Ordered a 14 inch 3 topping pizza for pickup recently and was shocked at the price. Look, I understand food costs have risen and it's hard times for businesses but $45 plus tip for a relatively small pizza? I called the order in, staff was very nice and the pizza was ready for pickup in 20 minutes. The parking lot is great because there is nowhere else to park at this location. I actually didn't know they had a parking lot until I picked this pizza up. I ordered the pizza to bring to my dad on his birthday and I'm sad to say he wasn't as impressed as I'd hope he would be. To be fair, I wasn't as impressed with the pizza as much as I had been in the past. The crust was rather crunchy and the rest of the pizza was floppy such that the toppings slid off if you didn't support the slice while eating. I appreciate that they make their own dough but I probably won't be back due to the prices.
Michael Sharitt
The pizza here was fantastic. The have good choices and everything tastes freshly made.I did find the prices here slightly higher than other places in the area. While it was good to splurge, there may be time that's taken into account.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Pitt
There is a famous pizza place in New Haven Connecticut, Pepe's, the pizza here is that good! This place is an untouched time capsule of amazing service and great food. Mangia!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Topping Pizza, Four Toppings Pizza
Jacob B
Sandwiches are awesome. Pizza is delicious but pricy.Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, veggie subs.Parking: A dozen or so spots to park.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: blt Sandwich, 12 Inch Pepperoni Pizza
Noelle C.
How is a 4 topping large pizza $92.45 after tax? How is this not a bigger story? I don't understand.
Toni K.
One of our favorite spots to grab a pie! It's always funny when they know who it is on the phone everyone is so nice. There is plenty of room in there too so you don't have to worry about bumping pizzas with someone!
Vincent J.
The pizza was good. It was a gas station style American pizza that had enhanced crust. You want to eat this pizza within 20 minutes of your order before oil sinks in. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and the amount of pepperoni was overwhelming after the second slice. Finally I think almost 30$ for a one topping pizza is definitely on the mort expensive end versus other businesses around the area. Unless you are craving the good old American pizza experience or having a nostalgic memory from the past I would probably try some other places first.
Blake Cannon
Good pizza but the price is crazy!!! You could get a amazing pie at Profenno”s in Westbrook for 1/2 the cost and if not better… just sayingParking: It was ok
Recommended dishes: 14 Pepperoni Pizza
Lisa Ellington
Greatvpizza and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 14 Pepperoni Pizza
Cynthia Richards
Food was great but the little man at the counter was rude. The price are out of sight and they need to update the prices
Food expensive out of breadLousy serviceSandwich was made
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Joe S.
Pizza was very good. They actually use pizza ovens here instead of those stupid carosel ovens. My 20 inch pizza with two toppings was $65, $67 with a 20 oz soda. Based on the price alone I will not return. I would have just gone somewhere else but I wanted to taste what a $65 pizza would taste like. It was good but it wasn't worth nearly $65!!!!!!!!!. I can get a 20 inch pizza with 2 toppings in Auburn for $26 and it comes with a free 2 liter soda. Don't know how these people are still in business.
Ordered a 14 inch 3 topping pizza for pickup recently and was shocked at the price. Look, I understand food costs have risen and it's hard times for businesses but $45 plus tip for a relatively small pizza? I called the order in, staff was very nice and the pizza was ready for pickup in 20 minutes. The parking lot is great because there is nowhere else to park at this location. I actually didn't know they had a parking lot until I picked this pizza up. I ordered the pizza to bring to my dad on his birthday and I'm sad to say he wasn't as impressed as I'd hope he would be. To be fair, I wasn't as impressed with the pizza as much as I had been in the past. The crust was rather crunchy and the rest of the pizza was floppy such that the toppings slid off if you didn't support the slice while eating. I appreciate that they make their own dough but I probably won't be back due to the prices.
The pizza here was fantastic. The have good choices and everything tastes freshly made.I did find the prices here slightly higher than other places in the area. While it was good to splurge, there may be time that's taken into account.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There is a famous pizza place in New Haven Connecticut, Pepe's, the pizza here is that good! This place is an untouched time capsule of amazing service and great food. Mangia!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: One Topping Pizza, Four Toppings Pizza
Sandwiches are awesome. Pizza is delicious but pricy.Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza, veggie subs.Parking: A dozen or so spots to park.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: blt Sandwich, 12 Inch Pepperoni Pizza
How is a 4 topping large pizza $92.45 after tax? How is this not a bigger story? I don't understand.
One of our favorite spots to grab a pie! It's always funny when they know who it is on the phone everyone is so nice. There is plenty of room in there too so you don't have to worry about bumping pizzas with someone!
The pizza was good. It was a gas station style American pizza that had enhanced crust. You want to eat this pizza within 20 minutes of your order before oil sinks in. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and the amount of pepperoni was overwhelming after the second slice. Finally I think almost 30$ for a one topping pizza is definitely on the mort expensive end versus other businesses around the area. Unless you are craving the good old American pizza experience or having a nostalgic memory from the past I would probably try some other places first.
Good pizza but the price is crazy!!! You could get a amazing pie at Profenno”s in Westbrook for 1/2 the cost and if not better… just sayingParking: It was ok
Recommended dishes: 14 Pepperoni Pizza
Greatvpizza and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 14 Pepperoni Pizza
Food was great but the little man at the counter was rude. The price are out of sight and they need to update the prices
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Really slow, sandwiches were not good at
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
On our way home with a great pie. lol
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is awesome. It's just so good.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food expensive out of breadLousy serviceSandwich was made
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pizza was very good. They actually use pizza ovens here instead of those stupid carosel ovens. My 20 inch pizza with two toppings was $65, $67 with a 20 oz soda. Based on the price alone I will not return. I would have just gone somewhere else but I wanted to taste what a $65 pizza would taste like. It was good but it wasn't worth nearly $65!!!!!!!!!. I can get a 20 inch pizza with 2 toppings in Auburn for $26 and it comes with a free 2 liter soda. Don't know how these people are still in business.