My boyfriend and I are obsessed with their donuts. Perfect every time, absolutely delicious. They remind us of sponge cakes, in the best way possible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Doughnut
Gordon A.
This is a great place to get a great cup of coffee and some yummy doughnuts. The bread is amazing.
Jay Bahre
The food was good, a co worker and I went here to get a thing called morning glory cinnamon buns or something like that. My co worker ordered 12 of them and he was told he couldn't. he was only allowed to order 6 because it's a rule only 6 per person. So he ordered 6 and I ordered 6 and then he went to pay for them and they wouldn't let him pay for all 12 I had to pay for mine on my own. That makes absolutely no sense to me. Even though their coffee and cinnamon buns are very good I don't think I'll be going back there because of their rules or policies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Jeff Chen
We tried 4 items: morning bun, pumpkin crumble, nosara spiced scone, and pumpkin scone.I think the morning bun is overrated ($5.35). It's small and absolutely smothered with sugar. Just way too sweet. The system for ordering these is totally non existent. Don't expect to walk in and get one right away. The employee told me "we have a batch ready to go in the oven. It will take 20-25 mins to bake and prepare, but we don't know when we will put in the oven. Can't give you any kind of estimate, just come by again whenever." Totally baffling. If you are really dying to try morning bun, call ahead and see if you can get any sense of availability and/or timing from them.The pumpkin crumble was amazing. Easily our favorite item.Both scones were decent -- less sweet but also less flavorful. If you're looking for something more subtle, go for the scones.
Sean Widman
If you have the chance to buy a morning bun, you absolutely should. It is the best thing in the world - the perfect balance of flavor and texture! So good! Also, their breakfast sandwiches are great too! A great place to visit whenever you visit Nantucket.
Loretta F.
Service is wonderful, people are great, morning bun go fast but are made throughout the day and they are as good as people say!
Ann D.
Disappointed. Of course everyone wants to try the morning buns but they can only make so many. I got there around 7:15 AM but Once I heard them tell the lady in front of me that the entire pan in the oven was already purchased I got a raspberry muffin. There were only raspberries on top. Otherwise nothing caught my eye. Too bad.
Dylen Badrose
The morning buns is a winner and the donuts are really good .love the crossiant fresh from the oven ?
Jeremy Abbott
Very good food at island prices. Not the place to visit if you are in a hurry. Grab some coffee, take a number, sit on the patio, and wait for your number to be called to pick up your morning buns.
Amazing ham and cheese croissants, banana chocolate chip muffins, coffee friendly staff. HOWEVER the morning bun situation is a bit out of control. I'm 0/10 trying to get one I've been there at 7 AM- 10 AM. The times on the board of them coming out 10/10 times have all been accounted for or pre bought? At what point do you just make 1,000 of them? Very frustrating because they are so good ...
Brent C
Whatever the opposite of a well oiled machine is the Wicked Island bakery. Clueless children running the show with seemingly zero training. The products are fine and taste great. The trouble getting them makes it less enjoyable. The morning buns are good when warm, just layered croissant dough rolled in churro sugar, the coffee is good, the scones are good. Watching a dozen clueless kids try not to assist customers is painful.
Brent C
Whatever the opposite of a well oiled machine is the Wicked Island bakery. Clueless children running the show with seemingly zero training. The products are fine and taste great. The trouble getting them makes it less enjoyable. The morning buns are good when warm, just layered croissant dough rolled in churro sugar, the coffee is good, the scones are good. Watching a dozen clueless kids try not to assist customers is painful.
Fish G
Great morning buns, sailor knots and ham/cheese croissants.As noted by owner and reviewers, hit and miss when they are available as made from scratch and limited baking facilities. Went 5 times during our week and only able to get what we wanted once.5 stars for great baked goods3 stars for availability - just the reality
Amy H.
It took me 3 days to finally get an opportunity to purchase the morning roll. Being a fellow Chef and understanding the many layers of the food service industry, its extremely odd their production is this antiquated. It's fun to have a mystery, but when it becomes an inconvenience the novelty will be lost. That said this Small roll was good but at the price of $6. each ...not so much!
Freat food and great service...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My boyfriend and I are obsessed with their donuts. Perfect every time, absolutely delicious. They remind us of sponge cakes, in the best way possible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Doughnut
This is a great place to get a great cup of coffee and some yummy doughnuts. The bread is amazing.
The food was good, a co worker and I went here to get a thing called morning glory cinnamon buns or something like that. My co worker ordered 12 of them and he was told he couldn't. he was only allowed to order 6 because it's a rule only 6 per person. So he ordered 6 and I ordered 6 and then he went to pay for them and they wouldn't let him pay for all 12 I had to pay for mine on my own. That makes absolutely no sense to me. Even though their coffee and cinnamon buns are very good I don't think I'll be going back there because of their rules or policies.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
We tried 4 items: morning bun, pumpkin crumble, nosara spiced scone, and pumpkin scone.I think the morning bun is overrated ($5.35). It's small and absolutely smothered with sugar. Just way too sweet. The system for ordering these is totally non existent. Don't expect to walk in and get one right away. The employee told me "we have a batch ready to go in the oven. It will take 20-25 mins to bake and prepare, but we don't know when we will put in the oven. Can't give you any kind of estimate, just come by again whenever." Totally baffling. If you are really dying to try morning bun, call ahead and see if you can get any sense of availability and/or timing from them.The pumpkin crumble was amazing. Easily our favorite item.Both scones were decent -- less sweet but also less flavorful. If you're looking for something more subtle, go for the scones.
If you have the chance to buy a morning bun, you absolutely should. It is the best thing in the world - the perfect balance of flavor and texture! So good! Also, their breakfast sandwiches are great too! A great place to visit whenever you visit Nantucket.
Service is wonderful, people are great, morning bun go fast but are made throughout the day and they are as good as people say!
Disappointed. Of course everyone wants to try the morning buns but they can only make so many. I got there around 7:15 AM but Once I heard them tell the lady in front of me that the entire pan in the oven was already purchased I got a raspberry muffin. There were only raspberries on top. Otherwise nothing caught my eye. Too bad.
The morning buns is a winner and the donuts are really good .love the crossiant fresh from the oven ?
Very good food at island prices. Not the place to visit if you are in a hurry. Grab some coffee, take a number, sit on the patio, and wait for your number to be called to pick up your morning buns.
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing ham and cheese croissants, banana chocolate chip muffins, coffee friendly staff. HOWEVER the morning bun situation is a bit out of control. I'm 0/10 trying to get one I've been there at 7 AM- 10 AM. The times on the board of them coming out 10/10 times have all been accounted for or pre bought? At what point do you just make 1,000 of them? Very frustrating because they are so good ...
Whatever the opposite of a well oiled machine is the Wicked Island bakery. Clueless children running the show with seemingly zero training. The products are fine and taste great. The trouble getting them makes it less enjoyable. The morning buns are good when warm, just layered croissant dough rolled in churro sugar, the coffee is good, the scones are good. Watching a dozen clueless kids try not to assist customers is painful.
Whatever the opposite of a well oiled machine is the Wicked Island bakery. Clueless children running the show with seemingly zero training. The products are fine and taste great. The trouble getting them makes it less enjoyable. The morning buns are good when warm, just layered croissant dough rolled in churro sugar, the coffee is good, the scones are good. Watching a dozen clueless kids try not to assist customers is painful.
Great morning buns, sailor knots and ham/cheese croissants.As noted by owner and reviewers, hit and miss when they are available as made from scratch and limited baking facilities. Went 5 times during our week and only able to get what we wanted once.5 stars for great baked goods3 stars for availability - just the reality
It took me 3 days to finally get an opportunity to purchase the morning roll. Being a fellow Chef and understanding the many layers of the food service industry, its extremely odd their production is this antiquated. It's fun to have a mystery, but when it becomes an inconvenience the novelty will be lost. That said this Small roll was good but at the price of $6. each ...not so much!