Wicked Island Bakery

$$ • Bakery, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free

Hours:
7 Bayberry Ct, Nantucket
(508) 901-5797

Customers' Favorites

Wicked Island Bakery Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
3.9 (35)
Restaurantji Rating

The food was good, a co worker and I went here to get a thing called morning glory cinnamon buns or something like that. My co worker ordered 12 of them and he was told he couldn't. he was only allowed to order 6 because it's a rule only 6 per person. So he ordered 6 and I ordered 6 and then he went to pay for them and they wouldn't let him pay for all 12 I had to pay for mine on my own. That makes absolutely no sense to me. Even though their coffee and cinnamon buns are very...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

We tried 4 items: morning bun, pumpkin crumble, nosara spiced scone, and pumpkin scone.I think the morning bun is overrated ($5.35). It's small and absolutely smothered with sugar. Just way too sweet. The system for ordering these is totally non existent. Don't expect to walk in and get one right away. The employee told me "we have a batch ready to go in the oven. It will take 20-25 mins to bake and prepare, but we don't know when we will put in the oven. Can't give you any kind...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

If you have the chance to buy a morning bun, you absolutely should. It is the best thing in the world - the perfect balance of flavor and texture! So good! Also, their breakfast sandwiches are great too! A great place to visit whenever you visit Nantucket.

More Reviews(148)

Ratings

Menu

Hours

Monday 6AM - 2PM
Tuesday 6AM - 2PM
Wednesday 6AM - 2PM
Thursday 6AM - 2PM
Friday 6AM - 2PM
Saturday 7AM - 12PM
Sunday 7AM - 12PM
Updated on: