Lusty Lobster

88 Bay Ave, Highlands
(732) 291-1548

Recent Reviews

Katie Leasor

This place is the best ! Fresh fish, clams, lobsters and love their smoked whitefish pate. Some other local fish markets buy from them and resell at higher prices, but going direct to the source is the way to go. Nice people and I hope they stay around forever - am always satisfied with their products. Thank you !

Chris S.

Been there since I was a kid and same old greatness. Not the cheapest place on earth to get fresh seafood but the lobsters we purchased were VERY alive and rather feisty. The meal came out perfectly and always nice to see a place like this continue to thrive throughout the decades. Great staff to boot.Cheers

Jeslyn Lemke

Very fresh clams and oysters, affordable. Staff are super friendly. Place has an awesome selection of wild caught marine fish like swordfish. Swordfish was amazing too!

Phyllis D.

I love Lusty! The seafood is always fresh and it's a great value. They are my go to for lobster, crab cakes and oysters!

Jon Splarch

Freshest seafood I've ever had. Cocktail shrimp to die for!

Monica P.

M M Enjoyed very much having a lobster and corn just nice to sit outside had a good time with friends

Caroline D.

Best and freshest! my go to place for fish. Service is awesome. They are knowledgeable and quick with service Two clambakes and one lobsterboil all seafood from here excellent. Worth the price.

Katie L.

Been going here forever! Delicious seafood and local seafood market.

Alison Felix

I ordered two 3lb lobsters (steamed and cracked) and they were absolutely delicious! I drive about 45 minutes each way to Lusty Lobster because every visit it is totally worth it the travel. The Manager Andrew helped with my order and I look forward to my next visit!

Patty McCaffrey

Had their Cajun clam chowder today absolutely delicious!!!

Ruijin Song

Highly recommend their clam, no sand at all. Very fresh! And their oysters too. High quality with reasonable price.

Luis A.

I was working in the area and was looking for a place to eat. Not knowing it was more of a fish market than a deli. But I was hungry and saw there sign. From fresh fish to shrimp ,scallops , shrimp salad,lobster salad and soups. I tried there sea food minestrone and that was ok. But there seafood chili soup was amazing. OMG! I highly recommend this place. Thank you once again for you delicious foods and soups.

Jill Lynch

Seafood is suoer fresh. People there are nice. Yes you pay more but it's worth it to know it will be top quality. I recently called ahead a couple of days and ordered 20 lobsters for a private party. They packaged them nice and neat for me in a wax-lined box and put down plastic in my trunk so it wouldn't make a mess. They even carried out the box for me and put it in the car. Everyone raved about how sweet they were! Each year we have a lobster party and every year without fail we get the lobsters from Lusty Lobster. Also you should check out their holiday shrimp platters. They are professionally presented, sweet and succulent with their awesome cocktail sauce. It's a must have for the season!

R C.

Staying in Highlands for part of the summer and thrilled to have discovered this fish market. Everything I've gotten so far has been superior quality and fresh. Wonderful red snapper, shrimp cocktail, tuna fillets.

Ed M.

Fresh, fresh, fresh. The seafood platter is amazing. Looking forward to stop by for more.

Load More