13 Best Sandwich Shops near Hightstown

“It’s Friday again. Time to relax and order a few luncheon specials. We ordered the classic grilled chicken sandwich with extra chicken, spinach, tomatoes and cucumber ?. The other sub was the supreme meat ? with pepperoni ?, salami, capicola and provolone cheese ?. Oh so good ?.“

“This is just a great shop ran by awesome, friendly people. The bagels, sandwiches and food really is excellent. It always tastes so fresh. We get sandwiches or bagels multiple times per month and never disappointed. ( Cleaned up and have my daughter a new bagel after she leaned on table, did it with a smile, above and beyond). Thanks.“

“The lady is so nice and her hospitality is outstanding but the india guy was rude and didn't listen to me that I paid extra for cheese. And my sandwich was messy. From next time I will tell the lady to make my sandwich and I hope the owners take any action on this.“

“Stopped here between jobs at lunchtime and found a gem. Classic Italian was perfect. Even amount of lettuce and onion, thin tomato and the bread was super fresh. Would definetly recommend you skip WaWa which is two doors away and try this place out, you won't regret“

“Great tasting sandwiches. Their Sharp Italian is my favorite, high quality meats and some of the best sharp provolone I've had. Service can sometimes be slow, so it's a good idea to order ahead of you're going to be in a hurry“

“Some of the best subs around. I absolutely love this place. I recommend this place if you want a sandwich sub that you can overload and put as many toppings on as you want. They have choices from regular cold sandwich to hot sandwiches, buffalo chicken, and Philly cheesesteak. I recommend this place if you Are in for a New York style types sub. They were very professional and very helpful always clean and bright.“

“I’ve been a customer of this establishment since 2003. It is by my experience, the best sandwich shop in the Plainsboro/West Windsor area, bar none. The bread is excellent, and the meats are top quality! Service is always excellent. Tell them, Richard says “buy the Italian!”.Kid-friendliness: Kids are welcome“

“I was really happy they had free coffee and water. A bit tight for sitting area but still good.My reuben melt was $12. The sandwich was very good but not amazing. Maybe the beef was less than stellar or I don’t like reubens that much? Great service.I will be back.“

“First time in. Place is clean and neat.Cheesesteak for us today.Food was very good and flavorful. It’s Jersey mikes , you can’t go wrong .Prices are a little on the high side, but the quality of the meats and ingredients are there (which I’ll pay for any day of the week)Overall I’d recommend stopping in for a bite.The employees were all nice and friendly.“

“We've always had tasty sandwiches at JM's and were happy when this location opened near us. Tonight, we had excellent service and food prepared by David--not only did he make two killer subs, he checked to make sure they were just how we liked them and was super pleasant. Kudos to David!“

“On Sunday, April 14, 2022 I was passing through cranberry New Jersey decided to stop at Mr. sub to get a ham and cheese. They have two sizes 16 & 8 inch. I asked the female preparer. I didn’t get her name. My apologies. She was very nice. Ask her what size is 8 inch. She said “I was going to get smart and said 8 inches”. A friendly bantering. I was going to get smart back with her and say I should know what 8 inch look likes. Outstanding customer service.“

“Me and my friends visited yesterday, and we got take out but we ate at the cute tables out front.I got the chicken parm sandwich..: oh my gawd.Yall, let me tell you this was the best meal I’ve ever eaten in my entire life. Next time I visit I know where i’m going !“

“I've been hesitant to reveal our 'secret place' but Sandwich King deserves a great review. I live in NYC, the parents are in NJ. When I am nearing 8A each week I call in an order for p/u. The service is impeccable, food is excellent, over the years the staff which has not changed are very polite, punctual and efficient. At the counter you can see how fresh the food is. They keep the food prep area and the entire place super clean, spotless. They also have a nice seating area if you want a break from work or just to have a meal with a friend. I highly recommend, but let's keep it a secret. *We love the pork roll egg & cheese as well as the Italian hero*“