Can’t believe I haven’t tried them until now! My family and I tried a little of everything and we loved everything we tried! Taco salad was huge and delicious and fresh. The pizza was super tasty, the Italian sub sandwich was to die for. The staff was super friendly and helpful 10/10 recommend!!
Jim H.
if I could do 0 stars I wold very rude and unprofessional foods not that grate but what can I say if the service sucks it makes it not as good to eat there
juan Lopez
Good food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub, Italian Combo
matt queen
Danny, the owner, makes everyone feel like family. Food is always good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Turkey Supreme, Turkey blt
Daniel stephens
Always a hit, been a fan for many
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub, Garlic Cheese Bread, Spicy Fries Ham and Cheese Sub Southwest Chipotle Steak Sub, Italian Salad, Garlic, Italian Combo
Spring Tea
Awful experience here this evening. Ordered two simple sandwiches and one cheese pizza. We waited for over 30 minutes, then checked on our order. No one was making our order or it got lost among the 3 young employees working. We were the only people sitting at a table in the restaurant and the employees could clearly see we didn’t have our food yet. They were all just standing around. The employees were rude when we asked them if they could see we didn’t have our order.We already had paid for our food, so it took us an hour to wait for food we never got and then another 15 minutes for the young employees to figure out how to refund our money.Absolutely disappointed with the terrible service, kids who have no work ethic or customer service conscience.We usually love this place, but don’t think I’ll ever come back.
Shara Lyman
I was so disappointed. I have heard so many times how papa Kelsey's is the best pizza in town so tonight I finally tried it. I should have taken a hint when the place was almost completely deserted on a Saturday night right at 6pm but I wanted to try. The building was absolutely freezing. My pizza was completely cold in the middle right as they took it out of the oven. There was no flavor whatsoever. They put the toppings under the cheese which made everything fall right off the bread. I would honestly get little Cesar's pizza or a frozen pizza from the store before coming back here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jeff H
The food is always good. Been goinghere since I was a kid. The turkey supreme is proba ly the best sandwich ever. My go to is the french dip. Mmmmmm.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Turkey Supreme
Derek Cox
Went to Papa Kelseys before the midnight madness parade.. and I have to say that the crew was on point!!! The place was insane busy, but everyone was calm, cool, collected. It was clear that everyone had a job to do and they each did their part perfectly! We didnt have to wait long to order, and our order was perfect, and came out alot quicker than we anticipated! Kuddos the the entire crew, and a great job being prepared for a big rush!!
Eric Mccly
So this is my first time here. This place was pretty cold inside. And it was pretty cold outside too. I think their heater was broken. Not sure?But I decided to sit down and eat.It took a fair time to cook.The server brought me my pizza. My pizza was kind of cold, but it was good.The price was okay.Maybe it came at the wrong time. But it did the job.
Really yummy subs that melt in your mouth and are so warm, perfect for rainy days! Occasionally extremely busy, typically around lunchtime. When that’s the case food takes forever to come out, so I usually try and go during the slower hours which even then it usually takes awhile. Prices are decent, just under $10 for a 6in sub, chips, and drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kevin Hultzapple
Got food to go, and it was OK. Not necessarily as good as a friend hyphed it up to be. But maybe it was just a one off time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Linda Bate
Always love their sandwiches here. Workers are friendly & never rush you to order. Keep up the good work!
Nice little hole-in-the-wall place. We stopped by on our way out of town. My wife had been there as a kid and wanted to relive memories and see if their mushroom pineapple sandwich still held up - it did. I had the Turkey BLT. The turkey was tender and delicious, the bread soft with a crispy grill char on it, and the combination of ingredients were great. We had an enjoyable meal before heading home on the road. We will probably return, when we are in the neighborhood again.
Can’t believe I haven’t tried them until now! My family and I tried a little of everything and we loved everything we tried! Taco salad was huge and delicious and fresh. The pizza was super tasty, the Italian sub sandwich was to die for. The staff was super friendly and helpful 10/10 recommend!!
if I could do 0 stars I wold very rude and unprofessional foods not that grate but what can I say if the service sucks it makes it not as good to eat there
Good food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub, Italian Combo
Danny, the owner, makes everyone feel like family. Food is always good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Turkey Supreme, Turkey blt
Always a hit, been a fan for many
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub, Garlic Cheese Bread, Spicy Fries Ham and Cheese Sub Southwest Chipotle Steak Sub, Italian Salad, Garlic, Italian Combo
Awful experience here this evening. Ordered two simple sandwiches and one cheese pizza. We waited for over 30 minutes, then checked on our order. No one was making our order or it got lost among the 3 young employees working. We were the only people sitting at a table in the restaurant and the employees could clearly see we didn’t have our food yet. They were all just standing around. The employees were rude when we asked them if they could see we didn’t have our order.We already had paid for our food, so it took us an hour to wait for food we never got and then another 15 minutes for the young employees to figure out how to refund our money.Absolutely disappointed with the terrible service, kids who have no work ethic or customer service conscience.We usually love this place, but don’t think I’ll ever come back.
I was so disappointed. I have heard so many times how papa Kelsey's is the best pizza in town so tonight I finally tried it. I should have taken a hint when the place was almost completely deserted on a Saturday night right at 6pm but I wanted to try. The building was absolutely freezing. My pizza was completely cold in the middle right as they took it out of the oven. There was no flavor whatsoever. They put the toppings under the cheese which made everything fall right off the bread. I would honestly get little Cesar's pizza or a frozen pizza from the store before coming back here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
The food is always good. Been goinghere since I was a kid. The turkey supreme is proba ly the best sandwich ever. My go to is the french dip. Mmmmmm.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Turkey Supreme
Went to Papa Kelseys before the midnight madness parade.. and I have to say that the crew was on point!!! The place was insane busy, but everyone was calm, cool, collected. It was clear that everyone had a job to do and they each did their part perfectly! We didnt have to wait long to order, and our order was perfect, and came out alot quicker than we anticipated! Kuddos the the entire crew, and a great job being prepared for a big rush!!
So this is my first time here. This place was pretty cold inside. And it was pretty cold outside too. I think their heater was broken. Not sure?But I decided to sit down and eat.It took a fair time to cook.The server brought me my pizza. My pizza was kind of cold, but it was good.The price was okay.Maybe it came at the wrong time. But it did the job.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
We got a to go order. My family loves these subs!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Chip, Garlic Cheese Bread, Turkey blt, Roast Beef, French Dip, Steak
Really yummy subs that melt in your mouth and are so warm, perfect for rainy days! Occasionally extremely busy, typically around lunchtime. When that’s the case food takes forever to come out, so I usually try and go during the slower hours which even then it usually takes awhile. Prices are decent, just under $10 for a 6in sub, chips, and drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Got food to go, and it was OK. Not necessarily as good as a friend hyphed it up to be. But maybe it was just a one off time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Always love their sandwiches here. Workers are friendly & never rush you to order. Keep up the good work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Garlic Cheese Bread, Turkey blt, Roast Beef, French Dip
Nice little hole-in-the-wall place. We stopped by on our way out of town. My wife had been there as a kid and wanted to relive memories and see if their mushroom pineapple sandwich still held up - it did. I had the Turkey BLT. The turkey was tender and delicious, the bread soft with a crispy grill char on it, and the combination of ingredients were great. We had an enjoyable meal before heading home on the road. We will probably return, when we are in the neighborhood again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Turkey blt