26 Best Seafood Restaurants near Randolph

“Wow. The Black River Barn has outdone themselves again. What I remember growing up is an older pub feel with ok food, that has changed. It's now the most reasonably priced, delicious, kid and adult friendly food in a good part of Northern NJ. The atmosphere is palpable and full of life. Everyone loves their service, food, and drinks along with the prices. Can't say enough good about a restaurant I once wrote off as an older crowd. If you haven't visited in a while, give it another chance and they WILL impress you.“

“Me and my wife decided to have lunch at Mr Crabby's and we were not disappointed. From a 1 to 10 I would rate our experience a 12! From the waiter, Brian to the delicious food, we had the Lobster Reuben and the Mahi Mahi Tacos, we were amazed and well pleased. The owner, Colleen came to our table and greeted us like we were a part of their family. We had such a great time and we plan to return very soon. Mr Crabby's is a special place that I would definitely recommend to all our friends and family.“

“We had a wonderful, relaxed meal with super attentive (but not obtrusive) service led by Thomas Connelly. Thomas knows the menu inside and out, made helpful and considerate recommendations, and orchestrated the timing of the food delivery to perfection. Highly recommend!!“

“I liked making my reservation online. The hostess brought us to the booth I had requested. The re-vamped large room is cozy. The lighting is a little too low though. I had to use my phone light to read the menu. Our server was challenged with the 6 tables he was serving. So, the service was not as good as usual. I had 4 of the largest shrimp in my shrimp cocktail. I thought the presentation was a bit odd though. The extra large, round bowl full of ice, seemed like a big waste of ice. The smaller loaf of bread was very tasty. The steak house salad came in a new elongated bowl, which worked well. My petite steak looked lonely on the big plate. I don't know why my friend had his large baked potato served on a small square bread plate. It was hard for him to eat. The food was good. It's too bad the prices have risen like everywhere else.“

“Visited the Season 52 while traveling to Morris Plains, NJ for work. Went during happy hour which they have from 3-6pm, and the bar was full but they had high top seating open around the bar. The service was quick and the server was delightful. My food was well made and typically this comes with a risotto but I wanted just protein and veggies. It was seasoned well and cooked well too. I'm never disappointed in my time at Season 52.“

“A hidden gem. Authentic Irish inn atmosphere. (Well, I have never been to Ireland, but it seems to be authentic.) Consistently fresh and delicious food. Service at the tables is excellent, but there is a lively bar scene, for the those inclined. Try the shepherds pie.Parking: If you park on the other side of route 46, there is no stop light. In New Jersey, stopping for crossing pedestrians is optional!“

“We found this gem when I was looking for someplace different to go. After our first time, we always go here for a special day. This time our anniversary. Food is excellent, always plenty of outstanding servers. The price is a little high, but well worth it.“

“We had dinner in the dining room. A great space behind the pizzeria area in front. We were on the early side of a Friday night and they space for us, but would recommend a reservation. It was full by the time we left. Food was great. The fresh bread and mushroom app special was exceptional. It’s BYO and a short walk to wine store on south street. We met one of the owners who offered a suggested wine pairing for my entree. We were happy to learn they are passionate about quality and sourcing of their food. Shrimp is from gulf and not international where they destroy environments and abuse people. They grow their own fresh herbs in front window (yes those are for the kitchen) and with grow lights in a closet. Looking forward to coming back to try the pizza.“

“We love Thai food. We've had authentic Thai food in Bangkok itself, and Ricky's Thai is a solid local Thai restaurant that meets our cravings. There's a wide menu of options, you can get dishes from no spicy at all to super spicy. Tip: Level 5 isn't the spiciest, they can go higher. The various duck dishes are awesome, our kids love the lettuce wraps, pad kee mao, satay, and more. Very courteous service and always a great experience, whether we dine in or take out.“

“Food was excellent, I had the special halibut over mashed potatoes with a lemon caper sauce. Large thick piece which was very soft and flaky literally melting in my mouth. Sauce was perfectly balanced and plentiful. Finished with coffee and desert, topped off with a complimentary shot of zambucca.It was quite loud which is the only thing I can criticize with the dinner. Cost was fairly high but considering the quality of our meals, it was a fair price.“

“Overall, solid choice and worth a visit if you're in the area. Typical bar scene with large television screens broadcasting a variety of major sports games, so it does tend to get rather loud inside. But also decently family friendly assuming you're ok with the large tv's around. Decent selection of drinks, and the happy hour specials are well worth the bang for your buck. I personally enjoy the LIT (Long Island), but the House Margarita Special is probably a better deal. Food is pretty much what you'd expect to find at a bar. Large menu so chances are you'll be able to find something that works for everyone. I'm a huge fan of the mozzarella sticks which was the star of the show for me. It is nice that they let you add onto sides for an extra charge. I've tried several of the entrees but nothing stands out. Overall quality is average across the board. Have not ventured into the dessert options here but they looked good for what it's worth, I'll have to give them a shot one time. My experience with service here has been mixed. On my most recent visit, they did very well apart from taking a long time to bring refills/check, but given how busy it gets on weekends it was understandable. However, I have had other times where my order has been messed up without an apology and were visibly upset that I asked for it to be fixed. Personally I prefer here over Tommy's but some may disagree.“

“I started writing this big, long and detailed review/ description of this place, and about 3 paragraphs in, I decided 1) no one has the time to read a story like that but 2) and really more importantly, this restaurant, this specific location in particular, is LEGIT.From the 1st time I tried it, to each and every time since, quality, delicious food made with top shelf ingredients. I'll sum it up by saying this, and you other foodies out there will know right away what I mean.How many times do you get chicken from a pizza place, and it's the rubbery chicken flap they get from a restaurant depot in bulk to save money?? More often that not right? Then, once in a while, you get a pizzeria where you unexpectedly bite into a chicken dish, and it's a nice, thick, juicy piece of actual chicken, and you're literally like "whoa, that's delicious" yeah, that's this place, but with everything“

“Great food, service, and atmosphere. Everything about my experience was fantastic. I'd highly recommend this place, not just if you like German/European food, but great food, period. This is the real deal, folks.Parking: Parking was free and plentiful.“

“Our experience at The Windlass restaurant for Easter Brunch was simply outstanding! From the moment we arrived, we were greeted with warm hospitality and a festive atmosphere that set the tone for a memorable dining experience with family.The selection of food at the brunch buffet was exceptional, with a wide variety of delicious options to satisfy every palate. From traditional brunch favorites to inventive chef specialties, each dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. The freshness and quality of the ingredients were evident in every bite, and we appreciated the attention to detail in every aspect of the meal.The ambiance of the restaurant was charming and inviting, with stunning views of Lake Hopatcong adding to the overall atmosphere. The staff were attentive and accommodating, ensuring that our dining experience was nothing short of perfect.Overall, our Easter Brunch at The Windlass exceeded our expectations in every way. We left feeling thoroughly satisfied and grateful for the wonderful memories created with family. We cannot wait to return and indulge in more of the culinary delights that this gem of a restaurant has to offer.“

“This place is amazing! The pizza, wings, macaroni, and pasta salad are all out of this world. The owner made sure that the oil was changed before making my wings, because after cooking eggplant, the quality of the oil was not up to her standards, which I greatly appreciated. I had mentioned to the owner that I had just moved in and before I took my food to go, she was kind enough to offer me paper plates, which I desperately needed, top notch customer service.“

“Best Gluten free pizza I have EVER HAD IN 14YEARS!!!! The crust was thicker and not cardboard, the sauce was sweet, and the cheese was real!! There wings amazing, (not gf but my kids loved it!!) We just moved here and can't wait to order from here again and again!! Yummmm!“

“The store environment is clean and tidy, and dining is comfortable. The service attitude is highly praised and thoughtful, and the dishes are rich in taste and delicious, satisfying the needs of many people. The dishes are fresh, the taste is excellent and so on.“

“Dined her many times years ago when I worked nearby, it’s been over 20 yrs. It was excellent then, and still is now! Some of the best Italian food you can have. Everything we had was excellent… fresh & full of flavor. It’s a bit out of the way for some, but so worth the trip. I live in Florida and have had many grouper meals, the potato crusted grouper here is ?! The best I ever had. My wife had a chicken dish with pasta that was the bomb. My buddy had the pork chop that was tender and tasty. If you’re looking for a quite atmosphere with great cocktails and fantastic food, you need to make plans to drive to Hibernia Inn ( approximately 3 miles off the Hibernia/Rockaway exit off of Rt 80). This is family owned for many years and they keep bringing a excellent dinning experience. Wish they were in my home town in Florida ?“

“Best local sushi place around! The sushi is always fresh and the sides/appetizers are delicious as well. They have a little "mizu mart" in the front of the store with plenty of Japanese and Korean snacks, ramen, and candy. There isn't any space for indoor eating (it's really tiny) but takeout or outdoor dining is available. Service is quick and very kind.“

“Hands down the best food in town. This place is a hidden gem and the best pasta shop in Denville. Everything is delicious, from the vegetarian "Asian macro" to the salads and the very reasonably priced sandwiches. Every single pasta offering is delicious and unique. The service is always excellent and the warm bread at dinner is a welcome addition. Great for a small or large party, with the vibe of a laid back local cafe. It is BYO. Highly recommend giving this place a chance if you are looking for a great meal in Denville.“

“This was our first time dining at Barka. We were not disappointed. I easily give it 5/5 stars!! Tony was our server and he was fabulous. He was pleasant and very accommodating with all our requests. The cocktails and wine were great. There were 6 of us and we all thoroughly enjoyed our more than substantial apps. The lobster bisque was delicious as were the beet salad, Shephards salad and clams casino. My daughter and DIL shared the Paella for two. It was enough for 4! They loved it. I had grilled lobster which I requested to be removed from the shell and I loved it ! My husband had the delicious Halibut, my son had Ravioli stuffed with lobster and crabmeat and my son in law had the Osso Bucco. We all loved our dinners. This is surely a special occasion restaurant as it is truly fine dining and pricey, but well worth it!! We will be back!!“

“I have been to this restaurant a number of times. I have never been disappointed in the food and presentation. Always top notch. Service is excellent. I liked that our waitress asked if we were going to the MPAC show so we were served accordingly. The owner (I assume) decked out in jacket and fedora was friendly and professional (handsome too). BYOB makes it even better. I recommend highly. Which I did to the two ladies who sat at the next table who had never dined at Pavesi.“

“Husband and I were very pleasantly pleased. We had calamari marinara and chicken contadina. Going low-carb, really appreciated having option to substitute pasta for sautéed spinach for nominal fee and received huge portion of spinach! We really enjoyed our meals. Wish that we had tried the pizza.“

“Always searching for new pizzerias, I stopped in for lunch at Pizza Rustica yesterday. This restaurant is located in a strip mall off Main Street in Rockaway. There's plenty of parking in the lot in front. The place is big inside with plenty of seating. The counter is on the right with a few small tables. To the left is a large dining room. I always love when there's plenty of choices of pies for slices, and they had an excellent selection here. I chose a slice of broccoli rabe with sausage. That combo is great and you don't find that on pies too often. Very friendly server behind the counter giving details on other pies. It was a fun stop and I definitely recommend!“

“Even if you're not into Chinese food, you've got to admire the style that comes with it. My top-tier chums and I came here for lunch yesterday after The Pasta Shop had a 90-minute wait (which annoyed them/pretty much quashed any interest they had in trying to go back, and made me want to go even more - so it goes), and were rewarded with approximately a 30-second wait for a table here. Boy is there a lot to look at; I'm not going to risk using incorrect terminology in describing this building, but it's a lot. I'm assuming it's a fairly accurate interpretation of an "authentic" Chinese structure, but that's as far as I'm going. Very unique, very cool. And as someone who has spent a bit of time at a time vortex Chinese place in Rockland County of late, apparently aquariums are a big part of the decor.If you're looking for information on Hunan's authentic Chinese dishes, you've come to the wrong place - we went so basic, we might as well have ordered this with a side of Uggs and a Pumpkin Spice Latte. I ordered my tried and true Sweet & Sour Chicken, one top-tier chum ordered the Sesame Chicken, and the other top-tier chum ordered General Tso's Chicken. The edgiest item we procured were the steamed pork dumplings app to share.Everything here was very solid. These are obviously items that we'd typically get from a hole-in-the-wall takeout establishment, so it was a nice change of pace to eat the chicken off of actual plates (maybe most people do that too with their takeout orders, but I'm a barbarian through and through). The two keys for me when it comes to sweet & sour chicken are ensuring the chicken isn't overly deep fried where you're eating more fried skin than meat, and that the sauce is on the thicker side. Hunan checked off both boxes here, and since it was served with some vegetables, etc., there was some extra flavoring at play as well. The dumplings were very good as well. I've become more of a soup dumpling adherent in recent years, but I liked the seasoning in the pork and was pleased we got something other than generic chicken with our meal.The service overall was above average. I thought it slowed down noticeably towards the end, though we weren't in a rush or anything. But we'd clearly stopped eating and didn't receive a visit from anyone to pack up the leftovers for about 20 minutes - not egregious, and there were tons of staffers all over the place and it would have been very easy to hail someone down if the urgent need arose. Beyond that, everyone we interacted with was pleasant and efficient.One of my chums noted a party room in the back and was openly pondering the possibility of returning in the near future and hosting a birthday in there. I wasn't QUITE as blown away by this place as she was, but I'd definitely come back. But since I'm not a frisky teenager anymore, I sadly have to pick and choose my moments to chow down on Chinese food these days. The perils of Geriatric Oregon Trail Millennial-hood.“

“We were traveling and just stopped by to eat sth. with my family. The place had a great atmosphere, cozy friendly and comfy. With an "old school diner" vibe. We had a cheeseburger DX, protein omelette and chicken gyro wt FF, coffee and soda. The whole check for three people was around $52. And the waitress Melinda was great! She even told us how much time driving is left to our destination point. If we're gonna be in the area we'll definitely come back?“