Joy's Cakery

2481 E Main St #190, Plainfield
(317) 742-7858

Recent Reviews

Sean Anderson

They made a wonderful cake, and the service was great!

Natalie Odier

I had a cake for a work award celebration and it was incredible. Flavor and texture were amazing. Everyone was asking where the cake was from!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kay B.

Excellent flavor, a little pricey for size of cupcake but good variety. Helpful staff. Signage on building made me doubt if bakery was still part of business

Rosemary Tomey

This place is AMAZING!!I couldn’t have ask for a more beautiful and delicious cake anywhere but here!Joy the owner was so accommodating and went up and beyond to make my daughter the most perfect cake and it was so delicious!!We will definitely be back to buy our cakes from her from now on.We live in Terre haute but it’s so well worth the drive!!Her staff is awesome too!We bought a couple cupcakes too and they were delicious!:)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Chocolate Buttercream, Snickerdoodle, Cupcake

John O.

Very friendly and great atmosphere. Always feels like you are at home and can just kick back.

David Hughes

Joy's Cakery is reasonably priced.

Xiao Y.

I ordered a chocolate cake with cream cheese icing in the middle layer. It was delicious and everyone loved it. At first, I was afraid the six inch cake would be too small. After 5 slices, we still had 75% of the cake left. This was a great value!

S.

Such a cute, cozy place. A nice atmosphere to sit & relax with delicious drinks and cupcakes

kath vansant

Been buying cupcakes here for my kids' birthdays. Their cupcakes are beautifully designed and are always a crowd pleaser. They are deliciously moist and not too sweet. Thank you Ms. Joy!

Austin Arkins

Absolutely love Joy's Cakery! She makes amazing cupcakes and cakes. We have gotten a cake every year for three years now. And she is reasonably priced

Justin Duprey

Sooooooooooo disappointed!! I had picked up a birthday cake for my daughter's 6th birthday party and I was blown away because the cake was absolutely gorgeous! The reason we chose Joy's is because we had their cupcakes in the past and they are AMAZING! Unfortunately, the cake was an E-X-T-R-E-M-E disappointment! We ordered half white/chocolate. The cake was more like 80% chocolate to 20% white. The cake was EXTREMELY DRY! None of the adults at the birthday party could even finish the cake, it was THAT DRY! We all felt like the cake had been frozen before because it was so dried out. The top section of the white was a much darker color like it maybe was overcooked?I had called and left a message with Joy's bakery with our concerns but they never called me back.Honestly save your money and go to Meijer or Walmart and buy a fresh cake! Don't make the mistake thinking the cupcakes at Joy's are the same as the cake or you will be extremely disappointed.

Bri Wozniak

We had a really great experience! It was super easy to order and the cakes were delicious! We got both vanilla and chocolate. We picked up a couple gluten free Chocolate and Vanilla cupcakes and my guest who needed them said they really tasty! Probably the best GF cupcakes she’s ever had. The staff was very friendly. Thank you so much for all your help—I will forever make the 40 minute drive from Cloverdale to pick up cakes from Joy’s.

Maegan H.

AMAZING cupcakes!! Coffee is delicious and Super friendly staff. Great place to get cupcakes if you are in the mood for something sweet or needing to pick up for a special occasion. I highly recommend this little gem. She also makes cakes for special occasions!!

Megan Shafer

Delicious cupcakes. Friendly staff. Great latte! Will be back!

Deanna Brown

she made a cake for my dad's 80th bday and it was so good and beautifully made. i will order another when I need one.

Load More