Wiseguy Pizza Pie
$ • Pizza, ItalianAbout Wiseguy Pizza Pie
Customers' Favorites
Slice of Pizza by the Slice
Margarita Guy Pizza
Large Garlic Knots
Pizza Was Great
Pepperoni Pizza
Wise Guy Pizza
Italian Hoagie
Side Pepperoni
Buffalo Wings
Caesar Salad
Wiseguy Pizza Pie Reviews
185 ratings
Share your opinion about Wiseguy Pizza Pie
I usually get my Calzone from Hailey Wise Guy and it’s the best. Unfortunately can’t say that about Ketchum Wise Guy. Crust was so hard it was difficult to chew, hardly any olives inside and overall tasteless. These 2 restaurants must not be affiliated with each other. I’ll Never will go back to Ketchum.
great place, great people
The Metro Guy pizza was seriously impressive. The dough is thin, crispy, and has the perfect amount of crunch. The lemon adds this bright, fresh element that really brings everything together, while the chicken has a subtle sweet heat that keeps you coming back for another bite.
It’s a creative take on flavors we all know, but put together in a way that feels completely fresh. Definitely worth ordering if you’re at Wiseguy Pizza Pie in Ketchum!
It’s a creative take on flavors we all know, but put together in a way that feels completely fresh. Definitely worth ordering if you’re at Wiseguy Pizza Pie in Ketchum!
Hours
| Monday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11:30AM - 9PM |
Wiseguy Pizza Pie offers a cozy atmosphere reminiscent of a college pizza joint, making it a nice little pizza shop to visit. The staff is friendly and helpful, providing efficient service, and the menu features a variety of pizza options, including the ability to create your own combination. Pizzas have a cheesy char and a crispy crust, with some customers praising the fresh, thin dough that is not greasy at all. However, some reviewers noted that the tomato sauce could be less sweet and the dough more umami. The restaurant also serves a nice meatball sub and has received positive feedback for the White Trash Guy pizza, which includes potato chips for an excellent crunch. With a casual vibe, Wiseguy Pizza Pie is a great spot for a meal, offering some seating outside that appears to be shared with the KB's Ketchum Burrito place. There is a heavy pour of wine and beer on tap to enjoy with the food. Customers have praised the quality of the pizza, including the Margarita Guy Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza, as well as the delicious garlic knots and buffalo wings. Some options like the Metro Guy pizza have received mixed reviews, with suggestions for more seasoning, but overall the restaurant captures the big-city pizzeria feels at an affordable price in Ketchum.