I was on my way to AC and saw this place reviewed by Dave Portnoy I think he gave it an 8.1. It was quite a drive out of my way as this place took me north as I needed to head south . When I got about 20 mins away I called in my order and it was a quick easy order . I ordered a pie with pepperoni. When I finally got there I parked at a meter (first 15 mins free) . It's in a really nice area with a nice stream of water over an old bridge which was nice to see . As I entered they didn't seem busy and I was helped right away . The pie came to 21.00 which these days is more than fair . I couldn't wait to get to my car and chow down on some pepperoni pizza! As i opened the box I liked what I saw a nice well done thin pie with cheese all the way to the end of the crust . It had a nice char but I felt a little light with the pepperoni. So as I said it looked well done and thin and I thought it would be crispy . However it's softer and kind of chewy . It reminded me of a frozen pizza consistency . I'm glad I tried it and enjoyed the experience but it's not for me as I prefer a crispy pizza . My advice give it a try and perhaps have it to stay as the box came make it less crispy or in this case soft and chewy .
Hannah L
they were so nice and gave me breaded chicken after accidentally giving me grilled ?
Tamar Mor
I have been getting Vinnie’s for 2.5 years now and I finally decided it was time for a review. Let me tell you that this is one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever had, and definitely the best in the area.The way they make their delicious pies is simply genius- the crust is made of crispy cheese rather than regular dough. The dough itself is so perfectly thin and crisp. Typically, I am a toppings girly; I love me some toppings. But here, I don’t need any toppings- plain pie is perfect as is.Also of note is their Caesar salad. The croutons are so good and garlicky, always fresh lettuce and shredded parm. 10/10The staff is very friendly and are always quick with orders even on busy nights. Can’t recommend enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Vinnie Pizza
Daniel D
Great pizza. Honestly up there with the best pizza places in the state. The meatball pie was so good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill B.
Great pizza except for one thing: the dough is very chewy and not firm or crusty at all. Was this intentional or are the ovens not hot enough or did the 10 minute trip back home in my car ruin it. A response from the restaurant or another reviewer is welcomed. The cheese and sauce and toppings were so delicious.
Noor B.
I saw a review of this place on social media and I was sold when he said the side of the pizza has burnt cheese. Mmmm heaven. I like their sauce too. It's not sweet like some other places. I don't eat pork so I've never tried any of this toppings. I always get plain. But I'm sure with toppings the pizza would be incredible.
Robert P.
Saw this place was a top reviewed spot (and saw Portney's review) and had to check this place out. Right off the main downtown area of Milburn it has some outside seating when the weather is nice. Inside it's two small tables and a nice/newer vibe. The pizza takes me back to the classic bar pie with thin crust. Not greasy and does have a little crisp at the ends it's a really great pizza. 8.7 Go and get it, I will be back
John Sheckelton
Haven’t had the pizza (yet), but the chicken, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella sandwich may very well be the best sandwich I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Catharine F.
I drove 90 miles to get two pies. Next time I need to get more pies to the gallon. Totally worth the trip. The sauce compliments the spicy Sgt. Peppers pie. What I love the most about the pie is the cheese is carmelized, sauce & toppings right to the edge of the pan pizza. Driving down the turnpike all I could smell was the meatballs from Sgt. Peppers and sweet sausage from Gramps Pizza pie. This Philly girl is hooked.
Anthony
Vinnies makes an excellent thin crust pan pizza. Another rare find where all 3 of pizza 's main ingredients are exceptional. My son and I have a painting business and make a point of trying pizza wherever our work takes us. Vinnies is among the best we have had. If you are pizza snobs like us you will appreciate Vinnies.
We were not greeted at all and there is only 2 tables inside not even given a napkin or fork the man behind the counter was rude and, on his phone, the whole time. Food was ok nothing great. So disappointed...we also didn't even get a receipt for our meal and definitely not worth the money for sure.!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Lane L
Worth the wait. Terrific thin crust pizza. We always reheat post delivery for 5 min or so which brings back the crisp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Louis D.
The pizza was one of the best I've ever had but the rigatoni/vodka was the absolute worst ever! the amount of oil in this dish was disgusting & it was $40 for a pizza & the pasta dish that's way too much for those two items! Clearly this place is for the pizza.
Uzma K.
This spot was great!! It was perfectly crisp, the service was good. You can tell us a good spot, phones kept ringing and pizza kept getting made. The place is very small. Looks like many people don't dine in, we ate inside and it was cold in the area where they have tables. Pizza was delicious I love that it's pizza all the way and no crust. This was a gramps pie - hot peppers. Sausage peppers and onions. I wish I had some ranch on the side but they didn't carry any. Everything tasted fresh!
I was on my way to AC and saw this place reviewed by Dave Portnoy I think he gave it an 8.1. It was quite a drive out of my way as this place took me north as I needed to head south . When I got about 20 mins away I called in my order and it was a quick easy order . I ordered a pie with pepperoni. When I finally got there I parked at a meter (first 15 mins free) . It's in a really nice area with a nice stream of water over an old bridge which was nice to see . As I entered they didn't seem busy and I was helped right away . The pie came to 21.00 which these days is more than fair . I couldn't wait to get to my car and chow down on some pepperoni pizza! As i opened the box I liked what I saw a nice well done thin pie with cheese all the way to the end of the crust . It had a nice char but I felt a little light with the pepperoni. So as I said it looked well done and thin and I thought it would be crispy . However it's softer and kind of chewy . It reminded me of a frozen pizza consistency . I'm glad I tried it and enjoyed the experience but it's not for me as I prefer a crispy pizza . My advice give it a try and perhaps have it to stay as the box came make it less crispy or in this case soft and chewy .
they were so nice and gave me breaded chicken after accidentally giving me grilled ?
I have been getting Vinnie’s for 2.5 years now and I finally decided it was time for a review. Let me tell you that this is one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever had, and definitely the best in the area.The way they make their delicious pies is simply genius- the crust is made of crispy cheese rather than regular dough. The dough itself is so perfectly thin and crisp. Typically, I am a toppings girly; I love me some toppings. But here, I don’t need any toppings- plain pie is perfect as is.Also of note is their Caesar salad. The croutons are so good and garlicky, always fresh lettuce and shredded parm. 10/10The staff is very friendly and are always quick with orders even on busy nights. Can’t recommend enough.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Vinnie Pizza
Great pizza. Honestly up there with the best pizza places in the state. The meatball pie was so good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza except for one thing: the dough is very chewy and not firm or crusty at all. Was this intentional or are the ovens not hot enough or did the 10 minute trip back home in my car ruin it. A response from the restaurant or another reviewer is welcomed. The cheese and sauce and toppings were so delicious.
I saw a review of this place on social media and I was sold when he said the side of the pizza has burnt cheese. Mmmm heaven. I like their sauce too. It's not sweet like some other places. I don't eat pork so I've never tried any of this toppings. I always get plain. But I'm sure with toppings the pizza would be incredible.
Saw this place was a top reviewed spot (and saw Portney's review) and had to check this place out. Right off the main downtown area of Milburn it has some outside seating when the weather is nice. Inside it's two small tables and a nice/newer vibe. The pizza takes me back to the classic bar pie with thin crust. Not greasy and does have a little crisp at the ends it's a really great pizza. 8.7 Go and get it, I will be back
Haven’t had the pizza (yet), but the chicken, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella sandwich may very well be the best sandwich I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I drove 90 miles to get two pies. Next time I need to get more pies to the gallon. Totally worth the trip. The sauce compliments the spicy Sgt. Peppers pie. What I love the most about the pie is the cheese is carmelized, sauce & toppings right to the edge of the pan pizza. Driving down the turnpike all I could smell was the meatballs from Sgt. Peppers and sweet sausage from Gramps Pizza pie. This Philly girl is hooked.
Vinnies makes an excellent thin crust pan pizza. Another rare find where all 3 of pizza 's main ingredients are exceptional. My son and I have a painting business and make a point of trying pizza wherever our work takes us. Vinnies is among the best we have had. If you are pizza snobs like us you will appreciate Vinnies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Vinnie Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered the thin pan pizza and it did not disappoint! Full of flavor and the crust was cooked to perfection, definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roni Pizza, Sausage, Wings
We were not greeted at all and there is only 2 tables inside not even given a napkin or fork the man behind the counter was rude and, on his phone, the whole time. Food was ok nothing great. So disappointed...we also didn't even get a receipt for our meal and definitely not worth the money for sure.!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Worth the wait. Terrific thin crust pizza. We always reheat post delivery for 5 min or so which brings back the crisp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was one of the best I've ever had but the rigatoni/vodka was the absolute worst ever! the amount of oil in this dish was disgusting & it was $40 for a pizza & the pasta dish that's way too much for those two items! Clearly this place is for the pizza.
This spot was great!! It was perfectly crisp, the service was good. You can tell us a good spot, phones kept ringing and pizza kept getting made. The place is very small. Looks like many people don't dine in, we ate inside and it was cold in the area where they have tables. Pizza was delicious I love that it's pizza all the way and no crust. This was a gramps pie - hot peppers. Sausage peppers and onions. I wish I had some ranch on the side but they didn't carry any. Everything tasted fresh!