Restaurants in New Castle

“We are here visiting from Missouri and stopped by to eat dinner it was delicious I had pit tips, spuds and baked beans. Excellent food a must try if you’re in the area.”

“Potato wedges were not cooked enough and were very dark brown. The breading on cod was spicy and way too thick.the side salad was super as was the chicken tenders.”

“Been trying to get my hands on her food for weeks now. Made a stop today on Madison Street in Muncie. Trust and believe; I was not disappointed. I bought the Jerky Chicken Tacos and they are ???!!. So different from any other Taco you have EVER had. I also brought the Pineapple Glazed Chicken dinner. It comes with the rice& beans and your choice of an additional side. I chose the fried cabbage. This dish was on point also. the rice is perfectly cooked well seasoned and not to sweet. The cabbage is spicy, semi sweet and cooked to perfection with still a little crunch to the cabbage. The pinicle of the meal was the Pineapple Glazed Chicken. Fall off the bone done, succulent, sweet spicy and ohhh so juicy. Talk about a real Nap Time Meal. lol. I will be visiting them again soon.”

“Tip: order light sauce. Otherwise this place piles on the toppings and makes their food amazing. Probably some of the most friendly staff I've encountered. Definitely my pick in town.”

“Outstanding food and service!!! Ordered a General Tso’s Chicken and it was packed full!!! Huge portion and flavor was great!!! Less than 10 min. to wait!!!! Great experience once again!”

“This bar is a local tradition for New Castle. There are regulars at the counter each day. They have pool tables, a juke box and a lively atmosphere. I sampled the steak sandwich and WOW. They have meat from Rihms locker, and mix it with cheese and onions on a buttery grilled bun. Excellent diner style steak sandwich. The decor is ecclectic and plenty to look at while you have your beer. It reminds me of the Toby Keith song, "I love this bar." There are bikers, farmers, firemen, hippies, chain smokers and boozers. You can go here to laugh and have a conversation with a stranger, or sit in silence at the bar with a drink. It is a true classic "dive bar". It is locally owned, and you can tell that the owner truly cares about her patrons. We stopped in on the evening of Thanksgiving. I thought it was so neat that the owner had assembled a Thanksgiving dinner for all of her normal patrons. You don't find a family, "we are all in this together" atmosphere like that very often anymore. Warning: they do allow smoking.”

“Walked in and felt immediately welcome. Locally-owned small business, recently upgraded, food was great, beer was cold. Will def go back anytime we are in New Castle.”

“We rented "The Gather" for family Thanksgiving." It was very nice, clean and comfortable and perfect for our family. We will diffently be renting it again. Very well decorated.”

“Love getting fresh produce here. Always great. Always feel like my business is appreciated. Got sweet corn this past weekend. Some of the best I have ever had. Also got several other things. If you want good produce at a good price, you definitely need to check them out!”

“This is the best quick service restaurant in New Castle! My wife and I chose Culver’s for a quick dinner tonight and we were thoroughly impressed. Food was great, service was exceptional and the whole dine in experience was a pleasure. The pretzel bites are a must!”

“Tommy at the bar was great, friendly and helpful. The wild mushroom ravioli was spectacular. The mushroom in the ravioli was rich and creamy. The mushrooms on top marinated in a vinaigrette were surprisingly popping and sweet. Needed more of those for sure because the balance with the richer cream would have been even better! Seriously some of the best ravioli I have ever had. Added shrimp which was good, wish I had tried the salmon. Tommy lived in Alaska and says the salmon is spectacular. Next time will try that. Erin got the cajun chicken penne which was also really good. Bread tasty and crisp and a wide selection of bottle beer along with several drafts. First time here will for sure be back!!!”

“We arrived at the restaurant a little after 1:00 pm. The front door was jammed with people checking out and another couple and ourselves waiting to get in. We were promptly seated and asked what we would like to drink. Our drinks were served in less than 5 min with our salsa and warm chips. Our order was taken and it wasn't 15 min our meals were served. Our waiter checked with us several times to see if we needed anything else. Our meals were delicious! We had to ask for take home containers as our portions were huge. We live approximately 17 miles from this restaurant and it is worth the trip! Nothing comes close to Los Amigos in our town. Highly recommend!”

“We went to the Early Bird Cafe today for breakfast. It was pretty good; I ate the biscuits and gravy. Hubby ate a burger and fries. Coffee was weak but everything else was good ?!”

“I've lived in New Castle for about a year and a half and I regret that it's taken me so long to try this place out. It is wonderful! The grab and go food is so delicious and convenient! I got the chicken salad and veggies with house ranch. I wanted to try everything! It all looked so good! I'll be a regular!”

“My main go-to restaurant in New Castle! Love their grinders, pizza and breadsticks! PS for all restaurants- please consider sanitizing items such as menus and salt/pepper/cheese shakers between customers, thanks”