Buttermilk Baking Company

$ • Bakery, Gluten-Free

Hours:
9 Liberty St, Newburyport
(978) 499-8278

Customers' Favorites

Buttermilk Baking Company Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.5 (22)
Restaurantji Rating

I got the most beautiful and delicious cake from Buttermilk. I was stunned by the gorgeous cakes they had ready for sale, and got the lemon raspberry cake with macrons on top. It was soooo gorgeous, and tasted as good as it looked! The friend I got it for was so excited and happy. I will definitely get my future cakes from Buttermilk!

Restaurantji Rating

Stopped by with the family for some treats here. I couldn't resist the key lime pie on a stick...Holiday edition. Look at the detail on this masterpiece! This spot smells amazing and the staff is friendly. It's a must stop spot for sure.Kid-friendliness: What kid wouldn't want to be in a dessert shop?

Restaurantji Rating

I absolutely love this place. The entire energy of the store is beautiful, and the sweets are so appealing. I got the chocolate peanut butter pretzel pie for a little under $7. When I say I could eat like 3 of these in a row I mean it. I am so used to desserts being wayyy too sweet— this one is so balanced. Its crunchy, soft, sweet, and salty. Nothing in it is too overwhelming or overpowering. Knowing this dessert was so delightful I can’t wait to go back to try out their...read full review

More Reviews(119)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 8AM - 3PM
Wednesday 8AM - 3PM
Thursday 8AM - 3PM
Friday 8AM - 3PM
Saturday 8AM - 3PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: