently dined at this fantastic establishment, and it exceeded all expectations. The ambiance is inviting, with a cozy yet modern vibe that sets the perfect tone for a delightful meal. The service was impeccable, with attentive and friendly staff making the experience truly enjoyable. Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza. Each bite was a flavor explosion, from the perfectly crispy crust to the mouthwatering toppings. A definite 5-star experience that leaves me eager to return for more
Pros: Service was good, pizza was tasty and fresh. restaurant was clean and had a lovely ambiance cons: the salad was sparse and took a long time to get to us. The pizza took FOREVER. The restaurant was half full. We got in and immediately ordered, I looked at the menu online. It took over 45 mins for the pizza to even get in the oven. We watched as the owner waited until all the orders were in from the other tables and THEN he put our pizza in. People who came in 50 minutes after us got their pizza at the same time we did. So while I liked the pizza, I won't be going back unless I have 2 hours to kill and I would never order the salad again.
Tony makes real pizza. If you grew-up in NJ or NY, you know what I mean. He never disappoints. It is a small place; max party size is 4. Tony prepares everything, so go when you are not in a hurry.
Fabulous pizza AND atmosphere. The pizza is ridiculously simple and enjoyable. Don't over do it with toppings, just keep it simple. Get a bottle of wine and take home what you don't finish. Go with a small group. Tony's is a valuable institution and is basically a one man show with Tony working the oven and an assistant in the front. It's like eating at your Italian Uncle's house. Love it and can't wait to get back there.
Quaint little Italian pizzaria. Wife and I ordered the standard margherita with pepperoni. Boy was it good! Thin, but not to thin crust. Crispy yet not tough. Full of flavor, not drenched in marinara. Priced very well. Expect a small wait as seating is somewhat limited. If you like authentic pizza pies, this is the place. You won't regret it.
I went to school in New Jersey and this is the best pizza I have had since moving to Idaho. Tony is the man. The inside is a nice quaint atmosphere perfect for people who take pizza seriously.
Incredible all around! My fav local pizza, authentic!
I enjoyed a solo date with a delicious Margherita pizza and a glass of wine. Service was amazing!
Restaurantji Recommends
This is the best pizza in the Treasure Valley in my opinion, and I've had most of it.
Pizza was the best we’ve had. The service was phenomenal. Can’t wait to come back!
NO! DO NOT SUPPORT THIS ESTABLISHMENT We arrived as a family of 5 to be told that we WOULD NOT be seated because they only seat parties of 4 or less. We asked if we could divide up and sit at two separate tables and were told splitting is NOT allowed and that they only have 1 Chef. We asked how that would work if we had been two different families arriving at the same time, and were met with rudeness and emphatic NO, sorry you cannot eat here. SAD. DO BETTER!
Would give zero stars if I could. Showed up. Place is empty. One table sitting. We are 5 and there are 4 open tables inside and 4 outside. They say we only do parties of 4. We said we don't mind and we would be happy to sit apart and be a party of 3 and separately a party of 2. "No we won't do that." Ok so if we weren't together and yet arrived at the same time as two people and then three you wouldn't refuse them service right? " Well that's not the case. Ok so you are refusing to seat us. Yes. The owner was staring at us from the kitchen. Sorry. You deserve the crap review and you sure as hell won't see me ever again.
The pizza was delicious, the crust perfectly cooked. Our server was very sweet and it wasn’t too busy when we went, so the food came out really quickly. Highly recommend.