Restaurants in New Castle

“What an experience! Friendly, welcoming, and warm are a few adjectives I would use. Jesus’ light shines through them and the food is great. When I go back I will ask for sauce on the side because I like to dip my ribs in sauce. Great place to have a beautiful experience!?”

“We like the food here,just wish they would post the specials on Facebook earlier.”

“Inga and the ladies at Temptations are great—they provide fast service, and the food is always fantastic. This is home cooking at a restaurant.”

“We go here all the time. The food is always 🔥. we always get a 16" royal feast with o mushroom or onion Apparently they didn't hear the onions part tonight but the manager( i think she said her name was Carol)was awesome and asked if I wanted a small discount or said she would remake it. I said it was all good and gave her a better tip lol. its fricking 🔥 🔥 😆”

“Best Chinese food not only in town, but anywhere. Family owned and operated. Lovely people. Prices are unmatched and portion sizes are great. If you like Chinese food, do yourself a favor and eat from here!”

“Great selection. We had a great time!”

“Went here with a group of friends and had one of those nights you talk about for years. The food was absolutely top notch — seriously, do not skip the fish sandwich, it was next-level OMG! The vibe was fun, welcoming, and energetic without feeling chaotic. I felt accepted. Karaoke took the night to another level with the competition, and had everyone laughing, singing, and just having a blast. You can tell the staff and owners truly take pride in this place — the service was great, the atmosphere felt intentional, and it honestly felt like they wanted everyone there to have a good time. From the food to the music to the people, everything just clicked. We’ll never forget the night we had and will 100% be back.”

“I love the location and the inside, beautiful atmosphere with great people”

“Pulled pork nachos were an excellent recommendation!!!”

“Love this place!!!! Everybody was super friendly, the owners, the bartenders, and the regulars were all absolutely amazing! We had the best time and can’t wait to come back to town and visit again! Cold cheep beer and everything you want in a dive bar!”

“Very cool building with an open air relaxed vibe. Solid beer menue, and my burger was terrific, perfectly balanced. Our server at the bar Carly knocked it out of the park. We will be back.”

“This was some of the best Mexican food I've ever had. Everything was made to order and only took 10 minutes. The quesabirria quesadilla was cooked perfectly and the meat was tender and full of flavor. The chips were crisp and the queso was delicious. The horchata was the perfect consistency and was a great balance between sweet and spiced. I would 100% recommend if you want authentic Mexican food.”

“Great prices and great food and service... staff are amazing people”

“Friendly staff, Good food, Fun place to hangout, Very clean.”

“Real Authentic mexicain!! Delicious flavours. Highly recommend!!”

“We love visiting The Press. The Carrot Cake Latte was AMAZING!🥕☕️ Can’t wait to try your other seasonal drinks!”

“Great place for my group to meet and eat. Great food and quick service. This was our breakfast tray for the 8 of us.”

“We rented the building connected to the ice cream that they rent. with package 3for a birthday party for my twins and it was so amazing! Very easy to work with very clean! They came and checked on us made sure we had everything we needed. Was a wonderful experience highly recommend if your looking for a meeting room or a place to throw a birthday party. 🥳”

“Summit Lake Market is such a loving place! Everyone is beyond friendly and have hearts for the Lord. Would highly recommend stopping in and getting a tasty treat.”

“Best Mexican food, excellent service”

“Great tasting Chicken & cole slaw”

“BEST APPLE CIDER DONUTS EVER.
on an out of state trip and looking to kill time, we drove an hour out to this apple orchard. it’s much smaller than the one i normally go to, but much cozier (i loved that they had a fire going). i don’t have children, but the play area seemed huge and like a wonderful place to bring your kids. we only came for the donuts, but everything inside looked AMAZING, and for a really good price. We didn’t do them, but i’m aware they also have lots of fun activities! now the donuts! our apple orchard is kinda “to die for” when it comes to the donuts, my family would betray each other for a bite. but THESE donuts have put edwards apple orchard to shame. i’ve never had an apple cider donut so good, im mad i didn’t get more, and i’ll be awaiting the day im back in indy during the season. and might i mention it was only $6 for a 1/2 dozen? im so glad we went to check this place out.”

“I hope the Management Team reads this… I have been beyond impressed with the staff at the New Castle Culver’s. It is evident Management has taken a great deal of time training the staff to be customer friendly. When ordering staff guide you to choices. As many of us hesitate in making choices the response is “we want you to be happy and please take your time”. Food delivery is prompt. As we leave we always get a positive comment like “have a great day” or “ thank you for visiting us”. What is most impressive is these are often young adults who are learning customer service which is being reinforced obviously by the owners and Management Team. I might also add the environment is spotless. We don’t go to Culver’s often but when we do I leave smiling. BTW the grand babies LOVE the ice cream with the kids meals.”

“Booked the restaurant for a party. Everything was set up and food was prepared as ordered and delicious. 80 people served. Had a great experience. Highly recommend for get togethers. Husband and I have returned several times for meals. We have not been disappointed. We will be returning soon. Check out their new pizza menu.”

“the best pizza in indiana!!! never once in 40 years have we gotten bad service or pizza...with a track record like that where can you go wrong!!! too bad they don't make a 24 inch!!!”

“Amazing as always! Thank you so much”

“Real Authentic mexicain!! Delicious flavours. Highly recommend!!”

“Made a quick stop for pizza at this local restaurant and ordered a medium cheese and sausage with Alfredo sauce. Wow! I wish I lived closer. It was delicious and everyone was extremely polite. Waited maybe 20 minutes to eat. Great place ! Highly recommend.”

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

“High prices, good drinks. It's a nice drink, just can't afford them everyday. They need to be open through the farmers market every Saturday, I think there would be much more business during that time.”

“My daughter and I pre-ordered our drinks and once we got there realized we did it wrong. They went above and beyond and was so nice. They made it like we wanted it. Really appreciate it and it is why we pick Dunkins because they are so nice. I forget the woman who we thought was amazing but we went Saturday 10/24/26 between 1p and 2p.”

“Edit: as of today Wed Oct 21, Mings is now fully reopen including buffet and dine-in!

Ming's is one of the best Chinese Buffet's in the state, and I've tried a few. Due to flooding damage in their neighborhood during the Northeast Indiana floods in late summer 2026, they had to close for repairs. I'm so happy to hear that they will now reopen in October 2026! Carry out reopens on Wednesday October 14 with dine soon to follow according to their official social media channels.”

“i give this a 5 out of 5 on the weenee scale”

“Nice.. just opened after being flooded from historic rains.. very nice.. no smell of mold.. did a very nice job remodeling everything.. have always liked this Applebee's.. very friendly and attentive staff”

“Good food good selection decent price I do wish they had the unlimited crab legs for dinner but other than that very good experience will go back to eat there again”

“🙂Just picked up sushi tonight, carry out, fresh, delicious, highly recommend, I will be back!! Can't wait to try the Seaweed Salad, one of my faves!”

“Can I sign up on the app?”

“I ordered a custom buffalo chicken pizza for delivery and it was absolutely perfect. Literally zero complaints. The ratio of ingredients was fantastic and every bite had an amazing crisp from the crust. I could tell straight away from how the buffalo sauce was drizzled over the pizza in such a purposeful, artistic way it was going to be good. I didn’t expect a pizza from Domino’s to be this fantastic. I called and gave my appreciation to the individual who made the pizza. I didn’t get her name nor her position but hats off as it is very obvious you care about what you produce and your craft which I truly, greatly appreciate. 10/10 will be ordering from this location again. Thank you kindly”

“the food is really good, and the people that work there are very nice”

“We've been weekly customers for a year or more. Our Saturday and/or Sunday morning tradition is to stop by for a drink and a breakfast sandwich. The app makes it even easier to order and provides loyalty rewards. The rotating menu keeps things interesting by providing new flavors to try!”

“I went there the other day and the order I was picking up wasn’t ready yet. The gm knew I was annoyed but she handled it so well. She broke out conversation with me and knew exactly how to change me from being annoyed to being friendly. They definitely picked a great gm and she was working and helping out just like the employees.”

“I come here maybe 3 times a week and get the same sandwich. I had an issue one time where I did not get the extra meat that I paid for. I called and spoke with Mark and he said to just bring receipt in to refund me the extra meat. A few days later I drove in and he took care of my refund for it. My sub is alwsys fresh and thats why I come back every week. Yes the kiosk is closed some evenings, but if youre short staffed you gotta do what ya can. Can't work store and drive thru alone. I love subway. And they also take my coupons, that arent expired!”

“The ladies that work here on Wednesday nights are just amazing!! I stop here every week on my way to church and every time receive nothing less than perfect service from them!!!”