22 Best Italian Restaurants near South Hadley

“Once again, parthenon has satisfied my cravings. Tuesdays (and Sundays) are pizza discount night and my pizza with white sauce, chicken cutlets, bacon, and pineapple was absolutely superb. Their ingredients are premium quality. Writing this eating the leftovers heated up in the toaster oven, and it's just amazing as last night. I eat here about once a week and it always hits the spot. Try their chicken, or eggplant, cutlet sub too - if you're feeling fancy, add peppers and/or onions and/or mushrooms. 10/10.“

“Great atmosphere, great food, and great service! Emmanuel was an absolute treat! Tuesday “Date Night” special is a screaming good deal too. Appetizer, 2 salads, 2 entrees, dessert, AND a bottle of wine, $85 total! I was prepared for $85 each! Oh and there was a gentleman playing piano and fugal horn!!! 5 stars“

“We tried for the first time today! :) Food was great & coffee even better. Really enjoyed my coffee. Service wasn’t rude but was very unfriendly. Very stoic and serious, straight to the point. Seemed bothered by our presence and a question on the menu. The dining area wasn’t clean and upon walking in, everyone was standing around (we were the only ones in there) so not sure why it was so messy. Perhaps they were taking a break in between a rush which is understandable! I will give it another shot soon.“

“Authentic Italian local eatery! Highly recommend if in town. The pizza was cooked to crispy thin crust perfection and the generous toppings were impressive! Huge bang for your buck! Stayed busy with a 5-15 wait but well worth it! Great atmosphere and staff! I will be going back next time I'm craving some good food and am near!“

“Just found my new favorite spot to get my subs (grinders) and much more. I ordered a steak sub, and let me tell yall...it was one of the bests I've ever had. The owners are the perfect example of what a restaurant owners should be, very welcoming, and super friendly. Very cozy place, and they're open until 3 am on Fridays and Saturdays. Yall have to give them a try if yall haven't yet. Can't wait to try everything they have on their menu.“

“Milano's is consistently good! Toni can make an amazing Martini with a charming smile to boot ☺️ Great food and amazing service every time. Worth a mention that if you get Brittany as your waitress, you will be well taken care of!“

“Under new Ownership. The Grinders are really NOT GOOD Especially the ham & american "cheese". The American is the cheap fake like kraft singles type cheese. The food is also Quite Pricey, but who isn't. You can now order online now & its easy. The pizza and dinners are really good stick to that the grinders are REALLY bad. I'd eat subway over these grinders hands down.“

“The BEST BLT I've had in YEARS! Perfectly cooked bacon, portions of each ingredient just right, and the grinder roll was perfectly toasted for a nice crunch yet soft and easy to take a bite. DELICIOUS! All for a fair price at that. 5 ? for sure :)“

“No doubt a 5 star review for this pizza place! When we came in we were told we could get seated anywhere we’d like . Our two children were offered high chairs. Our waiter was very pleasant. The food was ready quite fast!! you could tell the food was homemade , the mozzarella sticks were out of this world! Overall we were very pleased with our experience!“

“Best pizza in the area along with the best prices! I literally pass 5 other pizza shops to get here (1 of which used to be my favorite). Can’t beat the price or quality. Wish I found them 5 years ago! And the owner is honest, I accidentally overpaid and she was quick to let me know. It’s definitely worth the 15-20 minute drive for us. Btw, it’s a small restaurant easy to miss and drive by“

“Wow, what a fantastic spot for a quick slice! From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted warmly by the owner, who promptly confirmed they offered cheese and pepperoni slices. Though I initially tried to pay with a card, they kindly informed me they only accept cash, directing me to the nearby ATM. Within minutes, my order of four slices, totaling around eight dollars, was served – one neatly packed to go, and the other plated for immediate enjoyment. To top it off, the owner generously included a complimentary can of soda. As I savored my slice, I couldn't help but appreciate the friendly atmosphere, even catching snippets of lively conversation from fellow patrons. A solid 10/10 experience all around!“

“My fiance and I went here for the very first time. He is a chef. He knows excellent food. The food is excellent, I had gotten the steak grinder with cheese mushrooms, and the bread was perfect, the steak was season perfect, and cooked perfect, my fiance had gotten the fish and chips.. fish was cooked perfect and seasoning perfect, and the french fries were nice and crunchy, the taste was perfect. We have to say this is the Best Place in Easthampton Massachusetts, to get any food. We have been back 3 times already. Now to the customer service, they are so friendly and inviting to talk too, just great people. The place is very clean. We love it here. Thank you for making our experience fantastic every time. Thank you, Linda & Ferdinand“

“Top notch restaurant with first rate cuisine/cocktails and a nice, casual atmosphere. The food and drinks are comparable to what you would find in West Hartford or Newbury St. in Boston. Even the chicken breast, which I have seen far more expensive restaurants struggle with, was cooked to perfection. Honestly, if they were in NYC, they would probably be Michelin rated, they're that good. If Northampton can get a few more restaurants of this quality, it might just become a dining destination.“

“I moved to the area just today and what a perfect place to have my first dinner! From Ben's warm welcome as I stumbled up the stairs to Sid's excellent service. I was lucky enough to get probably the best table,one at a window. The dinner was excellent, loved the fresh bread with olive oil, the herbivore dinner, and dessert with coffee. The atmosphere was eloquent yet casual, warm and comfortable. I plan on many visits to come!“

“My body thanks me for such a delicious meal today. Upset with myself that I took no good picture but means I need to come back again. Came here with family after going to a retirement party. We ordered stuffed mushrooms and fried mozzarella for appetizers. Has to be some of the best fried mozzarella I have ever had with that perfect crisp bite and oozing cheese. Everyone ordered fillet. Cook it to how you like it, rare is indeed rare and look as a medium rare comes away it should too. I have some leftovers so looking forward to having that for lunch Sunday this week. Thought about steak and eggs for breakfast but I am still full! For dessert my aunt wanted to order three things by insisted how full everyone was we only ordered two. We all had cappuccinos and I asked the waitress to get me a scoop of ice cream for mine as well as order a chocolate cake and tiramisu. Chocolate cake was dry, tiramisu was out of this world and I am not a fan of tiramisu. The end of the day I had a very positive experience and looking forward to bringing a date here someday.“

“Ordered the Caprese, New England Combo, and the Amherst pizzas. All pizzas were of good quality and very tasty. The ordering process via their website was straightforward, and the delivery was prompt, with the pizzas arriving hot. A reliable option for anyone in the mood for a good pizza.“

“Very friendly staff. Food was. Great and they went above and beyond great customer service.Dietary restrictions: I am a diabetic so I have a lot of restrictions, but I was able to find a selection that fit my dietKid-friendliness: Open floor plan where the kids got to move around and enjoy themselves.“

“I love this shop, just truly wish the chefs understood extra. When you're paying more money for an ingredient you should get it. I shouldnt have to put emphasis on actually giving me my moneya worth. This happens all the time and I just don't get it.“

“Came for dinner last night with my dad, and I had the pasta martigiana (fettuccine with onion and bacon in a garlic and olive oil sauce).It was a little on the greasy/oil side but very tasty nonetheless. The interior of the restaurant is comfy and relaxing. Our waitress was very friendly and professional. Definitely would like to come again!“

“We had a very nice waiter who was helpful and our apps were very good_ garlic bread, blue crab ravioli , Caesar's salad , but my fra diavolo sauce was just ok and my crème brûlée was not that good. It's also really hard to find parking in the area.“

“It was my first visit, and I'm from oit of town. The place looked good. The server was nice. They got our pizza order mixed up with another person's, and they made us a whole new pizza. When the bill came, the manager didn't charge us for pizza!! How awesome was that. I will definitely return on my next visit.“

“While short on atmosphere it is long on great food and service. This is our go to spot (usually on Wednesday) and all our boys love it. My son gets the “chicken tendies”, while the older peeps get pizza. Their pizza is so good! If it was closer to us we would get it for take out all the time.“