26 Best American Restaurants near Winona Lake

“I have been to the boathouse restaurant several times and I enjoy coming. I was there this evening and I ordered a side of asparagus. I often order a side of vegetables and I specifically ask that there being no oil on the vegetables. And every time they put oil on them. The only way I can seem to get this request met is to have to send the waiter or waitress back to the kitchen and have it redone. I don’t understand why it’s so difficult to just get plain steamed vegetables upon request. I really enjoy food I get otherwise, and I usually have good service, I just cannot seem to get food that isn’t all coded in oil.“

“We are in town visiting family and stumbled on this place. Hands down the best breakfast we have had in a long time. Love these little mom and pop places.“

“If you want good seafood in Warsaw, you go to Noa Noa. The Ahi tuna was excellent. So delicious. Thank you.“

“I eat there all the time. Only thing that I don’t like is when I’m eating a salad and they bring my dinner out before I’m done with my salad and by the time I get to my dinner, it’s cold. I’m a slow eater. Other than that I highly recommend them.“

“I had a meal they catered, it was great Pulled Chicken, Pulled Pork, Green Beans all were excellent. Tell your friends“

“Great food and friendly staff. Gets busy on a summer weekend. Reservations highly recommended. The walls are lined with pics of Capone and others who frequented the hotel and bar. If you love the stories of ghosts and hauntings, you’ll enjoy this place.“

“After 8 long years in Indiana we have finally found a pizza that is a true Chicago pizza. Highly recommend.“

“Truly amazing food and outstanding bar and wine selections in a comfortable environment with a welcoming staff.“

“The food is just great! The Steakburger and the Stuffed Bacon Cheeseburger are juicy and flavorful and HUGE. The atmosphere is typical of a nice, quiet country diner. The staff is great and right on top of keeping your drinks full. Stop in if you're in the area.“

“Had a 7:30 reservation, arrived about 5 minutes early, but ended up waiting for 30 minutes. When we asked about the delay after someone arrived and was seated, the "found" our table. That was the only negative though.Food was amazing. I had the bone in rib-eye and the wife had sushi. We looked at the menu and commented that one of everything looked good. Reasonable prices, we'll definitely go back.“

“Friendly and fast staff great for catching a Monday night football game. Good food, cold beer, and right across from my old house.“

“Great food and service is excellent!!“

“Met there with a group of friends they don't open till 1 p.m. on the weekdays the kitchen doesn't open until 4. Sharon was so sweet and seeing that there were seven in our group she got permission to open the kitchen. The food was normal bar food but with the added extra love that Sharon added to the whole visit it tasted that much better.“

“very delicious food, fast service and kind peple, I'll come back soon“

“1st time Fan! EXCELLENT service, large portions, yummy food, great prices!“

“We ordered a cheese burger well done. When it came out, it was pink in the middle. The bartender took it back, and they made us one the way we ordered it. Well done.She gave us a discount for the mistake the kitchen made. She didn't have to do that, but she did.“

“forget the butter burger that fish sandwich(their fish sandwich is an actual fish sandwich so breaded fried fish not a fish patty on a bun) is wonderful and while you're there you gotta get a concrete the stuff is amazing , service time was great personally I would suggest you get a value basket and sub out the soda for a concrete and take that fish sandwich“

“We went on a Saturday night and it was just the bartender and she was the cook too. But she did a job and was very attentive and friendly. Very limited menu with only chips or apple sauce for sides. The place was very nice and clean and homey. We went hoping to eat on the train but they didn't have it open. Do recommend if you just want a nice quiet place to have a drink.“

“Good food fast service , didn’t have to wait long for our food“

“Restaurant service was EXCELLENT, OUR waiter Brent was fabulous, ? VERY FRIENDLY, & Always served with a Smile ? Food was delicious, especially your cornbread casserole ? please give Brent a Big raise! Thank you Kristine“

“Was a little disappointed. With only 3 tables full, we had to wait 5 minutes to be seated. I finally just went to the salad bar (which looked like a hog wollar) and started making a salad. Service was equally as slow.This used to be a great place to eat, but I'll likely not go back anytime soon. Such a shame.“

“The Scotch eggs are AMAZING! And they have the best staff. Jeff is literally the best server I've ever had, anywhere, at any restaurant. And the other night Marissa made the best espresso martini I've ever had. And I've been to a lot of high end bars, and always get an espresso martini if they have it, so this is saying a lot! Bravo to Mad Anthony's for having the best around!“

“Our group of about 11 had good food and good service this morning.“

“The cod was from God. My Lenten observance brought me here to Warsaw, Indiana, but my experience was hardly penitential. The service was as cordial as the curds were crispy. The aesthetic of this Culver’s blended tile and carpet, brick and drywall, friendship with fascination. Was I in the middle of Indiana, or Cape cod? My group of eight was well satiated and now prepared for the next leg of our voyage toward Ohio. Thank you Culver for being the lighthouse of hope in my tempest of hunger.“

“everything is okay I guess .except when I got home my order is incomple.I called and complained about it and they said I will get a free bread next time I come ,really .?My point is they should be checking everything although its my mistake that I trusted them when they said yes everything is there .It would be nice to have the bread in the meal right now but have to come again drive all the way just to get a bread.Thanks for their mistake .“