Gencarelli's Pizzeria & Restaurant

$ • Italian

501 Bloomfield Ave, Newark
(973) 261-8919


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

Bad service. They pick and choose when they want to sell slices. On random days and on random times. I only have a 20 minute break so I call to make sure they’re selling slices. Nice guy on the phone tells me yes. I drive over to order, the girls in the front tell me “no, we don’t sell slices. We’re closing soon”. 40 minutes before they close, and they refuse to sell slices. It’s as if they’re happy to tell customers no, who are willing to spend money on their full review

Don’t waist your money here! For a plain pie 2 pepperoni and two orders of wings I paid 89 dollars ? with that price I could had order better food elsewhere. The wings have an awful taste of really old.... oil. The pizza it’s not great. Prices are too high for the quality of pizza. The woman taking orders over the phone was rude and sounded like she just wanted to clock out. I wish I can give a negative star instead. Very disappointed.

This pizza is authentic cooked to perfection flavorful, & tasty?.. I don't even get the $8 pies anymore (try extra cheese, fresh garlic, mushrooms, green peppers, half sausage half pepperoni ?).. reminds me of NYC.. Gencarekli's.. for-get a bout it!! (Not crispy If that's what you like)❗

More Reviews(154)


Monday 11AM - 8PM
Tuesday 11AM - 8PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8PM
Thursday 11AM - 8PM
Friday 11AM - 8PM
Saturday 11AM - 8PM
Sunday 11AM - 8PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.