“My youngest wanted dessert from here for his birthday. I've always been very pleased coming here. The staff is always super friendly and helpful. The desserts are delicious. And they're very reasonably priced. Four Bundt cakes runs ya something like $22. Not cheap but very reasonable compared to other dessert places and this one is better. We got snickerdoodle, chocolate chocolate chip, strawberries and cream, and cookies and cream. All four were fabulous. And we each got two servings out of ours. It's a winner!“
“I'm so sad that the store front is closed as I LOVED their cupcakes (much better than the other cupcake stores in Memphis). I would definitely recommend them as I think they are still available, just not as a store front. I MISS YOU GUYS!“
“We've had 2 cakes from The Cakesmith and they were both amazing! They were as delicious as they were beautiful. Communication and response to messages was timely and friendly. Can't wait until our next birthday (which is mine!) to order another one! 10/10 recommend!“
Bakery • $
“Got my graduation and birthday cake from here and let me just say…. SUPERB, AMAZING, CAKE WAS JUST EVERYTHING GOOD! I will NEVER shop anywhere else for a cake! It’s pretty and I started eating it a day before my birthday. Plus I ordered it a day before my birthday and it was not rushed, it felt like I put this order in months in advance!“
“I ordered some of the girlscout cookies while hanging out in a live on tiktok. I was a girlscout and i had always followed the owners page and story and I finally decided to order. They took a few days to get here and when I opened them I felt an overwhelming feeling of “I am so PROUD of her” I have only tried the funfetti one which was very soft and has A LOT of sprinkles haha. I then tried the chocolate mint but it wasn’t bad, I just think it would be better if you get them fresh from the store! But for a shipped cookie it was way better than you’d expect, it might be good heated up or mixed with ice cream! The flavor was good, so close to those thin mints I remember from childhood. I still have two flavors to try but I can’t be a Cookie Monster so I put them in the freezer and I have no doubts that they won’t be as delicious and fun as the first two were (I think it’s going to last me a month these cookies are HUGE! So totally worth the cost.) I feel lucky I finally came full circle watching you in your days when your mom was still here and then all of the ups and downs leading to this moment brought a tear to my eyes that you did it and you’re doing so so well my love. Thank you for not giving up. You’re kicking butt! My next goal is to come to your shop and see it in person! Sending so many hugs and so much love from Minnesota, Swanky“
“So thankful a friend recommended old town bakery! I waited a little too late to get a cake, and no one was able to help me except this bakery. The communication was great and the staff was friendly. I specified the style of cake I needed, and they delivered! Thank you so much! You now have a return customer! Honestly I don't think the picture does this cake any justice.“