23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cape Neddick

“Great tasting today at Odd by Nature Brewing. Enjoyed the Kolsch Bandicoot and Mambo Mentality - Big in Japan was great too! Thanks Tim for sharing your brewing expertise - we will be back!“

“Beer was solid, highly recommend the Mexican Lager. The fries are excellent. I got the BH Burger it was delicious. My wife got a bacon cheeseburger, and it was overcooked, more like beef Jerry. The chairs are for from comfortable, you are not able to sit back in them without sliding down. All in all I do recommend to give this place a try.“

“DELICOUS PIZZA YUMYUMYUMYUM“

“It's a pretty small place with only a couple of tables, so it looks like they do a lot of takeout. We ordered the 'big blue' and the 'meatball margarita', both were awesome. The honey lime Sriracha wings were also great, not very spicy.the prices are very fair. I went here because I got gas across the street, and I'll definitely be back.“

“Bridgette is amazing. She has such great energy and personality. Quality atmosphere and aesthetic. All around amazing place. Been here many times and never fails to impress. Highly recommend if you’re in the Portsmouth area and want a small place to enjoy good food and friendly staff.“

“We finally stopped in here recently and we were so overwhelmed, in a great way, at the slice options. Pizza is always a battle for us as we don't often like the same types.We got the sicilian slice and a spinach roll. Both were absolutely tasty. They were very busy with takeout orders but still go to ours rather quickly.Cannot wait to go back and try other things.“

“never have we ever had a bad meal here! Everything is fresh & extremely tasty! One sub gives me 2 meals & my wife 3! they go out of their way as well. Pleasant & friendly when ordering & picking the food up. Will not go anywhere else for subs or pizza!“

“Grandma’s pizza. The best slice on the sea coast.“

“Discovered this gem of a place while staying in York for vacation. It was absolutely amazing!! They had something for everyone. I got Anthony's Italian and not only was it super delicious, but it was ginormous as well. Grabbed a couple of their jumbo cupcakes as well and they did not disappoint. If you are in York for any reason, make sure to stop by! I can't wait to go back.“

“If you are craving pizza, this is hands down the best joint to eat it from. Let me tell you, they make a MEANNNN meatball pizza (10/10!) I recommend also trying their vegetarian pizza and Hawaiian pizza. If you have the room for a sweet treat right after, go for the brownie sundae—it’s superb :) The bakery attached to it is so adorable. The pizzas are never overwhelmingly greased up and they are so worth every penny.“

“Had an awesome experience at the oar house this weekend. Got to sit at the bar and taste some new creations from the bartender. Was really cool watching the experimentation and getting a first glance at the upcoming drinks. Snagged a couple of photos ??“

“This place used to be a surface level parking lot. So, automatic positive review. This business seems to go through little changes all the time. I miss the water stations, the swing chairs, and the new uniforms give a corporate feel that I don’t think fits the beautiful community environment they’ve created. It seems the lounge spaces disappear in favor of more tables.The bar area is very nice as well as the fire place during winter. I am very excited to see how the outside dining area will develop as the weather warms up.“

“I live right down the street and frequently get take out from here. I haven't eaten anything from here that I haven't thoroughly enjoyed. Good pizza and subs, very reasonable prices, and a friendly and hard working staff. The inside is a bit dated but spacious and clean, though take out seems to the go-to for most.At the time of this review they do deliver after 3pm, though we've never used this service.I highly recommend this place for an easy and affordable way to feed the family!“

“Menu is Limited ESPECIALLY the Pizza Menu, due to my Fixed income I've only had their Butter Pasta with Cheese from their kid's Menu, their Caesar Salad and Cheese Pizza. Prices for me are Expensive but the food I've had has been good, my brother LOVES their Pizza whenever I've taken my leftovers home. Their Caesar Salad is both a perfect size for me as well as yummy, staff have been so nice and friendly. love Jordan and Kim,“

“First off as soon as you walk in you are greeted very Respectfully. We were in a 6 person group and everything we had was fantastic. Some of the best Italian food I've had in a long time. Pasta was made in house and fresh and the ficcocia bread was fresh and amazing. Will come here again for sure when visiting.“

“So we happen upon this pizza place, which was just great. It was two for one pizza night tonight so we ended up getting two huge, thin crust pizzas. The first was a stuffed potato pizza. It had mashed potatoes, chunks of bacon, a white creamer sauce, drizzled, and it was really really good. The melt of tastes were great. We sat in the bar area, and we could see the guys making pizza in the wood burning pizza oven. That was really cool. The second pizza we got, was the not so traditional margarita, pizza. Very thin crust, fresh, tomato slices, and buffalo mozzarella. Lots of basil also. Something about the roasted tomato slices were just really really tasty though I don't usually like that. Lastly, I didn't get the name of our waiter, he was a very nice guy with curly dark hair. Seemto be the only wait staff in the whole restaurant other than the bartender. But he did great. He was juggling many tables at once and didn't stop for a second , but we thought he was great.“

“I recently dined at Bubba Fryes Wings and Things, and it was quite the experience. I ordered two chicken tender lunch boxes.The fries in one of the boxes tasted a bit like they'd seen better days, but the onion rings in the other were surprisingly good. The chicken tenders were large and satisfying, with a tasty and complex seasoning they call "Bubba dust." They had a great crispy fry on them, and the barbecue sauce was well-made.To my surprise, they also served a Caesar salad, and it was actually great. The cheese, thick Caesar dressing, and fresh greens made for a pleasant surprise. The croutons were on the larger side and had a great texture and taste.The service was friendly both on the phone and during pick-up. I would definitely recommend giving Bubba Fryes Wings and Things a try; I'm already planning my next visit.“

“The food here is great for the price. Especially the fries! They don't lie when they say that people love them, cause I do! The interior is kinda eh once you see Portsmouth just across the bridge. Service was pretty quick, nice staff, and overall a great time!“

“Awesome PIZZA, great sauce, cheese not greasy and just the right amount, flavorful toppings. Worth the drive just north of town center. As a family we've been going to Ogunquit for decades and have family who summer there. We've tried almost every pizza in town, even have it delivered to the beach for dinner, and nothing ever has prompted me to review. Years ago we tried OGT House and it was nothing great. This past week the kids wanted pizza so we tried it again after "Yelping" Wow! a wonderful surprise, we've found our pizza joint. We ordered 4 lg for 7 people (Green pepper/onion, pepperoni, cheeses and bbq chicken which was amazing) 2 slices left, need I say more?“

“Every year we stop here to get the steak sub with onions and peppers and we are very pleased every time. The bread is the softest we had. Not sure if the two guys are thee owners but very pleasant. I would recommend this place for sure. We drive through York just to stop here . It’s just an old fashion Pizza shop with great food. Thanks guys.“

“The breakfast was very good and plentiful;. New owner has a great personality abd is being innovative in the menu !“

“Saw the story of Amato's on a food show. Had a chance to stop at remote location on my ride home. The original italian sub was delicious. Everything about it was great. Fresh vegetable and a delicious roll. Highly recommend getting one if you are in Maine.“

“My friends and I have been coming here at like 2am for a while now and I love the atmosphere. The owner and employees are all so inviting and kind and the food is incredible! Especially their cannolis. I love the chocolate covered cannoli!Thank you so much for being part of “