Matera's Italian Market

72 Park Ave, Rutherford
(201) 438-8083

Recent Reviews

Mike V

Have ordered catering a few times from here. Great variety. Very fair prices for what you get. Quality ingredients and presentation. Would recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sean Brand

The food service and atmosphere were second to none. This is my new go-to.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ronald Hernandez

Great spot. Had one of the best chicken parms I have ever had. The service was spectacular and the atmosphere was incredible. Will be returning to try different sandwiches on the menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vodka Chicken Parm, Fresh Mozzarella

Tom Gawron

Typically my go to Italian deli in the area. Unfortunate visit a few days ago as I ordered and H7 and various Italian deli meats. Upon opening the H7 sandwich once I got home it was just breaded chicken and cheese without any vodka sauce which was upsetting. Also all Italian meats were stacked on top of each other which made it near impossible to peel off single layers of prosciutto instead of being layered with paper as it is usually done. Quality of food wasn’t the issue as compared to the service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Nick C

Spectacular sandwiches and they are reasonably priced!

Jo “Sweetjo”

Was looking for an authentic Italian Market/Deli and glad I found this one. It’s a cute little shop on a corner very clean and quint, some tables inside to enjoy one of their amazing Sandwiches or a cup of coffee, everything is fresh and tasty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Sandwich of the Day

DJ Lou Productions (DJ Lou)

Awesome place worth the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

maria malindretos

Delicious ? food wonderful team great birthday party in the Loft!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Frank S.

The food is amazing. I have had the coach, m1, h7, and the Belleville classic. The bread and the meats are amazing. Highly recommended!

Jessica M.

Got the C18. So filling. Love the specialty cutlets they have! Had to grab a dessert - pumpkin cannoli! Fast delivery.

Justin Boushay

This place is the go to Italian market/deli for anyhting your heart, soul, and tastes desire

Paul M.

Really nice Italian deli, they seems to make many things fresh and in house and while I have only had their lunch sandwiches they are really good.

Alice R.

I grew up in this small town and what this town is known for are restaurants on Park Avenue. Unfortunately the Mandees and the Hallmark where we all went shopping and got candy after school are gone, but this place is one of few businesses that stayed in tact. I recall walking by it many times, but never really went in. Now I live in the city and come to Jersey once a month to visit family. My brother picks me up at the Rutherford train station, but he is always running late. I was a bit hungry one day waiting for my awful uber driver so I decided to grab a something here. I got an antipasti salad and a bag of chips to go. They were really sweet letting me sit around and wait for my brother. When I got home, I had the salad and man, simple and what a gal needed to get some veggies in her tummy. Will be going back here next time my uber driver is late again!

Joselyn Marrero-De Jesus

Yummy the food and workers there are all amazing

DEANA KAZINCI

My mom hosted a surprise bridal shower for me this past Sunday which was held at The Loft. I was so excited as the space is beautiful. So much natural light which made for great photos. The food was delicious as we had a nice spread of brunch items and some hot food items. My mom was in communication with Erica leading up to the shower and throughout the planning process. She was so helpful and kind. On the day of the event, Carol was our server and was wonderful. So sweet and very attendant. We have a great experience!

Load More