50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pompton Plains

“My family has tried several pies from Hoboken's Pizzeria. Our favorite is still the Spinach Artichoke Rectangle Pie and we now prefer it cooked light so the crust is soft vs crispy. I got some friends into this pizzeria and this pie, it's become their favorite too.After 1 pie was too crispy, almost burnt, the owner remembered us and gave a discount the next time I went in. Really nice people. We drive from several towns over because their pizza tastes great.“

“Pizza Man @ Pompton Plains Friends have recommended this place and we definitely wanted to try it since I heard their seafood dishes are amazing !!!! Unfortunately, there were only two of us and there was a limit to how much we could try, and I completely missed the menu from Fish section .... Because we wanted to order the fresh clam in white sauce over linguini !!! Instead, we ordered Cavatelli alla Ripini from the Pasta section and Hawaiian pizza. Both were really good and the Cavatelli was sooo chewy and pleasant texture. We will definitely come back to try the clam in white sauce over linguine - since Alladin, the owner, mentioned that it was his favorite !!!!! And another one we plan on ordering ... the large portion ($34) Zuppa di Pesce !!!!! Seafood all the way !!!“

“I recently visited Wood Stack & Pizza for the first time with a group of friends, and I must say, we were all impressed. The thin crust pizza was a definite standout, with most of us ordering it and loving every bite. The service was also top-notch, adding to the overall positive experience. We had a great time at Wood Stack & Pizza and would definitely recommend it to others looking for delicious pizza in a cozy atmosphere.“

“They do everything they can to make you feel at home A nice to eat in a place Where you feel Comfortable with the service They treat you with kindness and courtesy And respect Great spot for family friends To get together And have a great meal and a great time together All in the family pledge to be Whoever is taking the time to read this Hope to see you there soon ? Yummy“

“Excellent place that has been around for a while. They know good food, and have a great atmosphere. Personally, I think they have the best pizza in town. They have consistently good service that never disappoints, and everything on their menu is delicious and well worth the trip here.Parking: The parking could be better, but they do have a valet on site that takes care of all of that.“

“Went there a couple of weeks ago with some friends and was absolutely blown away with the pizza , the quality of the food and the service ! I got the casino pizza and it might’ve been the best pizza I’ve had in morris county . Gianluca the owner also was so helpful with all and any questions we had, if you like Italian food this place is an absolute must !“

“Enormous menu, and while that can often waterdown quality, that's not the case here. The butter chicken baos and somosa chaat appetizers were a great start. The Punjabi goat curry and goat korma were tasty entrees, but the portions are small. Do not miss out on the Naan. It was a perfect compliment to the curries. Vibe is a little weird. One part Indian restaurant, one part sports bar... Just a little odd. Either way I'd go back.“

“Their catering food deserves more than 5 stars. Been using them for a yearly party for a few years now. Not once have I even received anything less than spectacular feedback from those attending. They are not afraid to season their food, which is a pleasant experience with catering. Do not hesitate to use Rusillo's for your next event. They will be there when they say and will help you take your event to the next level. You won't be sorry.“

“I stopped into Bask 46 on Thursday for Happy Hour. Enjoyed the ambiance & vibe and that carried over to your bartender.She was the star of it all. She greeted me with a smile and made me one of the best old fashioned I’ve ever had. I think I’ve found my “Cheers” !!! See you again !!“

“My boyfriend and I tried this for the first time today and thought it was absolutely DELICIOUS! Pizza had such good flavor and the dough was great. I’m so angry I didn’t find out about this place sooner! Will definitely be coming back.“

“Order their drunken grandma with garlic knots tonight for dinner. When my husband brought it home it smelled amazing! The vodka sauce had a nice flavor to it. Not too acidic. Crust was nice and thin. The garlic knots where so light and fluffy as well as loaded with garlic and Parmesan cheese. I would definitely order it again!“

“It's very disappointing to see that already after only a few months of being open to make changes and to start cutting corners with their menu. They changed up their Sub Sandwich rolls from a beautiful seeded semolina roll to some substandard Italian sub roll. The bread makes the sandwich. Any chicken Parm and Meatball Parm should have stayed on that semolina roll. Cheesesteaks should not, they belong on those other Italian rolls. It "was" the best chicken Parm I ever had. Now it's just like every other round of the mill pizza joint that comes and goes...“

“A Dominican pizza restaurant that shows Formula 1 races?! A dream come true! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! Amazing service and even better food! We had the chimi pizza and breakfast pizza. They were phenomenal! We are definitely going to make this our spot to watch Formula 1 races and have yummy food with friends. Can’t wait to go back!“

“It's great to have this historic pizzeria reopened under a new name! Frank & sons was always my favorite pizza in town until the early 2010s. The people are friendly, the service is great and the pizza left me extremely happy to have visited once again!“

“My family and I each enjoyed fantastic service and food at Pazza today. We were offered seats in or outdoors and chose to sit inside. I have celiac and absolutely loved their gluten-free penne shrimp fra diavolo! So spicy and delicious. We all left feeling happy and very full!“

“So glad there is a Singa's near us - pizza is always great. They are generous with toppings and even offer a "half cooked" option so you can finish cooking at home for a fresh pizza experience later. Owner/Staff are always pleasant too.“

“Their pizza is terrific, and unusual - square crusts!? My wife had the gluten free which is the best we've tasted, ever. There was a small error in our order which I will put down to the fact that it was the superbowl and the place was hopping. Veggie Pizza was great with the truffle oil touch and the pepperoni was thick cut and flavorful. Will definitely order again.“

“I ordered the chicken parm dinner and it was fantastic. This is one of the best chicken parm’s I think I’ve ever had. Thin chicken cutlets that are pan fried and crispy with the perfect amount of cheese melted on top. The sauce was great and the garlic bread was like nothing I’ve ever had before but it was very good. The best part was they delivered it to an address I’m parked at for the night with my tractor trailer.“

“It is one the best pies around and you have to go and enjoy the quality of the pie.. sauce crust cheese... always consistent! all so evenly prepared... dinners are solid as well.. order a pie as soon as u get there.. then review the menu for dinner!“

“Ordered the vodka sauce with fresh mozzarella pizza (square). ONE OF THE BEST PIZZA'S I'VE EVER HAD! Perfect sauce, crust, cheese, everything! Chef's kiss. Wonderful staff as well. Run, don't walk to Delizia's. ?? ??“

“Came here on a Friday night to meet up with a bunch of ladies. There were 15 of us. Had a great experience. We sat upstairs which was perfect because it was quiet and we were able to talk while enjoying our meals. The pizza was excellent! Very thin crust and crunchy. I loved it! Service was fast! Our waiter was Lav and he was amazing! He was able to accommodate us all and give us separate checks. Very cozy atmosphere. Will be back!“

“Very clean, fast, & friendly employees were very welcoming and accommodating to what I was looking for if it was not put out amazing food if your passing thru on the highway definitely give this place a stop and get some gas while your at it lol“

“This is by far the best italian food outside of Italy. The owner Anthony is a Johnson &Wales graduate chef and it shows.. Very reasonable prices for such high qualtycuisine....Large portions..took half home and just had for dinner...sodelicious... Have dinner there..you willnot be disappointed.“

“Dough’s fun logo caught our eye and after driving by a bunch of times, we finally gave it a try. And WOW, were we impressed!We tried the zucchini crips, deviled eggs, Caesar salad, shroom pie and b&b pie…and everything was amazingly delicious. I never thought I’d be so impressed with a zucchini appetizer…but they nailed it. You’ll never want a zucchini fry again after these. The deviled eggs were perfect, and I’m REALLY picky about eggs in all forms. The Caesar salad may have been the best I’ve ever had, with a lightness and freshness that most others lack. And the pies…that DOUGH! So good. The char and flavor were perfect. Never knew what bresaola was until eating it on the b&b, and boy was I happy to meet it. Can’t wait to come back to try more pies!The cocktails we tried (lavender haze and applewood old fashioned) were also a delight, and we’re really looking forward to trying the coconut cake and gluten-free chocolate cake we got to go.Our waitress was super friendly and attentive, as was the rest of the staff we encountered. With amazing food, a great laid back feel, awesome staff, warm and welcoming decor (and a really nice restroom to boot), this is definitely the kind of place we will return to often!“

“I'm new to Riverdale since I just opened an acupuncture practice in town and I gotta say every single time I order from Danny's I'm elated. My mom is from Italy and I know GOooooood Italian food and Danny's is just the absolute best in this area. I've ordered incredible Pizza, Chicken Francese, and today I had a calamari salad and it was delicious. This is my new favorite place and I'm telling everyone about it.“

“Seemed like a crazy Friday night when I walked in but they were very helpful when I was trying to order last minute pies. Just got finished with dinner with the family and the pizza was amazinggggg! We got a grandma square pie and a regular cheese round pizza, the crust is so good. Thank you for being so kind and accommodating! I go here once in a while but I just felt the need to write a review finally tonight because it’s always been a great experience and seeing how hard they were working tonight really made me appreciate everything!“

“Great food and strong drinks! Calamari was cooked well, and the garlic bread that came with it as an appetizer was cooked perfectly crispy. The pizza was dense and filling. I could see the rest of their food being great and would definitely go back. Overall, I give Reservoir Tavern a 4.5 out 5.“

“Absolutely amazing, for as long as I can remember, my father has been bringing me here since I was a little kid and the food has always been top-tier This Sicilian is out of this world and the chicken Parm with vodka sauce a must try ??‍???“

“I haven’t eaten here in many years but since moving back to town I wanted to give it a try again. I have to say, The BEST Italian sub, mozz sticks and pizza so far! And we’ve tried them all lol. So good I just had to share! Definitely my Go to for our pizza nights!!“

“Forget the pizza! Order their Empanadas. My cousin bought them for a party and they are massive and stuffed to the max!!! I believe you can only get them as a catering order. If they sell these individually, I'd get them for lunch everyday. It was chicken filled. Came with a hot sauce but taste more like a Buffalo sauce. Goes real well with it.“

“I love this pizzeria! I come here once a week literally. The best pizzeria I’ve been to hands down. Everything on their menu is delicious my favorite is the penne vodka pasta with grilled shrimp. I had Nicole as a waitress she was phenomenal! Also, theyre very affordable“

“I order all the time and great food. My only suggestion is for some dinners they offer don't put over pasta unless states. I ordered veal Frances that came with a side of pasta. Veal was on top of and all the lemon butter sauce was soaked up so the veal was dry. Not what I planned on ordering based on menu. But I will never stop going back will just be clear. UPDATE to all. I apologize to francos not a criticism a suggestion. Owner not only called me but so gracious and wasn't want I was looking for. The stuffed filet of sole was outstanding and again one of my favorite places. And the woman who takes the phone orders one of the most pleasant nicest person ever and repeat the order. I would give 10 stars overall if available“

“We always get delivery. They are honest when you order regarding wait time. The food is always good. I enjoy the salads, pizzas and subs and appetizers.Dietary restrictions: They don’t have a large variety for gluten-free but the cauliflower pizzas are pretty good. The gluten free crust is ok but I prefer the cauliflower crust. The salads are great as well.“

“We have ordered a couple of times and it is always delivered on time and with plates, cutlery, napkins and pepper flakes - you don't have to request for theseDietary restrictions: Jason does a great job and makes sure the food is delivered on time“

“My favorite pizza place of all time. I used to frequent this spot many years ago, I stop by every chance I get when I'm in the area. I stopped by today and 11years later and is still the same. The owner is really nice. The food is great, glad to see not much has changed.“

“Khushpal - Best Eggless Pastry Chef in TownKhushpal has worked with me to make multiple eggless custom cakes for birthdays and special occasions and every single time we have been very happy with the results. The cakes are scrumptious and utterly delicious as well as his work is neat and totally on point to what has been asked. We always have bunch of guests come to us after the party for cake recs and that speaks a lot. In all Lazeez is killing it in dessert section as well with Mr Khushpal leading it!!!“

“Tonight was my first time there and I was told the food was really good. We had wings and some slices and Ari and Mary didn't disappoint. They brought us some knots while we waited and those were fantastic also. I'm new to the area and will definitely be “

“I decided to try a sandwich from this restaurant for the first time. I just ordered a hot chicken cutlet sub and it was the best sandwich I have ever had!! The chicken was cooked and seasoned perfectly, the lettuce and tomato were extremely fresh, the bread was also freshly baked! The food is so clean which is the most important and the service was phenomenal. Sweet beautiful young girl rang me up, and that just elevated the entire experience. The food is definitely crafted with love and that is apparent. I will be ordering daily from today forth. Thank you Pizza City! “

“Classic Italian restaurant. We came here for a rehearsal dinner. Everything was family style and was excellent. So many classic dishes. Everything was set up as soon as we walked in. Staff took a moment to describe the dishes to us before we ate. They were very attentive and quick. Food was excellent everything was delicious.“

“I know it's a chain but their pizza is pretty darn good. The crust is very thin and crunchy and it's very customizable - cheese, sauce, toppings, condiments, pineapple whatever fancy you. They put whatever you ask for in front of you and put it in the oven. I don't know how but it's usually ready within minutes. I've had takeout but it's really best when you eat it right after it comes out. You can also order via the app and specify what time to pick up which is a plus. And every now and then they would give you coupons to lure you back but we don't mind it because we (especially my 4 year old) really do like their pizza.“

“Brought the kids to Ferati’s tonight and they did not disappoint! We are originally from Brooklyn so we know good pizza. Alex made my daughter the most delicious chicken roll! The quality of food made me feel like I was back home in Brooklyn! Will be coming back often!“

“Tino’s has fast become our favorite pizzeria. Our young children always shout “Tino’s!” if I ask whether they want pizza for dinner. The pizzas are always great. We usually do pick up and eat at home but some times we go in to dine. The service is always great. Oh and for Valentines I asked if they could make a heart shaped pizza - it wasn’t advertised but I knew of another pizzeria doing it but didn’t want to go to another pizzeria. So I called and asked and they said we could request for one when we placed the order. We ordered two pizzas and one turned out better than the other but it didn’t matter. Our kids got a kick out of seeing a heart shaped pizza when they opened the box on Valentine’s Day.Highly recommend this place.“

“This is my 3rd time coming to Tommy’s. The vibe is amazing… friendly staff and really good food. Drinks are good as well. A bit pricey but nowadays what isn’t. I like Tommy’s because they have a wide variety of food choices such as pizzas, sushi, burgers, sandwiches, and poke bowls, pastas, and more. Def would recommend it if you’re in the area.“

“I like Maggie’s now. They’ve updated the menu. I got the ginger sesame orange salad it was delicious. Next time I won’t get shrimp on it because it was too big. I thought it would be popcorn shrimp. I do like the option of adding protein like chicken. The place is always packed and very loud though. Don’t get the fish and chips, not great. Probably better for takeout.Dietary restrictions: They make changes to your order if you request it.“

“Food is pretty good, my 4th time here. It's funny that an Italian Restaurant is actually closed "Every Sunday" when that is the biggest day for Italians and everyone else to go out for macaroni dinner. I'll come back, just not on a Sunday, haha. I'd give them 5 stars if they were open Sundays.. That's just weird. Everyone needs a day off but perhaps take a weekday off instead or rotate Sundays on and off? I'm not the only one who wonders why they close every Sunday..“

“Stopped by here with some friends after a hike and the service was amazing and with funny people. On top of all this the menu selection is good and the pizza was amazing. The Carne Asada pizza pie was amazing and i've never had anything like it before. The ambiance is really clean and modern, it's really welcoming and comfortable.“

“We licked our knives! Need we say more?! (We didn’t eat everything so we asked them to use a spatula to be sure to get all the sauce!) LOL! But seriously, we just found our new favorite restaurant! Everything is exceptional from the moment you walk in! Excellent service, excellent atmosphere, PHENOMENAL FOOD! Can’t wait to come back! Eric was the most excellent waiter!“

“A Chicken Veggie Slice For Me ($4.50)... Specialty SLices Might Seem Small But Hearty... A FIRST Ive Ever Came Across Was Thier Beef Chicken Stock Herb Compilation As I Was Told It Is,, Which Seems to Consist of Garlic,, Onion,, Salt,, Parsley and Red Pepper FLakes and I Think Dried Pieces Of Chicken N Beef... Someone Tell Me What This Is Called If Uuu Run Across This Review... Very Tasty It Is and I Dont Eat Beef Anymore But I Made an Exception to Try... Pretty Decent Place...“

“My wife and I stop by the bakery to pick up St Joseph cakes on our way to Anthony Francos to get dinner. We noticed the menus at the door and picked one up. We were planning on ordering Eggplant Rollatini. We decided to give Grandmas a chance. People were very friendly and food was fresh and delicious. Would definitely recommend this place. We will be returning in the future.“

“Friendly staff, great quality food. Nice dine-in room set apart from the take out counter.Vegetarian options: Italian-style sautéed veggies ...YUM...my broccoli had great fresh flavor . (They also offer sautéed spinach and rabe.)Dietary restrictions: Gluten free personal pizza. Super happy with how light & crispy Roma's GF version is. Nicely done.Parking: I parked at a town parking lot around the corner. Spaces on the streets too.“