50 Best Italian Restaurants near Pine Hill

“The owner reminds me of the best part of going out to eat or grab takeout. She is friendly, chatty, and she aims to please. Ordered a custom sandwich of Italian specialty ingredients for a long drive. It was delicious! It was so good that the drive went better :) Added a drink, a pickle and chips. Lots of good stuff to choose from including prepared goods like chicken salad, which I can attest is very tasty. This spot is clean and organized, full to the brim with goodies. You can pick up grocery items, lunchmeat, bread, even a cannoli. The deli is a better-than-most neighborhood spot with lots to offer. I used to live in the neighborhood. However, if Pine Hill is not nearby, believe me - it's worth a trip. I'm sure you'll agree. The vibe is "Norm!" from Cheers. Even if it's your first time, you'll feel right at home. Yes, I'll be back!“

“Ever since the new owners took over this place, the level of detail throughout the experience has really exceeded expectations. Every single pizza slice I've ordered here has been exceptional, their staff incredibly friendly and accommodating and I just can't think of a better pizza place in the area that offers this level of service. I highly recommend this place for any occasion!“

“It's a hidden gem in Haddonfield NJ great date night ambiance. Food and dessert are amazing it's also a BYOB. Staff and service are great. I been coming for date night for years love the place. Always packed so reservations are a must.“

“We decided to make a reservation to try Anthony's for our anniversary last night and were very pleased! Our waiter, Brandon, was so friendly and made our experience a great one! We were seated right at the time of our reservation in the upstairs section. The restaurant was extremely quiet even with it being crowded. We started with the special strawberry salads. The strawberries were extremely fresh and vinaigrette and Asiago cheese made it very tasty! The complimentary bread and olive oil were very unique. The olive oil was some of the best I've had with a strong olive taste. For entrees, we had the pesto and burrata gnocchi and boar bolognese pasta. They were both AMAZING! We finished with the chocolate chip cake to share. This cake was extremely good as well and I am interested to see if you can buy it from them. We really enjoyed our experience and all of the food! We will definitely be back and tell all our friends about how great it is here!“

“Where do I even start? From top to bottom, start to finish, this place is an absolute gem and a banger!It’s been around forever, I grew up going here and recently came back to the area and knew I had to stop in the see what was new….Ali, one of the owners, has some of the most outstanding customer service skills and his smile and charisma light up when you walk in. Nothing else like it. This guy is straight up awesome!!Omar, the other owner and Ali’s brother is in the back cooking up some of the best food in the area.I got garlic knots, pizza, fries, tenders and mozzarella sticks.The garlic knots are hands down the BEST garlic knots I’ve had in my entire life. No joke. Legit. And my standards are high / picky for garlic knots. They’re fluffy, pillow-like, chewy and PACKED with garlic. Tons of garlic and the texture is PERFECTION. If you like dry overcooked no flavor garlic knots that skimp on garlic, go elsewhere.The pizza is in my Top 2 and I’m very particular about my pizza….fresh, perfectly cooked, ratios of ingredients ideal and not too thin (I hate cracker-like crust pizza. If I wanted that, I’d get a flatbread) it had the perfect texture, chew and nice amount of cheese. Has a very very awesome unique flavor that’s hard to describe that I’ve never tasted before all the way through to the dough and the cheese is FRESH. These guys know what they’re doingOh and by the way, the tenders are hand breaded and house made to perfection. Nice and juicy, melt in your mouth fall apart just picking them up.The mozzarella sticks are also house made and you can tell they are fresh.These guys are charitable too, involved in the community and with donations.Literally everything about this place is amazing from the people to the food. I can’t get over how amazing those garlic knots are. I’m mad because now I have to go back regularly lol.Genovas is the definition of QUALITY!“

“From the gelato to the atmosphere, everything was amazing! Whether I opted for classic favorites like pistachio or ventured into more adventurous territory with flavors like tiramisu, they all tasted fantastic! Every flavor I tried felt as if it was crafted with precision and passion with the finest ingredients. What truly sets this place apart, however, is the attention to detail in every aspect of the gelataria. The decor and music makes you feel like you traveled to Italy and are visiting an authentic Italian gelataria.“

“It's been a long time since I've been to Sapori and definitely regretting not coming back sooner. The food was outstanding, from the bread and olive oil, to the fresh calamari, main, and dessert. Everything was great in terms of service and the waiter was attentive and charismatic. Heated patio was excellent and everything was reasonably priced. Will definitely be back soon.“

“Went to Home Depot to get some paint but was distracted by the smell coming from this place and had to stop in. Ended up getting the sweet sausage on a long roll, with fried onions, hot peppers and brown mustard. Delicious food, on point roll, friendly atmosphere and good prices. What more could you want?“

“One of the only original real Italian food, and people. I'm part Sicilian. I love it. The other 100% Italian pizza place is Riccardo's in Beverly city, NJ. Highley recommend. If not I will reimburse you. For either place. They definitely need to deliver.Parking: There is about 500 spots to park, and for pick up you can park out front.Kid-friendliness: Bring them all john will make them laugh.Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp at the door, low bumb at the door and plenty room to wheel around.“

“My brothers rehearsal dinner was here. Anthony was amazing to work with. The food was fantastic, service was amazing, and everyone had a fabulous time. The room looked so classy and elegant when decorated and set up. Would highly recommend for any event and we cannot wait to return!“

“There are a number of outstanding, topnotch restaurants in Haddonfield. They all offer great food, service and ambience. What sets Mare Monte apart, is that the placement of the tables allows diners to enjoy a great meal and engage in pleasant conversation without competing conversations from other diners.“

“There is something about this small, intimate bar/restaurant that I love. Their broccoli rabe, white bean appetizer with sausage is something that I crave! It's so flavorful. Tonight, I enjoyed meatballs and marinara over penne, and my husband had a tasty chicken cheesesteak and wings. The garlic parm sauce has actual pieces of roasted garlic in it, which is so good on the wings. My vanilla bean creme brulee was great with a perfect sugar crust on top. When people say that small family owned restaurants are better than chain restaurants, Briglias is certainly a testament to that.“

“Ordered a large pizza through Slice app. Pizza was ready on time and staff were friendly. The best part was the pizza tasted quite good. I am fairly picky when it comes to pizza. The crust had a nice crunch, sauce was tasty and the cheese was quality. Had a slice before I got home because it smelled fantastic.“

“Went for the first time and all the food was great. Had the Cacio e Pepe Cheese Wheel entree portion. Lived up to what I was expecting, presentation of the preparation tableside did not disappoint. Artichoke appetizer was unique and absolutely tasty. Had to try dessert and we got the vanilla/chocolate pudding with cookie dirt was soooo good. Highly recommend!“

“Absolutely unbelievable value, service and ambiance. The food is exceptionally excellent quality and quantity at a very affordable price. Surprising variety of menu selections for everyone. Convenient parking. We cannot wait to return and enjoy the many other entrees on the menu. We plan on sharing our experience with all our friends and neighbors.“

“Everyone there is always nice and in good spirits. The service is so fast too! I've gotten a large pizza in less than 45 minutes on a busy Friday. I almost always get spaghetti with Vodka sauce or Capri pizza and is amazing every time. Mainly a take-out placeVegetarian options: Plenty of different vegetarian sauces and large selection of toppings for pizza. Also a salad stationParking: Nice large parking lot in a shopping center. Always somewhere to park!Wheelchair accessibility: Sidewalk ramps and everything is on a ground floor“

“We were early, but were seated and the staff was warm and welcoming. We were there for the Spring Early Bird Specials and the choices made it hard to decide, but we each chose different apps and entrees and each of us was delighted with our choices. We chose the same dessert and were very happy with it. The grilled salmon was cooked perfectly and the risotto was so creamy i could have had an entree of just that! My sister, it was her 89th Birthday, got the Gnocchi and said it was excellent, she almost asked for a doggie bag because it was so filling, so she opted for the Sorbetto for dessert instead of a cannoli. The sound level was quiet, the music was soft. More people came after us and the staff still acted as if we were their only concern! As senior citizens we don't like to drive at night, especially since we were coming from Marlton. We will be looking to do this again.“

“Let me tell you about this restaurant! I absolutely loved everything about it! When I say the food was on point, I mean on point! I had Chicken Bella Piazza. The sauce was so tasty. This is a BYOB ? location. Had I known I would have had a bottle. I came after work for a retirement party. One coworker was ready! Another co-worker was able to help everyone else out by running around the corner for a few bottles ?. The staff were friendly and offered suggestions. They were accurate saying both dishes were good choices. Some restaurants just say that! We stayed til closing. No pressure to leave. Thank you Siena for a great evening out. I will be back!Parking: You can park in front or on the side.“

“Overall 5 stars,This is their carnivore pizza without bacon. We also had their white Detroit pizza, I would rate 7/10, room for improvement for the price I think added ricotta would have been an amazing benefit. There is another establishment we usually frequent but I think I just found the best pizza in twp“

“I came in with a few friends who have never been here before, and they were beyond impressed. The portions, prices, and quality of food were outstanding. Our server Ryan was the best and filled them in on all the details. He made sure we had everything we needed and, though he was very busy he made us feel like we were his only table. Needless to say we were all very pleased.“

“Nicoletta's on Main is a hidden gem worth discovering. The atmosphere is cozy, the staff are super friendly, and the food is simply delicious. They offer a solid selection of Italian classics, all prepared with care and attention to detail. It's the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy an amazing meal, and leave knowing you’ll definitely be back!“

“Every time I go the food is perfectly cooked and the drinks are spectacular. We had not gone to this place since before COVID and decided to go back in November. it was just as we remembered. In fact, my wife loved it so much, she wanted to come for her birthday which was only a few weeks away in December. When we went back in December, the food was even better then I remembered from November when we were there! I suggest that you take a trip there ASAP!!!“

“Attended a Communion party at Filomena's today and it was very nice. I selected the Salmon with Basil Shallot Cream sauce and it was phenomenal. Also had the best mashed potatoes in a long time. Absolutely delicious. The wait staff assigned to our party were absolutely wonderful. So friendly and great service.“

“I'm usually very picky where I get my pizza from I decided to try out cafe Antonio's for the first time. The pizza was great the gravy was just right, and the service time was quick. The staff were very busy but yet very nice the owner came over and introduced himself. Great customer service, so today I'm going to try chicken franchise I can't wait I found my new spot.“

“Honestly this was the best Italian food I’ve ever eaten! I ordered the Lasagna—fresh, hot, delicious with large portion. The seeded bread with garlic oil on side was warm & tasty!The staff (Scott) was so friendly & accommodating & drinks were also amazing!I definitely recommend this restaurant & will be going back again!Parking: There are a few spots in the restaurant lot but plenty of street parking & a CVS lot across the street“

“Just like Nona’s kitchen. The Scipelle soup is incredibly delicious. Perfect. This menu item, which is a very rare find, is a cherished dish here and Fiene’s rendition is the definitive preparation. I’ve been coming here for years to reconnect with my family roots through this soup and the recipe has not changed.You will not find better. Period.A major hit menu item was the Zuppa Inglese. This is not an Italian specialty dessert many may recognize. I’ve NEVER seen this on a menu before and I’m so glad I spotted it on the Holiday menu. Zuppa Inglese is an Italian Trifle dessert, similar in assembly to Tiramisu (which is also a menu star here). I hadn’t had this dish since the family holiday dinners of my youth. Curious how this found its way onto the menu I was informed that a matriarchal family member made this to order in advance at a the request of a good customer. Time consuming to prepare several of these were made and I was the beneficiary of a most wonderful accommodation.The folks at Fiene’s are family. They are “family” to the restaurant and to their guests as everyone here takes an ownership attitude. You will eat well. You will be treated well, like valued family members.I cannot say enough about the satisfaction of a Fiene’s experience.“

“We had a wonderful meal here on Thursday. The Chicken Milanese was delicious-the best i have had. The arugula salad was so fresh and enough for 2. Great bread, and great service. We sat outside on the patio on a picture perfect evening. We brought home enough leftovers for 2 more meals, but were able to eat our delicious cream puff deserts. LOL. It is BYOB too.“

“I Ordered A Pepperoni, Sausage , Mushroom & Onion Pizza And It Was The Best Pizza I've Had In Awhile..Sauce Was Not Tart At All Which I Like. Excellent Crust, Not To Soft And Not To Hard, A Little Charred Around The Edges, Just Right. The Mister Ordered The Pasta Pomodora Wiith Meatballs, I Can Say The Meatballs Were Excellent, So Moist And Flavorful You Can Tell They're Homemade. Meatballs Could Have Been Bigger Or They Could Give You Four Instead Of Three In A Serving. Overall I Will Be Frequenting This Local Restaurant....“

“The food was delicious and we love that you get a salad with your entrée. Service was very good. Our biggest complaint was the noise, which could have been cut down if they didn't seat everybody on top of each other. Despite plenty of empty tables, but they put everyone in the same section of the restaurant.“

“Me and my sister decided to come randomly to try your Alfredo pasta. My sister had the shrimp Alfredo and loved it. I decided to get chicken, shrimp, and crab meat. OH MY GOD when I tell you the crab mean was so big in my Alfredo it was unbelievable. The food was amazing the bread was amazing. This had to be one of the best Alfredo pasta dishes I've had. The pricing was worth every bit.“

“I consider myself a pizza connoisseur. It is by far my FAVORITE food so I like to try different places. This is by far the BEST pizza I've had in a REALLY long time. The sauce has the right amount of sweetness and not acidic like most. The cheese is just the right amount, not too much and definitely not too little with that good quality stringy texture to. It has that nice coating of reddish orange grease on top that we all hate to love. The crust is perfectly thin where the slice flops down making a perfect fold. Next time I'll ask them not to cook it as long but that's just a matter of preference.The service was quick and very friendly. It's also the best deal I've seen in ages. $10 for a large pizza! I can't even get a value meal at McDs for that!Rosalies I salute you. Thank you.“

“We’re from Oregon and stopped by twice before our flight back. Prices are great and the food is fresh, melt in your mouth softness from the bagels and bacon ? cooked perfectly!! Had a Breakfast Bagel both times and can’t get enough. We’re coming back once more today to get a hoagie for the plane trip!! Well Done Mama Marie’s!!!“

“This is our go to pizza place in town. It's rarely over 20 minutes for a pie and the taste is very good. I think it's the best when the pizza is extra crispy. We never dine in so no comments on the atmosphere, but the man always behind the counter is always friendly“

“We discovered Lorenzo's after charging our car across the street. The food was amazing! It was practically a homemade meal. Our visit was between lunch and dinner service, so we had the place to ourselves. Do not pass up a chance to eat here!“

“Excellent food and service! Free valet parking to start. Good selection of appetizers. The crabcake is a must. Too many to list but our party of ten had our own room. Of waiter was very attentive and checked on us frequently. They also have a staff that quickly checked on water and removed plates. Dessert was excellent too. Will definitely return again.“

“The all you can eat seafood buffet was a great experience, the lobsters were cooked perfectly as well as the crab legs and Dungeness crabs finger licking good, best seafood buffet by far. I will definitely be going back..A must try...Thank you Stellato.“

“HOLY MOLY WAS THIS JUST THE BEST FOOD IVE DONE DID EAT IN MY LIFE! BREAD-PERFECT, WATER-QUENCHING, FOOD-FULFILLING, SERVICE-ASTRONOMICALGET YOUR ITALIAN CRAVINGS FIXED HERE!(shane was a very good bus boy, handsome too if I do say so myself) ;)“

“Came here with family for a late lunch on a Sunday afternoon. The service was great, we had a large party too. I got the half and half soup and the linguine positano but I subbed in rose cream sauce. The warm fresh bread was also a nice touch.“

“60 years in South Jersey and I can say the best Italian food is at Il Fiore. Each dish comes to the table hot, well presented and delicious. Ask Lundy for something in case you do not see it, he is the "host with the most." His staff truly attempts to provide each customer with the best service. Even when the house is full and people are waiting in line to come in, your glass of water will always be filled, your BYOB wine will be poured and your meal will be as if you were the only table in the restaurant. I especially like when they have the veal chop special while my wife craves their grilled salmon dishes. Come to Il Fiore and enjoy, you will never be sorry. BTW, eating lunch there is a great treat--quieter, music playing and reasonable prices.“

“The food is amazing, on point every time. The protein shakes are also really good especially with the added options, and there’s a good selection of meals/sides on their menu. Even the staff there is friendly. It’s definitely worth the drive, considering I live 30 minutes away. I highly recommend it, 10/10!!Parking: There’s enough of parking spots.“

“I was surprised, being there for the first time for dinner, that Tuscan Bistro had lobster bisque soup and bacon wrapped scallops for an appetizer, my two favorites. I asked if it was regularly on the menu, and was told no, but the ingredients for the bacon wrapped scallops are always on the menu, so it could be made to order. My husband had the staple, Chicken Parmesan, which he said was very good and tender. We will definitely be going back for dinner, and not only for lunch. Service was excellent, prices were comparable, and meals were delicious.“

“We LOVE Anthony's, we live in town amd can walk there. They are always so nice, know our kids by name and have watched our family grow. Ms. Aaliyah the owner is a true gem. Happy to support a small business and highly reccomemnd stopping by.“

“Fantastic sandwich! (Soprano) Best I’ve had in South Jersey so far! Fresh crusty roll, the chicken was flavorful and not weirdly textured like other places I’ve been to. Everything was well seasoned (I’ve had very bland pesto sauces before). Highly recommend!“

“Wonderful is an understatement. I had my husband‘s 70th birthday celebration here yesterday we had over 50 people there was more than enough room. The atmosphere was perfect for our party .today alone I’ve received five phone calls from guest at the party to complement me on my choice of restaurant, they loved the food they love the atmosphere. They love that it was easy assessable since a lot of people were coming from Philadelphia .more than not yesterday everybody expressed how they will be back. I thank you Vinnie and crew. These guys did a wonderful job. Everyone everyone was pleased, but most of all my husband , he had the veal Parm , his favorite dish !our guest also had had fettuccine Alfredo with chicken, shrimp scampi and also chicken marsala. Everything was wonderful the staff was so attentive. This is a BYOB so they had us all set up for everything we needed it. Thanks Vinnie see you soon❤️“

“My neighborhood pizza shop was recently sold, no longer a fan of their food (sorry).Anywho, I was recommended to try Capri Pizza andYup, def my new #1 go to Pizza Shop!!! I have been there a few times now and NEVER disappointed.Food is sooooo fresh and tasty. You can tell they use the richest ingredients. #Drooling#Yummz!“

“What can I say? This "neighborhood" spot is not the usual. It's a special treat, yet nearby. Excellent, attentive service. Delicious menu with flavors. Small and cozy. Yes, I'll be back to see you Chef Joey Baldino. Maybe at Zeppoli, maybe at Palizzi!“

“My baby shower was held at Limoncello restaurant. I cannot thank Eric and his team enough for the absolutely incredible experience we had! From the event preparation to tear down, everything was seamless. The food was delicious (especially love the Chicken Parmesan and cheesecake!), service was top notch, and the ambiance was perfect. I highly recommend to anyone looking for the right spot to host their event or simply for a delicious meal!“

“We recently moved to the williamstown area and had a hard time finding a pizza place until we came across Tuscan Pizza. They are fantastic and amazing customer service. We asked for paper plates the one time, the driver left without them but received a call from Tuscan apologized for this and said they sent another driver by to deliver the plates. They literally arrived minutes late almost the exact same time as the pizza. This is just a small sample of their service. Top notch and amazing pizza!“

“Carosello's is our family's "go-to" spot for pizza and sandwiches. One of the best in the area! I know it's really tough to find a place that stands out among the sea of pizza joints in this region, but don't hesitate to place an order here - you will not be disappointed. Great food, and very fair prices. Fast and friendly delivery too, when needed! Chuck is a great guy as well. Thanks for never letting us down guys!“

“It was our 1st time there today and the woman who owns it was so friendly. We got vegetable soup, chicken cutlets, eggplant parmesan and a side of string beans and everything was delicious. All the food was homemade and you could taste the care she took in making everything. We can't wait for our next visit!“