This place has really good pizza. Chief at the front counter seems to be known by everyone . As everyone says hello by name .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice Main St
Zach Langowski
Been working in this area for 11 years, kind of disappointed I just found this spot. Very good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lorraine Franz
Good NJ Italian restaurant. Fairly new interior decoration, so all is clean and new. Good service, good food, all in all a pleasant dinner experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Rogelio Carrasquillo
Great Pizza and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Bezzone
Friendly neighborhood spot, with excellent pizza and simple Italian pastas and sandwiches for any type of guest. Good place to bring the kids and take out. The private room in the back is perfect for any kind of family, friends or company party. Love it here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza - Sunday Gravy, Tomato Pie
max l.
The photo explains it all, good food very enjoyable experience. Manager is a complete stud
Eric Williams
The Shop is awesome! I work nearby so I come here often for lunch.The pizza is delicious, everything from the plain to the elaborate. Thin crust, great sauce, and generous on the cheese. I highly recommend the Pesto Grandma and the Chicken Fresco. I watched the chef build the Chicken Fresco, and it was like watching an artist. The fresh mozzarella, tomaotoes, and basil are delicious; the drizzle of balsamic brings it to the next level.They have a great lunch combo during the week, any two slices plus a can of soda (or bottle of water) for just $7. Awesome.Shout out to Gustavo behind the counter, he's a good guy and is passionate about food.Update: Today I had the Italian Beef sandwich, and it was fantastic. Nicely spicy, but not overly. Really great cheesesteak with onions and hot peppers, and generous cheese on top!Parking: Lots of free parking, but it is a 2 hour limit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keri M.
Was loving the Shop when it first opened but lately we have been disappointed. Pizza is just okay now and when we ordered a panino it was on a hoagie roll not even toasted. Not sure what happened but feel like we will start ordering elsewhere going forward. Shame because it had become our new favorite and we were ordering every week but sadly we won't be doing that anymore.
Frank I.
Very good pizza, in my opinion the best in the Chatham. Try the main Street pizza.They have the weirdest name for a pizza place, we call it the pizza place next to CVS :)
Bill J.
Pizza is meh. Nice and light and well balanced sauce to cheese but a very standard dough, thrown together one hour rest taste. No complexity to the crust. Penne vodka was the most tasteless vodka sauce I've ever had. There was no hint of garlic or onion or any aromatics. Honestly seemed like mostly cream and the slightest touch of tomato. Sandwiches were not expensive but upon receiving it was very small and the bread was not good. Had higher hopes for this place. I'll give them a try again in a few months and hope to update.
Just moved into town and this is the closest pizza place to me. Got chicken parm dinner, dinner was so greasy I ended up throwing it out.
War Crimes
Very gud. Paul Va happened to be here. 10/10. gus is nice. He hand squeezes very good water out of the grounds of chatham. It is refreshing. Gus also hikes to the chatham mountains and gathersexquisite water. it is 3$
Konrad Roslonek
Pizza is great, well priced. Working next door also helps with convenience. I would love to see a specialty pie rotated in maybe once a week or month in addition to their already great staples to add some more variety. They do great pesto sauce which would be an amazing addition to drizzle on their pizzas or perhaps a bruschetta pesto pie as a pie added to the rotation.
Tim S.
The Shop has been here for over a year but just tried it for first time. In my view - terrible name but I judge these pizzerias by their meatballs and sauce and I have to say they were both fantastic. Little breading, great flavor - and a nice zesty sauce. Also tried their signature salad which was also great. Next time I try the pizza !
Alex Poelzing
Very clean establishment, and very nice. BUT; Italian Beef Panino is was overpriced and tasteless. Was basically a Philly cheesesteak smothered in oil. Didn’t taste very good.Will definitely try the other menu items for eventually and update my rating.
This place has really good pizza. Chief at the front counter seems to be known by everyone . As everyone says hello by name .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice Main St
Been working in this area for 11 years, kind of disappointed I just found this spot. Very good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good NJ Italian restaurant. Fairly new interior decoration, so all is clean and new. Good service, good food, all in all a pleasant dinner experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great Pizza and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly neighborhood spot, with excellent pizza and simple Italian pastas and sandwiches for any type of guest. Good place to bring the kids and take out. The private room in the back is perfect for any kind of family, friends or company party. Love it here!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza - Sunday Gravy, Tomato Pie
The photo explains it all, good food very enjoyable experience. Manager is a complete stud
The Shop is awesome! I work nearby so I come here often for lunch.The pizza is delicious, everything from the plain to the elaborate. Thin crust, great sauce, and generous on the cheese. I highly recommend the Pesto Grandma and the Chicken Fresco. I watched the chef build the Chicken Fresco, and it was like watching an artist. The fresh mozzarella, tomaotoes, and basil are delicious; the drizzle of balsamic brings it to the next level.They have a great lunch combo during the week, any two slices plus a can of soda (or bottle of water) for just $7. Awesome.Shout out to Gustavo behind the counter, he's a good guy and is passionate about food.Update: Today I had the Italian Beef sandwich, and it was fantastic. Nicely spicy, but not overly. Really great cheesesteak with onions and hot peppers, and generous cheese on top!Parking: Lots of free parking, but it is a 2 hour limit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was loving the Shop when it first opened but lately we have been disappointed. Pizza is just okay now and when we ordered a panino it was on a hoagie roll not even toasted. Not sure what happened but feel like we will start ordering elsewhere going forward. Shame because it had become our new favorite and we were ordering every week but sadly we won't be doing that anymore.
Very good pizza, in my opinion the best in the Chatham. Try the main Street pizza.They have the weirdest name for a pizza place, we call it the pizza place next to CVS :)
Pizza is meh. Nice and light and well balanced sauce to cheese but a very standard dough, thrown together one hour rest taste. No complexity to the crust. Penne vodka was the most tasteless vodka sauce I've ever had. There was no hint of garlic or onion or any aromatics. Honestly seemed like mostly cream and the slightest touch of tomato. Sandwiches were not expensive but upon receiving it was very small and the bread was not good. Had higher hopes for this place. I'll give them a try again in a few months and hope to update.
Restaurantji Recommends
Just moved into town and this is the closest pizza place to me. Got chicken parm dinner, dinner was so greasy I ended up throwing it out.
Very gud. Paul Va happened to be here. 10/10. gus is nice. He hand squeezes very good water out of the grounds of chatham. It is refreshing. Gus also hikes to the chatham mountains and gathersexquisite water. it is 3$
Pizza is great, well priced. Working next door also helps with convenience. I would love to see a specialty pie rotated in maybe once a week or month in addition to their already great staples to add some more variety. They do great pesto sauce which would be an amazing addition to drizzle on their pizzas or perhaps a bruschetta pesto pie as a pie added to the rotation.
The Shop has been here for over a year but just tried it for first time. In my view - terrible name but I judge these pizzerias by their meatballs and sauce and I have to say they were both fantastic. Little breading, great flavor - and a nice zesty sauce. Also tried their signature salad which was also great. Next time I try the pizza !
Very clean establishment, and very nice. BUT; Italian Beef Panino is was overpriced and tasteless. Was basically a Philly cheesesteak smothered in oil. Didn’t taste very good.Will definitely try the other menu items for eventually and update my rating.