Pizza Restaurants near Middlebury

Danny's Diner Pizza • $
422 S Main St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

8 Italian Grinder with Chips and a Pickle
Breadsticks with Marinara
Homemade Bread Sticks
Order of Bread Sticks
Large Supreme Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Garlic Cheese Bread
Homemade Ice Cream
Pepperoni Calzone

“We had family who had pizza from here that they liked. We decided to try this restaurant and are so happy that we did!We each had a whole Italian grinder, but we could only eat half. Danny's makes their own bread, and the sandwich was delicious. We recommend Danny's!!“

4.4 Superb76 Reviews
Piccadilly Circus Pizza Pizza •
901 S Main St, Middlebury

“I stopped in on Saturday looking for a bite. This place is on the main drag and easy to find. I stopped because it looked to be the only thing open and I needed some lunch. I really wanted something green after eating on the heavy side for a few days. I ended up getting a chef's salad which fit the need. The spot is a little run down and could use some sprucing up, but the staff is very friendly and helpful. What will definitely make me come back was watching them make pizzas. They looked so dang good, I almost ordered one on the spot.. but decided to come back another time. The pizzas look to be crusty and cheesy, so can't wait to try them too!“

4.3 Superb7 Reviews
Rulli's Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
851 US-20, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Bread Dipping Oil and Spices
Pizza and Garlic Bread
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicken Parmigiano
Chicken Wings
Supreme Pizza
Deluxe Pizza
Garden Salad
Baked Ziti

“Great Family owned restaurant. Great food, friendly staff and atmosphere. Serving the Middlebury community for 35 years.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pasta and pizza doughParking: Parking lot in front of restaurant...extra parking side lot.Kid-friendliness: They like kids! Kids menu selection“

3.3 Good67 Reviews
Pizza Depot Pizza • $$
129 Orpha Dr D, Middlebury

“First time ordering. Ordered 2 pizzas and were ready on time. Nothing special about food. Mac and cheese pizza was OK. I personally did not care for sausage on 2nd pizza. Pizzas slightly undercooked in our opinion. More toppings and cheese needed. Better options in Middlebury for pizza based on this first try.“

3.3 Good8 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
500 Spg Vly Rd, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza

“Awesome friendly staff, I between Middlebury, Ligonier, and Lagrange pizza hut's Middlebury is the most consistent in quality to me. Haven't gotten one uneven pizza where there are gaps of missing cheese or toppings missing. In my experience.“

2.9 Average20 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza •
104 US-20, Middlebury
0 Na0 Reviews
Venturi Pizza • $
123 E Lincoln Ave, Goshen

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto and Fresh Mozzarella Pizza
Truffle White Pizza
Garlic Flatbread
Pizza Margherita
Pepperoni Pizza
Seasonal Salad
Margherita Doc
Truffle Pizza
Fennel Salad
Nutella Pizza

“Wow!Simply put, the best pizza I had in the US.For my money, it beats any NY style pizza any day.My only disappointment, so to speak, was the tiramisu: it's really good, but I kind of wish it was just a traditional tiramisu. Alas, it is still well worth time and money.“

4.5 Superb91 Reviews
East of Chicago Pizza Pizza • $
350 S Van Buren St # C, Shipshewana

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chocolate Cake
Topping Pizza
Taco Pizza
Pan Pizza
Sausage

“Awesome place in a small town. They offered a buffet and since we were a group of 10 we chose that. They even let us put tables together so we could visit. Staff checked on how we were doing a couple of times. The food was hot and fresh. They kept the buffet well supplied. We will go again.“

4.3 Superb66 Reviews
Shipshe Pizza & Mini-Golf, Inc. Pizza • $
145 E North Village Dr, Shipshewana

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks
Garlic Loaf
Meat Hoagie
Extra Sauce
Traditional
Cookie

“I'm so glad this place has stayed afloat with so many owner changes in the past several years. The new owners have done a lot to improve the place, including the mini golf course, and I really hope to see the course finally repaired as it was a childhood favorite to play on. Outside of the mini golf, the food here is really good. They have a great selection of sub sandwiches and pizza. Both reasonably priced and very good. I also got to try the buffet that they are testing out last week and absolutely loved it and I hope they keep it around. I'm excited to keep seeing improvements and happy to have another good pizza place around!“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Samuel Mancino's Italian Pizza • $
68674 US-131, White Pigeon

Customers` Favorites

The Club Grinder
Garlic Bread
Garden Salad
Breadsticks
Grinders

“Missy and her staff are absolutely wonderful! Hands down- the best food & customer service I have experienced from any food establishment in a very long time. The food was exactly as it was ordered and arrived at our table HOT!!I have also placed large pizza orders for my employee lunches. Again, excellent customer service. Everything was ready on time & staff helped carry pizzas out to my truck. I have never such outstanding service anywhere else. We will definitely keep coming back.“

3.8 Good43 Reviews
Loading...
map Map