Aiello’s of Brooklyn

Was looking for a good ny/nj pizza and Aiello's didn't disappoint! I love Sicilian and I wanted to try it when I saw photos. From other reviews and their menu, it doesn't appear they sell slices. You have to order a whole pizza. The Sicilian is only one size, 12 inches but I'm not gonna complain, it won't go to waste.

First off the food is really good!! My brother and I have celiac and the gluten free Sicilian and garlic knots are amazing and taste like regular pizza. Our guests who had the regular pizza, regular Sicilian, garlic bread and meatballs also loved their meal. We ordered yesterday and the person who took our order over the phone was so nice and explained how it works with ordering gluten free (needs to be placed a few hours in advance). We ended up having a slight mishap with our...read full review

My husband and I started ordering from here in 2020 specifically for the gluten free Sicilian (I’m unfortunately gluten free, he’s not). Do you have to order before 3:00 for the gluten free? Sure. Is it worth it? Absolutely. The Sicilian is fluffy and airy. FLUFFY. Most gluten free crusts are thin and tastes like cardboard. Their pizza makes you feel like you are eating real pizza. My husband even loves it (he also highly recommends the chicken roll, garlic knots, and their...read full review