11 Best Italian Restaurants in Bridgewater

“Tried Carlo’s for the first time and got a 1/2 grandma 1/2 grandpa pie…..delicious!!!! So tasty!!! It also smelled amazing on the drive home. Got the sautéed broccoli which was also really good….loaded with flavor. Can’t wait to go back again!“

“One of the best Italian delis in central NJ! I have tried roast beef, tuna salad and chicken salad sandwiches. They come in big portions and good for more than one meal. The ingredients are very fresh. I customize my subs with balsamic flavor and just taste soooo good!“

“I have a rare food allergy which can often be challenging to accommodate. I was beyond please when the server had the chef come out and the chef told me I could have anything I wanted customized so it would be safe for me to eat. My dish was absolutely amazing and I even had the manage come and check on me as well to make sure my allergy was taken care of. I will definitely be dining again“

“I placed an order for pick up. Everything we ordered was delicious. The mozzarella sticks were so good. Never have I ever picked up an order brought it home and the sticks were still hot. When you bit into them them were still stringy. My boys bit into one and can pull the cheese out as long as there arm. Highly recommend!“

“Had the truck for my daughter’s graduation party on 6/25 and everything was phenomenal. Pizza is as authentic Neapolitan as you’ll find this side of the Atlantic. We had the truck 8 years ago for a prior graduation and guests who attended that event were thrilled to see Lombardi’s here again. First timers were truly impressed. Professional, immaculate and all around nice people. Jerry S Watchung“

“Tasty, thin and crispy pizza. We walked in looking for a few slices to eat there and he had a fresh plain pizza right on the counter. He warmed up a few slices for us and we took a seat. The pizza tasted great and had a great crisp to it. Not too cheesy and not too bready. I'd check out Joe's for takeout in the future for sure.“

“First time visit. A very nice experience. Excellent service from the time we arrived, throughout the evening. Nice menu. Every dish was excellent. A proper desert cart. The cheesecake was very nice. We look forward to many more evenings at Cafe Emilia.“

“I visited with my daughter and we were very pleased with the atmosphere, the service, the food and above all with the attention of Mr. Juan, very professional and above all a gentleman, my congratulations to Olive Garden for having Mr. Juan on their team. Without a doubt I would return to this wonderful place“

“Pizza is great, sandwiches are even better! Been going to this place for almost 10 years now. I always like to try other pizzerias in the area, and always find Sopranos to be my “go-to”. Owner is a standup guy and very personable. Also helps if your a Rangers fan! LGR!!!“

“Love this place! Byron is a great guy and is so great with the customers- really makes you feel at home! Great food consistently! Best pizza in Jersey! Jersey pie and white pie with spinach are amazing as well as the margarita pie!!!!! Must have!!!!“

“We ordered Chicken Giambotta tonight with a side of meatballs for pick up. My husband has ordered this many times when we were at the restaurant. It was absolutely delicious as always. Thank you Toscanas for being open for take out during the Coronavirus.“