6 Best American Restaurants in Edgartown

“Got here just in time ! Shops and restaurants are starting to open up for the season so we had the island all to ourselves. Although It was a bit nippy, we enjoyed the sunshine during our walks through the sleepy towns - spotted Rockfish and because I was craving a lobster roll - in we came ! The roll was delicious, my husband's fish and chips crunchy and flavorful- our gracious server was HCristina (think I spelled that right) from Serbia and she was just charming and fabulous! Great meal and wonderful service!“

“Bettini Restaurant at the Harborview Hotel is must if you're visiting Martha's Vineyard. Both the dinner and lunch menus have something for every palate. Each entree is delicious and we enjoy the chef's preparation whether it's a grilled chicken sandwich with avocado or boneless duck breast in a delectable sauce. Save room for dessert. Nick the bartender makes excellent cocktails! Dining at Bettini is not just eating a meal, it's a dining experience with a stunning backdrop of the lighthouse and harbor. Mary the hostess is so welcoming and gracious. Check out the menus. Bettini is highly recommended!!“

“Classic diner. Great food, great vibe. Love the Trivial Pursuit Genus cards at each table. Great for breakfast and lunch. Nice non-diner food options for vegetarians. Right in downtown with good parking and within walking distance from waterfront and hotels.“

“If you are looking for fresh, tasty and creative cocktails you should check out this place. The bartender Kamila makes the best drinks in town. I was amazed how good it tasted. Service is excellent too, Kamila was very welcoming and giving us detailed explanations about how she makes all the mixers for her cocktails from scratch. Do yourself a favor and get a dessert too, the crème brûlée was to die for.“

“Absolutely beautiful restaurant with fantastic service and excellent food. We love going early and having one of their outstanding drinks in one of their living rooms. The food is always superb and the setting is so romantic. We always celebrate our anniversary here. Highly recommended.“

“Decided to make this our last supper while staying in Edgartown and we were happy with our choice! We started with the brussel sprouts caesar and meatball special which was an appetizer that came with three small meatballs in an Asian style bbq sauce with crispy onions and coleslaw. Both were very tasty and shared easily between four people. The Brussels sprouts in the Caesar could've been a little crispier but all in all it was a tasty dish. We also split truffle fries which were very good with the aioli it comes with. For entrees, we tried the blackened mahi mahi with crab risotto, the cheeseburger, and the roasted chicken. Everyone loved what they got and had no complaints. Spicy mango margs and pineapple mojitos were had too! Service was very attentive and the atmosphere was nice.“