I honestly don’t know why this place has 4.5 stars. I’m German and was looking for good German bread rolls and bread.The first time I went a while back, I got bread rolls and bread pudding. The bread rolls were okay, but really not much like German ones, not crispy at all and flavor was lacking. The bread pudding was just dry, flavor was okay. Service was friendly during that visit.I recently gave it another try and got a pretty expensive loaf of multigrain bread. Service didn’t seem interested in selling anything.I tried the bread when I got home and it was sweet? Also way too soft, absolutely not like German bread at all.I was going to try some cookies, because they looked good, but for almost $19 per pound I skipped them.If you want decent German bread, try the bakery in Lidl supermarkets…more authentic than this…
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Wei S.
I found this place by an accident about three years ago. I have tried their strudels, scones and pies. Everything was so good. Nothing was too sweet. Cheese scone was something I have never had before.
Melissa E.
The pastries and donuts are divine. Been there many times, But...after an encounter there recently, I'm not sure I'll go back. I tried to purchase about $7 worth of buns- at which point the gentleman rolled his eyes at me when I pulled out my card. You don't have cash?? He asked in almost disbelief. No, Sir. I asked what the minimum was, he said "not $7".My poor kids were sad they couldn't get anything. I noticed it was 15 mins til closing. I understand the charges these business face, but this man preferred to let those baked goods go stale on his shelf or throw them out rather than eat a 40 cent processing fee. Maybe it's because I'm Latino, cause the way he snatched that bag off the counter when he found out I didn't have cash... I don't think I have the heart to go back.
Kevin L.
Family owned and has authentic German apple strudel. Haven't had something quite like that in years. Fantastic selection of fresh baked breads, all with a taste from home!
rabid raptor
Best cupcakes I've ever had. My favorite part of the store is walking in and letting the wonderful sweet smell engulf you. They have a wide selection of flavours and a cute environment.
Carrina Trawinski
Wow! I loved this bakery! We went to visit the area, and happened upon this bakery. There were all sorts of options to try: scones, cookies, cakes, croissants, donuts, etc. There wasn’t one dessert we tried that we didn’t like. The blueberry scone had to be my favorite though, well, and the chocolate croissant. Nothing was too sweet or too dry, the flavors were great! Staff was so nice. Would love to come back again!
T M
They have my favorite donut French Cruller ?
Jin
Heritage bakery shop that is all natural and homemade! I have to recommend this place it’s delicious.
Burt Shoobs
Varrelmann's Bake Shop, found on Park Avenue in downtown Rutherford, is one of those hidden gems that most people would simply pass by because it is practically hidden in the mass that is downtown Rutherford. It is however, one top notch bakery with tremendous items to offer. Their donuts, pastries, muffins and scones are super. I also found it refreshing to find, that even at 3 in the afternoon, they were still preparing fresh coffee, when most places would merely bang up their coffee dispenser. One more great plus; with more and more upscale coffee shops and bakery vendors appearing on the scenes along this stretch of town, it's a great relief to encounter a business that is comparatively easy on the wallet. I love this place.
Enjoying this peaceful rainy day on my way to work I get a little bit of sweet in this afternoon, I totally recommend this place in Rutherford. @Varrelmann's Bake shop. Soo delicious pastries. Love it ??
Rob M
Their brioche loaf makes the best french toast!
Jennifer Canova
Got a cake for Mother’s Day . It was moist and delicious. Everything about the place is good except the crumb buns are dry, unless you go there first thing in the morning when there still warm. Would recommend! ???
Lauren H.
Excellent cakes! I got two delicious chocolate cakes from here for a family party. Service was excellent and everyone at my party loved the cakes!
Bette S
I love Varrelmann's! This is a Rutherford staple that hasn't changed for good reason: why mess with perfection? They, of course, have the standard bakery fare of cakes, pies, and donuts that are delightful, but, you *really* want to go in for their butter cookies! They tout an old recipe, and for good reason! Come in and enjoy!
The best pfeeffernusse cookies!
Food: 5
I honestly don’t know why this place has 4.5 stars. I’m German and was looking for good German bread rolls and bread.The first time I went a while back, I got bread rolls and bread pudding. The bread rolls were okay, but really not much like German ones, not crispy at all and flavor was lacking. The bread pudding was just dry, flavor was okay. Service was friendly during that visit.I recently gave it another try and got a pretty expensive loaf of multigrain bread. Service didn’t seem interested in selling anything.I tried the bread when I got home and it was sweet? Also way too soft, absolutely not like German bread at all.I was going to try some cookies, because they looked good, but for almost $19 per pound I skipped them.If you want decent German bread, try the bakery in Lidl supermarkets…more authentic than this…
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
I found this place by an accident about three years ago. I have tried their strudels, scones and pies. Everything was so good. Nothing was too sweet. Cheese scone was something I have never had before.
The pastries and donuts are divine. Been there many times, But...after an encounter there recently, I'm not sure I'll go back. I tried to purchase about $7 worth of buns- at which point the gentleman rolled his eyes at me when I pulled out my card. You don't have cash?? He asked in almost disbelief. No, Sir. I asked what the minimum was, he said "not $7".My poor kids were sad they couldn't get anything. I noticed it was 15 mins til closing. I understand the charges these business face, but this man preferred to let those baked goods go stale on his shelf or throw them out rather than eat a 40 cent processing fee. Maybe it's because I'm Latino, cause the way he snatched that bag off the counter when he found out I didn't have cash... I don't think I have the heart to go back.
Family owned and has authentic German apple strudel. Haven't had something quite like that in years. Fantastic selection of fresh baked breads, all with a taste from home!
Best cupcakes I've ever had. My favorite part of the store is walking in and letting the wonderful sweet smell engulf you. They have a wide selection of flavours and a cute environment.
Wow! I loved this bakery! We went to visit the area, and happened upon this bakery. There were all sorts of options to try: scones, cookies, cakes, croissants, donuts, etc. There wasn’t one dessert we tried that we didn’t like. The blueberry scone had to be my favorite though, well, and the chocolate croissant. Nothing was too sweet or too dry, the flavors were great! Staff was so nice. Would love to come back again!
They have my favorite donut French Cruller ?
Heritage bakery shop that is all natural and homemade! I have to recommend this place it’s delicious.
Varrelmann's Bake Shop, found on Park Avenue in downtown Rutherford, is one of those hidden gems that most people would simply pass by because it is practically hidden in the mass that is downtown Rutherford. It is however, one top notch bakery with tremendous items to offer. Their donuts, pastries, muffins and scones are super. I also found it refreshing to find, that even at 3 in the afternoon, they were still preparing fresh coffee, when most places would merely bang up their coffee dispenser. One more great plus; with more and more upscale coffee shops and bakery vendors appearing on the scenes along this stretch of town, it's a great relief to encounter a business that is comparatively easy on the wallet. I love this place.
Restaurantji Recommends
Enjoying this peaceful rainy day on my way to work I get a little bit of sweet in this afternoon, I totally recommend this place in Rutherford. @Varrelmann's Bake shop. Soo delicious pastries. Love it ??
Their brioche loaf makes the best french toast!
Got a cake for Mother’s Day . It was moist and delicious. Everything about the place is good except the crumb buns are dry, unless you go there first thing in the morning when there still warm. Would recommend! ???
Excellent cakes! I got two delicious chocolate cakes from here for a family party. Service was excellent and everyone at my party loved the cakes!
I love Varrelmann's! This is a Rutherford staple that hasn't changed for good reason: why mess with perfection? They, of course, have the standard bakery fare of cakes, pies, and donuts that are delightful, but, you *really* want to go in for their butter cookies! They tout an old recipe, and for good reason! Come in and enjoy!