We have never been here before and went late tonight to pick up surprise bags with random food from the Too Good To Go app (which is awesome that they are actively working to reduce their food waste by participating)...They just gained new regular customers. Hands down best pizza I've ever tasted. We will for sure be going back. And they are so nice and friendly there. Definitely will be recommending this place as a go-to for friends!!!
Indian curry spicy pizza. Achari garlic bread. Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Meet S.
Food was great but very pricey, ordered for pickup and a small pizza, medium pizza, fries and 2 drinks were 55$, prices aren't accurate on website so that didn't help either but food was delicious!
wendy heller
We love jimmy tomatoes!! It's the best penne vodka pie around, super clean and very friendly staff, our favorite pizza hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joella Lockette
Smells hits you right when you walk in! Great service and food taste fresh even though I picked up close to closing time.
We ordered a few Indian inspired pizzas from here and they were all incredible. We couldn't get enough. They all tasted fresh and healthy and flavorful.
Pat M.
Always looking for NJ pizzerias to try, today I had the chance to stop in at Jimmy Tomato's in Denville. I had seen a post from a Yelp friend who'd been here recently and knew I'd have to try it myself. I was not disappointed! I had a slice of the Dhoom Tandoori Chicken and it was different and delicious. Made with lots of spices, this slice had a real kick to it. If you're looking for a more traditional slice, they have those too. I'm not sure how long this place has been open, I was here a few years ago when it was under other ownership. The new owner was very friendly and took the time to let me know the details of the slice I had. There's plenty of parking and plenty of seating. Prices very reasonable too. Give Jimmy's a try!
Vraj Patel
Really good service we were like 20 people they didn’t messed up our order and special thing is they have Jain
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Miheer Patel
Very delicious and great place to visit. You get whatever you order no difference. Good place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Focht
This is a great little pizzaria! I'm pretty new to Indian food, and being a little cautious when my friend and I went to eat here I ordered a basic, traditional pizza and my friend selected one of their Indian pizzas. While my pizza was certainly delicious, I tried a piece of my friend's pizza and it was amazing! It was a totally unexpected taste, but somehow everything blended together perfectly. If you like Indian food, you should definitely try one of their specialty pizzas. I highly recommend this place and will definitely plan to visit again soon!
This place makes some seriously delicious fusion style Pizza with a Bombay twist. The Dhoom Tandoori Chicken Slice is Fire as is their version of a Traditional Cheese Pie which I got piping hot right out of the oven. Every Slice is Pizza Perfection in every way and full of incredible savory flavor. I will most definitely be stopping back here again and again whenever I find myself in the mood for this delicious one of a kind style Pizza. Jimmy Tomato's is YUMMMMMMERS in every Bite. Come And Get Your Munch On!!
Sucheta chatterjee
Recently we visited themThey specialises and inspired by the concept of Fusion pizza with Indian Italian flavours as in pizza pies with toppings and seasonings.Everyone in the world loves and eat pizza and it’s part of their menu and their effort was to bring them to you.We tried? Desi Masala Fries?Desi Masala Wings? ?Buffalo Chicken Pizza? Achari Paneer Pizza? ? Penne Chicken Tikka in pink sauce with garlic bread?Aerated DrinksAchari Paneer pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza is a must try ..It was a perfect amalgamation of all the ingredients and reasonably balanced spices, with just a right amount of cheese. Both have a perfect balanced flavours.They also offer a range of Indian style desi Masala wings and fries which was unique and mouth watering…In Tadka pasta we tried their chicken tikka in pink sauces , garlic breads..Do check out their menu for more options..They got an amazing Indian fusion pizzas and pastas that’s unlike any pizza you’ve had before. Stop by and experience this at Bombay curry pizza ?Staff was super courteous and helpful..Must visit … ☺️☺️________________________
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Achari Paneer Tikka
Atit Raval
I have tried "Indian flavor" pizza before at several places in US but this is by far the best Indian Pizza. Yes, its bit on the dry side but the flavors are amazing. I highly recommend trying their masala fries and paneer tikka pizza. Would come back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
FAST AID STEP 1
One of the best pizzas I ever had. Great place especially for Indian style pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
shweta b
Really best Indian style pizza....absolutely loved it, especially the crust and of course mazing taste ?
We have never been here before and went late tonight to pick up surprise bags with random food from the Too Good To Go app (which is awesome that they are actively working to reduce their food waste by participating)...They just gained new regular customers. Hands down best pizza I've ever tasted. We will for sure be going back. And they are so nice and friendly there. Definitely will be recommending this place as a go-to for friends!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chill Paneer Tikka Pizza, Achari Paneer Pizza, Chicken Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Indian curry spicy pizza. Achari garlic bread. Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great but very pricey, ordered for pickup and a small pizza, medium pizza, fries and 2 drinks were 55$, prices aren't accurate on website so that didn't help either but food was delicious!
We love jimmy tomatoes!! It's the best penne vodka pie around, super clean and very friendly staff, our favorite pizza hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Smells hits you right when you walk in! Great service and food taste fresh even though I picked up close to closing time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chill Paneer Tikka Pizza, Chicken Pizza
We ordered a few Indian inspired pizzas from here and they were all incredible. We couldn't get enough. They all tasted fresh and healthy and flavorful.
Always looking for NJ pizzerias to try, today I had the chance to stop in at Jimmy Tomato's in Denville. I had seen a post from a Yelp friend who'd been here recently and knew I'd have to try it myself. I was not disappointed! I had a slice of the Dhoom Tandoori Chicken and it was different and delicious. Made with lots of spices, this slice had a real kick to it. If you're looking for a more traditional slice, they have those too. I'm not sure how long this place has been open, I was here a few years ago when it was under other ownership. The new owner was very friendly and took the time to let me know the details of the slice I had. There's plenty of parking and plenty of seating. Prices very reasonable too. Give Jimmy's a try!
Really good service we were like 20 people they didn’t messed up our order and special thing is they have Jain
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very delicious and great place to visit. You get whatever you order no difference. Good place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a great little pizzaria! I'm pretty new to Indian food, and being a little cautious when my friend and I went to eat here I ordered a basic, traditional pizza and my friend selected one of their Indian pizzas. While my pizza was certainly delicious, I tried a piece of my friend's pizza and it was amazing! It was a totally unexpected taste, but somehow everything blended together perfectly. If you like Indian food, you should definitely try one of their specialty pizzas. I highly recommend this place and will definitely plan to visit again soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place makes some seriously delicious fusion style Pizza with a Bombay twist. The Dhoom Tandoori Chicken Slice is Fire as is their version of a Traditional Cheese Pie which I got piping hot right out of the oven. Every Slice is Pizza Perfection in every way and full of incredible savory flavor. I will most definitely be stopping back here again and again whenever I find myself in the mood for this delicious one of a kind style Pizza. Jimmy Tomato's is YUMMMMMMERS in every Bite. Come And Get Your Munch On!!
Recently we visited themThey specialises and inspired by the concept of Fusion pizza with Indian Italian flavours as in pizza pies with toppings and seasonings.Everyone in the world loves and eat pizza and it’s part of their menu and their effort was to bring them to you.We tried? Desi Masala Fries?Desi Masala Wings? ?Buffalo Chicken Pizza? Achari Paneer Pizza? ? Penne Chicken Tikka in pink sauce with garlic bread?Aerated DrinksAchari Paneer pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza is a must try ..It was a perfect amalgamation of all the ingredients and reasonably balanced spices, with just a right amount of cheese. Both have a perfect balanced flavours.They also offer a range of Indian style desi Masala wings and fries which was unique and mouth watering…In Tadka pasta we tried their chicken tikka in pink sauces , garlic breads..Do check out their menu for more options..They got an amazing Indian fusion pizzas and pastas that’s unlike any pizza you’ve had before. Stop by and experience this at Bombay curry pizza ?Staff was super courteous and helpful..Must visit … ☺️☺️________________________
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Achari Paneer Tikka
I have tried "Indian flavor" pizza before at several places in US but this is by far the best Indian Pizza. Yes, its bit on the dry side but the flavors are amazing. I highly recommend trying their masala fries and paneer tikka pizza. Would come back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best pizzas I ever had. Great place especially for Indian style pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really best Indian style pizza....absolutely loved it, especially the crust and of course mazing taste ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Achari Paneer Pizza, Bombay Chilli Cheese, Garlic Bread, Vegetable Pizza, Veggie Pizza