Custom Cakes near St. Matthews, KY

Half-Peach Bakery & Cafe Vegan • $
170 Sears Ave, St Matthews

Customers` Favorites

Raw Taco Salad and Nacho Bowl
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cheeseburger Pizza
Spinach Artichoke
Margherita Pizza
Banh MI Sandwich
Beast Brownie
Shrimp PO Boy
Falafel Balls
Carrot Cake

“We LOVE Half Peach. It is always one of our favorites when we are in town. The best assortment of vegan desserts in Louisville that are all amazing and a smaller food menu. Our favorites are the big Chik'n Miso salad, the drumsticks, and the pizzas. I went here for my birthday in February and stuffed myself and still had leftovers. The portions are very generous and the staff is super friendly and helpful.“

4.8 Superb46 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
976 Breckenridge Ln, Louisville

“The ice cream here is okay, I find them WAY too sweet and if you are curious about the calories, all I can say is that almost all of them are 1k+ calories, except for the smoothies. The line can be quite long if it is busy and I don't like the fact that the fan is blocking 2 lights and is causing flickering near the ordering area, so watch out if you have epilepsy.“

2.2 Poor42 Reviews
Bae's Baekery Bakery • $
1804 Frankfort Ave, Louisville - 4.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

S'Mores Brownie Cookie Cake S'Mores Cookie Brownie Bite Cake Batter Cream Puff
Dulce De Leche Brownie Irish Cream Cookie March Lucky Charms Cookie March
Bourbon Ballin Cookie Cinnamon Rollex Cookie and Classic Chocolate Chip
Weekly Rotating Cinnamon Roll Flavor
Marble Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Chocolate Cake w Chocolate Icing
Weekly Rotating Cookie Flavors
Chocolate Ched Blandbb
Wedding Cake Tastings
Red Velvet Cookies

“She absolutely exceeded my expectations The customer service was amazing! I absolutely love this cake it’s everything my gf wanted and more! The price was very reasonable overall services was a 20 out of 10 absolutely amazing!! ❤️❤️❤️?“

4.8 Superb90 Reviews
William's Bakery Bakery • $
1051 N Clark Blvd # C, Clarksville - 8.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Cin Raisin Bread
Thumbprint Cookies
Plain Chocolate
Cinnamon Bread
Cake Donuts
King's Cake
Doughnut
Danish
Muffin

“I will definitely be back! I was looking all over for a lamb cake, as I always grew up in Chicago having one each Easter. A few people had recommended this bakery. While they didn't have a lamb cake, they had this bunny cake which definitely was a great stand-in in place of the lamb! All the kids loved it, and it tasted delicious! Cute cake, reasonably priced, and absolutely delicious!“

4.3 Superb41 Reviews
Blu Bakery Bakery • $
11615 Main St, Louisville - 5.2 miles

“Blu Bakery created an exact replica of the cake picture I sent! Also helped me out with delivery and pickup as we are from out of state and birthday girl was there visiting for the birthday! They had quick communications with me and professionalism. Customer service was A+ and I can’t wait to come down and order more goodies from them!“

4.9 Superb18 Reviews
Sweets by Millie Bakery • $$
223 S Hancock St #1, Louisville - 5.78 miles

“We could not have been more pleased with the way our daughter’s second birthday cake and cookies looked and tasted! From the start, the communication and customer service was top notch. The communication was speedy, friendly, and detailed from start to finish. I gave the cake artist a theme (Bluey) and a lot of creative freedom. She did not disappoint!The appearance of the cake and cookies was stunning and received so many compliments. My daughter loved it. We chose almond cake with raspberry filling. The cake was decadent with just the perfect amount of almond and the raspberry filling was fresh and delicious. The cookies were very intricate and delicious.To note, we picked up our order on Thursday morning for a party on Saturday and both the cake and cookies tasted like they had been baked Saturday morning, which was amazing.Thank you for a wonderful first experience! We will be back.“

4.9 Superb12 Reviews
Staggeringly Delicious Bakery • $$
962 Barret Ave, Louisville - 5.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesecake

“This cake was hands down the best birthday cake I have ever bought. I plan more parties than the average person, mostly baby showers, so I order a lot of cakes. This was hands down the best. You can tell that it is made with quality ingredients. A lot of thought has been put into the design. When I showed up to pick up my cake, I had a toddler and a baby with me. The owner graciously helped me get the cake out to my car. I was very appreciative of her kindness. 10/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Hire Staggeringly Delicous to bake for your next event!“

4.6 Superb11 Reviews
La Morena Panaderia y tortillera Bakery • $
8659 Preston Hwy, Louisville - 8.36 miles

“We heard about La Morena through Yelp's virtual event with Farm + House and decided to visit this bakery in person to check it out. As we parked we noticed that OPEN light was off. It was an afternoon so we thought maybe they had closed, but when we were through shopping at the small Mexican grocery next door the sign was lit, so we went in. It's a small business and our visit was in the middle of a pandemic, so odd hours are understandable. The storefront is recognizable if you've been to other panaderias: trays and tongs for self-service, glass-doored cases with shelves of panes dulces and breads, a refrigerator with packaged slices of cake. True to their name, they also carry tortillas, chips, and bags of masa (the latter found in the refrigerated case). The pastry selection is pretty standard: conchas, donuts, filled pastries, orejas, marranitos, tri-color cookies, etc. At the counter, there's a book with images of cakes that can be special ordered. I thought we went overboard selecting pastries on our first visit, but for only $8 we got half a dozen cookies/pastries and a piece of tres leches cake. It was a steal; all were good. We've also ordered through Farm+House, which is nice since La Morena is a drive for us. This has enabled us to try more items, including their telera rolls, tortillas, and tortilla chips. It's definitely worth a visit if you are in the area. If you aren't in the area, maybe manufacture and excuse to be so you can check out these baked goods.“

4.6 Superb10 Reviews

Custom Cakes Nearby

St. Matthews’s related cuisines