23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Salem

“Great NY style pizza with a gourmet twist. The manager, Stu, is a super nice guy. I highly recommend you give them a try! HUGE pizza slices!!!“

“Small Essex Special was delicious, perfect size for 2 to split without leftovers to carry around, crust a nice mix of crunchy and chewy. Relaxed pizza spot with plenty of seating, some arcade games, and coolers with drinks to choose from. Customer service was great, everyone was friendly and they brought our pizza out to us.“

“Highly recommend the pizza; it features all very fresh ingredients. The staff is very friendly and the environment is very comfortable! Great to bring the kids!“

“some of the more creative and better pizzas in the area. a wide variety of sandwiches, wraps and subs, plus salads and dinners (pasta or rice). what's not to like? love the melanzane and the shrimp scampi pizzas, but other combinations are good too (plus MYO, of course).“

“Scott and his crew are a welcome staff to this place. Had an awesome toasted Italian today with some pizza and a few other items to boot. Great service, clean place, excellent food. Can’t wait to go back!! Good luck Scott, you’re going to kill it!!“

“So good!! One of my favorite spots in Salem. Creative and fun pizza menu. Super cozy atmosphere. Highly recommend:)“

“The name is true, the pizza really is amazing. Jacqui has great hospitality, a delicious sauce and cheese blend atop perfectly crunchy but never overcooked crust. The garlic bread sticks are also a favorite!“

“If you're in Salem, MA, you have to check out Peter's Bella Pizza! Their pizza is absolutely delicious—crispy, flavorful, and always made with fresh ingredients. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Peter's Bella Pizza is a must-try!“

“I haven’t been on top of my pizza game in some time. We have so many great places around. And this is my very first online review. But I hit up Renzos for a simple lg cheese. It was absolutely fantastic. One of the best I’ve had in years. Paper thin crust and the closest to the real Thatcher St. Regina I’ve had. And on top of that, the owner and son are tremendous guys. Talked Patriots football while I waited.“

“Fantastic food and very friendly service!!! Highly recommend!!!“

“excellent food !!!!!!!!!!!! and staff“

“Love the service!! The guy at the desk is a really outgoing and friendly individual! Love the pizza and the specials they have, and I love how it comes out nice and hot, as well as fresh. I highly recommend it too anyone in the Salem MA area!!! 🫶🏼🙌🏼“

“Delicious pizza and Buffalo wings! It's located between both arcades. Fast service. Limited booths to sit at but you could always take your food and pop a squat across the way in the grass.

Parking: Parking was weird. Not every Parking space has a meter in front of it and you need to still have to pay for Parking which is NOT clearly posted.“

“The Chicken Alfredo is a must“

“We were a few days late for Halloween in Salem so we decided to stop in at Longboards for a quick bite. Their flatbread pizza is excellent and the full service bar has it all. Friendly service and great food on the water at Pickering Wharf in Salem. We had lots of fun playing music trivia at the bar! Highly recommended.“

“We have never been disappointed with the attitude and professionalism of the staff at Londi’s and today was no exception. The pizza was delicious with healthy portions. Our server was kind, and professional. We pray that each one of you who read this review will be reminded that all this delicious food is a gift to thank God for. And the best gift you could ever have is when in his love he sent his son Jesus to die for your and my sins on the cross, and if you believe in him you would not perish but have eternal life. John 3:16“

“I have no problem making the statement for all to read...This is the best pizza I ever had. I decided to get a steak sub today and it was the best sub I ever had. The people are friendly and professional. Seriously, I have had pizza everywhere and nothing comes close. I'm looking forward to trying everything.“

“This is the best place to get pizza!! Always consistent. Subs are also amazing!!! Did you ever try an Italian from here? They toast the sub roll!! Delicious!!!“

“Fabulous pizza at realistic 👌 prices. sandwiches & dinners look great Dave very friendly hard working guy. Hoping they start delivering & include Marblehead.“

“I ordered a buffalo chicken pizza for takeout and it was EXCELLENT!! Thin, crispy crust, TONS of cheese, seared red onions, perfect amount of sauce, and the buffalo chicken had a great medium-mild spice to it. Plus, it was reasonably priced. Also, the staff were very pleasant. My only complaint is to myself for not trying this place sooner, especially since I live next door. I will DEFINITELY be back!!!“

“Great place to listen to live music!!“

“Special thanks to Tony who helped us out on our Roadtrip when we got a flat tire!! thank you!!’“

“Everything is superb. They do everything right. I love this place.“