18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Valparaiso

“Was just here for a family lunch. The food is excellent. Decent variety of dish choices and the portions are perfect. It's a little dim inside / a little loud from the TVs so if you're there to chat I'd get like a booth or window seat. 10/10 would recommend coming here.“

“Pesto's is a hidden gem in Valpo. I've been eating here for 25 years and they have literally the best breadsticks on the planet. They are known for their delicious pasta dishes, but they also have amazing pizza! There are a few good pizza spots in Valpo (Greeks!), but honestly next to Giordano's deep dish, Pesto's is my go-to thin crust pizza place! Tip: They don't always bring their bread loaf and oil - ask for it, it's fresh and warm and served with a delicious Balsamic olive oil!“

“A very delightful pizza place in downtown Valparaiso. They have indoor seating and also a walk-up window. The joker is a really good pizza! It is thin crust but they oven bake it so it has a little bit of char at the edge but that makes it great!“

“Shout out to evening assistant manager at the Valparaiso Buono! We were there Valentine's evening to get a rainbow cone. It was closed, but manager offered to open a nd make us a couple. Wow, have to say excellent customer service! Very friendly and outgoing. We will be definitely be back!“

“Zao Island, a unique spot nestled along the shores of Porter County. As soon as you arrive on this quiet stretch along the Porter/Lake county line, you can feel the midwestern charm of the region. Off in the distance stands the stacks of Indiana's famous steel mills, a reminder of the industry that shaped the communities here for generations.But Zao Island offers a peaceful respite from the world, a place to take a deep breath and relax. Only accessible by a short footbridge, it feels like you've escaped to your own private oasis. Spanish moss drips from the trees, gently swaying in the breeze coming off the water. Butterflies flit about, chasing each other through the tall grass and wildflowers. It's the perfect spot for picnics, conversations that seem to go on for hours. Sunlight dapples the ground, and little rushes and cattails lean towards their reflections in the shallows.Venture down the winding paths that cut through the heart of the island. You never know what you might encounter - perhaps a family of deer nibbling on lush spring growth, or bright kingfishers zooming low along the banks. Bring a book and find a shady nook under an old oak, listening to shorebirds calling as they wade through the emergent vegetation. It's easy to while away an entire afternoon on Zao Island, soothed by nature's gentle rhythms. Before you know it, the sun will be setting behind those steel mills in a blazing ball of orange fire. Another day slips gently into memory on this cherished slice of wilderness along Lake Michigan's shore.“

“Spectacular. From the first bite, you can tell they use quality ingredients, not just what a distributor pushes their way.The building is well remodeled with a red brick veneer wall, nice furnishings, great lighting, and an outdoor seating area.The staff was very courteous and attentive, even when the Friday rush arrived as we were finishing our meal. Our server was well versed on the meals, their ingredients, prep, and provided helpful recommendations.Our appetizer was the meatballs. Made on site, the meat was flavorful but lean. The sauce made my wife go "wow," and the cheese was fresh and delicious. The appetizer arrived well before the meal, so we could enjoy it without being rushed.My wife ordered a Detroit pizza while I ordered the Johnny Boy sandwich. The waitress immediately asked and recommended ricotta cheese for the pizza, an excellent recommendation. The pizza arrived, well more than 1 person could eat, with a perfect buttery deep pan crust, a great sause, and again cheeses that were definately not from a distributor as they were fresh and with a complex flavor profile not found in something from a restaurant distributor.My Johnny Boy sandwich had thinly sliced meats cooked perfectly. The peppers were also cooked perfectly with a fully cooked flavor in a pepper slice that still was firm without being crunchy. The bread was so distinctive I shared a tear off with my wife, again something deliberately chosen by the chef for its quality. The fries were comparable to those from 5 Guys without being excessively oily.The waitress said the restaurant has been in this location for 4 years, unfortunately we just found it today. A fantastic addition to the Valparaiso food scene.“

“I was so excited to find a Fazoli's, hadn't had it since I left college 25 years ago. It's still the same reliable, quick, budget-friendly pasta I knew all those years ago. And the breadsticks are FIRE, just as I remember. I'll gladly stop by whenever I'm in town again. Thanks for the memories!“

“They took great care of us. We had a large group of friends and family members for a birthday party. The pizza was good but, for me, I thought the crust was too thick. Just my opinion. Overall, a great experience.Parking: Gravel parking lot. Sloppy out there when it rains. Dusty AF when it's dry. It's gravel, what do you expect... :)Kid-friendliness: It's a great place to let the kids run around and have fun. PLENTY of attractions for the kids to play and interact with. Indoors and outdoors (weather permitting).Wheelchair accessibility: They have the facilities spaced for wheelchair accessibility. Plenty of room for special needs chairs too.“

“We had a wonderful celebration surprise party. It was a perfect night until the bill came with a mystery Miscellaneous $100 charge. This was a room charge that was unknown to us causing another family member to pay the $400 bill embarrassingly to the host. Host called to reserve that day months beforehand and asked if a deposit was required to which the employee said no. At this time the room fee COULD HAVE BEEN discussed so that we could've been better prepared. If this is on the menu it was missed and I checked again not seeing it online. Otherwise it was great and our service was perfect. P.s we had disabled people on oxygen and issues walking. After asking if they could use the exit that the delivery drivers use, she said no and then changed their minds. Having a disability is REAL.“

“I was visiting for a funeral and did not want to go out. When I learned there was a Rosati’s nearby I remembered my great experiences in the past. I had the traditional thinner crust vegetarian pizza and it was as good as I remembered from almost 6 years ago. When I return to the area Rosati’s will be on my short list.“

“I never wanted to post a review on this place because I feel like it's a well-hidden gem in Valparaiso just off Calumet Ave. But I love the place so much that I've decided to share the secret. This is our go-to Pizzeria for Family Pizza Night. My very picky-eating daughters love this place for the mozzarella sticks, cheese pizza, and the fun, inexpensive toy machines that they have. We always order their wings because they are always served hot and crispy, as good wings are. The food never disappoints and we always leave stuffed and with leftovers to spare. The staff is always friendly and polite. They're always working and aiming to please. This place has excellent customer service and delicious food for a great price. No matter how busy, my family will continue to come here for years to come.“

“This place is our go to. We have sometimes even gone a few times a week. Food is always fresh, cooked to perfection and you get your money's worth. We have bought different items off the menu and we have never been disappointed. Their pizza reminds us of home back in chicago. Love love love this place, I cannot recommend it enough.“

“**Spectacular Review for Gelsosomo's Pizzeria in Valparaiso, IN**If there's a slice of heaven on earth, it's nestled in the heart of Valparaiso, Indiana, at Gelsosomo's Pizzeria. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza, drawing you in like a moth to a flame.Let's talk about the pizza. Oh, the pizza! Each bite is a symphony of flavors, from the perfect balance of tangy tomato sauce to the creamy melt of mozzarella cheese, all atop a crust so divine it could rival the Sistine Chapel. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni, a veggie aficionado, or a bold adventurer craving the Hawaiian Luau with pineapple and ham, Gelsosomo's has a pie to suit every palate.But it's not just the pizza that steals the show. The menu boasts a lineup of mouthwatering appetizers, savory pastas, and hearty sandwiches, each dish crafted with care and culinary expertise. And let's not forget about the desserts - the tiramisu is a dreamy finale to any meal.The ambiance of Gelsosomo's is warm and inviting, with friendly staff who treat you like family from the moment you walk in. Whether you're dining in with friends and family or grabbing a quick takeout order, the service is always prompt and courteous.And let's not forget about value. Gelsosomo's offers generous portions at reasonable prices, ensuring that every visit feels like a celebration without breaking the bank.In conclusion, Gelsosomo's Pizzeria in Valparaiso, IN, is a culinary gem that deserves to be celebrated far and wide. With mouthwatering pizza, stellar service, and unbeatable value, it's no wonder locals and visitors alike keep coming back for more. Trust me, one visit to Gelsosomo's and you'll be hooked for life.“

“I came in this last weekend visiting family, and we drove by and saw it was karaoke night and thought it was so cool! Our server Maranda was the absolute best! Since we had not been here she recommended good meals for us and answered all of our questions professionally. Next time we come to town we hope to have her as our server again!“

“Just had lunch on the patio, was very pleasant. Had a personal pizza. Was good but I did a standard. Specialty pizzas look delicious and I can't wait to try one next time.My service was mvp. I should have gotten her name. I will mainly come back for her.“

“Had the Italian sausage sandwich on a recent visit. Nice seasoning and cooked nicely.The onion soup was tasty and not overly salty. A nice layer of cheese baked over the top and full of onions.Nice place to hit after a round of golf at Aberdeen.“

“Sister ordered J&Js for dinner and wasn't disappointed. The delivery driver guy was nice. We had stuffed pizza with sausage,mushrooms, green peppers & peperoni. It's not bad for a stuffed pizza . We also had an Italian beef with mozzarella cheese and pepperoncinis. The sandwich was hot and delicious. I definitely recommend this place for something different to eat..“

“Haven't ordered from Dominos in over 30 years because back then their pizzas were a joke. Because of word of mouth that now they are excellent, I ordered 2 Medium Pan Pizzas for the price of 1 on line for pickup with Sausage Mushrooms and Green Peppers. They were very very good. Plenty of cheeses, but they skimped on the sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers - I should have chosen extra on the toppings because they were good. Anyway, they have come a long way in taste and quality in the last 30 years. i Will be going back in the future for more pan style.“