Edgartown Seafood Market

The new owners are doing a terrific job and their quality is as good as ever.. the boys are customer centric and wish to please … all staff are very polite and prompt in their service …we especially love the post covid renewal of Chappaquiddick delivery each evening. We ordered six lobsters, three were 3 pounds. Shells were very hard and full of meat… superb!! Our annual lobster bake was a success once again. We.also went to the shop and bought swordfish which was incredibly...read full review

This place was located about a 10min walk from our hotel in Edgartown. We were instantly greeted and helped with our order by the nice kid working the cash register. I wanted to try the Lobster Bisque, but they were out. Saw the picture on Yelp and had stop by for the Hot Lobster roll. It definitely delivered on taste and they do not skimp on the lobster. If you like mayo, then try the Lobster salad roll instead. Hubby ordered the clam chowder and stated it had great flavor, but...read full review

Not at all what I expected but it turned into a blessing in disguise. Edgartown Seafood turned out to be a fish market but still offered some of the FRESHEST soup and lobster rolls that I have ever tasted in my entire life. It was sad to see that they weren't more populated, because people who are not coming here are really missing out. While this place does not at all have any tables to sit at, there was a park just a few hundred yards away (walkable distance) where we sat and...read full review