James Original Salt Water Taffy, Atlantic City

1519 Boardwalk, Atlantic City
(609) 344-1519

Recent Reviews

Robin McClary

Atlantic City institution but like everything else could use a

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Su

Visited this historic building to see "Arteriors" exhibit by AC Arts Foundation.Building is sadly closed and will be removed. Still beautiful facade, hope they restore and keep it.

Atmosphere: 5

The Pizza Snob of NEPA & SNJ

On the day I shopped, a Thursday, the location was closed. There may have been a sign on the door redirecting customers to their sister store, Fralinger's; the store I had just passed...I was grateful this 2nd store was open and there was loose candy pateons are able to choose from, in this post-Covid era. There were also sugar free options. The cashier said the store would close on Oct 29 (2023) and reopen in Spring. I was displeased to hear this, but glad it was open that day; as I was saved a trip to Ocean City, NJ and this saved me time and money. I traveled more than 4 hours after that visit to deliver the candies. The taffy and butter mints will travel 700 miles to Maine as their final destination.

Service: 4

John C.

placed four Valentine Day Orders for Chocolate Candy totaling about $200. Three of the orders had $15.99 for Taffy added on without my permission-I am not a fan of salt water taffy!!. I placed a call to the order center who said they would send an email to correct this situation-No response. I left three emails-no response. I tried leaving a voice mail on their 6093441519 customer service-which does not take phone messages. I left a message for their administrative staff-no response. I have been a loyal customer for more than 20 years of Bayard Chocolates who were taken over by James. Guess this looks like the last order-tomorrow I will call the credit card company and dispute all charges.

Leh Nyo Rah

I thought i was going to end up in shame and disgrace why because I was seriously warned by friends who told me not to get involve in Bitcoin investment due to their past experience but I told them my case is different because I was so desperate to make money not until I saw a post on how a man made huge investment profits from MRS TAISHA CARSON I build up some trust and believe and I contacted her and truly everything start working fine for me. I specially give all thanks to MRS TAISHA CARSON for being a blessing to my life. contact her via:-

Albert Monillas

I bought salt water taffy for my dying aunt who wanted these in hospice. She called to tell me they were inedible and stale. Her nurse agreed. I contacted James Candy and asked if they could replace these salt water taffy with the butter mints. I called. I emailed. I mailed. No response. I’m shocked.

Nazeef Ahmed

I'm taking this time to express my gratitude to Mrs. Magdalene James who helped me trade in crypto with my little capital of $300 which then earned me $4,000. I was referred to Magdalene by Lisa Karon and all her trading techniques and withdrawal is easy. You can reach her for your best trading experience.

Sunshine Calm

Stale horrible salt water taffy. Selling year old pandemic candy and don't bother calling. Female was argumentative and all I was trying to do was let her know I won't be the only one calling. Please don't waste your money here

Nicole Valles

Great selection but the taffy was not very fresh.

Alan P.

I grew up on this stuff, but over the decades, something changed. The flavors are so...minor and bland. The peppermint still has zing, but the licorice is tasteless. I recently tried the "Filled Center" Taffy. UGH! The illustration on the box cover and on the website shows taffy cut open and oozing with centers. But the centers are non-existent. I saw teeny "ribbons" on each the ends of each piece, but that taffy tasted weird. Nothing juicy. False advertising! There were two stick-on gold stars on the box; hmmm, wonder if that is a quality control warning? Tasted like these pieces were old. A waste of money.

Felice B.

Couldn't wait to try! Planning a birthday in Los Angeles and thought taffy and molasses pops would go great with my party favors...knowing none of my girls had ever been to the Jersey shore they would certainly be a surprise hit! Bought a pound of taffy and a dozen pops. Pops arrived with all the sticks coated in chocolate but taffy was fine. I took a pic and sent to their customer service. I received a respectable reply but it was all down hill from there. They offered a replacement of 2 pounds of taffy, and were concerned about the pops melting as the weather gets warmer, but they only offered a molasses flavor taffy (because the pops were molasses???) but that neither fit my flavor nor color scheme. A 2-3 day delay of back and forth, very vague emails and a few ignored voice mails ensued (you can't speak with a human unless your placing an order!) and for all this effort I finally got another one-pound box of taffy - not the two as promised. Such a waste of time! It's as if no one's paying attention..kinda like the lady behind the counter on her phone! Lol

Peter A.

They took over the Bayards Chocolate company... I ordered some of the chocolate covered marshmallows. On their website they look just like the Bayards Chocolate covered Marshmallows I loved as a kid. What I got were square... the marshmallow was some disgusting filling not a REAL marshmallow like Bayards always used. And the chocolate was a cheap disgusting waxy chocolate. NOT the creamy rich chocolate from Bayards!!! Worst of all... they were about $2.25 per marshmallow NOT SHIPPED... shipping was another $25... That's some SHADY @#$%^ right there!!!!

Leslie Kemp

I love salt water taffy and always loved Fralingers growing up. I ordered the 2lb box

Julie Woods

I spent $118 with this company all for them to claim my address wasn't valid. They lied and said the post office doesn't recognize the address. How does the post office not recognize and APO address? Why do they have APO as a shipping option if they don't ship there?

Anne Marie Fiducioso Warchal

They took my $200 order online, never shipped the product, never returned any call or email over the last THREE WEEKS!!!! They are crooks, thieves, they stole my hard earned money & I’m now in a credit card nightmare trying to dispute the charges. Never again!!

Load More

James Original Salt Water Taffy, Atlantic City

1519 Boardwalk, Atlantic City, NJ 08401
(609) 344-1519