40 Best Ice Cream Shops near Stirling

“The Stirling Fountain is a great new addition to the neighborhood. When we drove up there were a lot of people sitting outside enjoying their ice cream and the line inside was out the door. We initially hesitated whether we had the time to wait and luckily decided to go in. The line moved so fast, and everyone working behind the counter was incredibly friendly. The portion sizes are better than most ice cream shops and they have a great selection of flavors. I highly recommend visiting. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Had a very lovely trip to the store. Was attended to by Micheal and he really took the time talk with us and show us the merchandise. Took time to get our full order with no rushing and even enrolled us in the rewards program for a free chocolate. Chocolate is very tasty and worth the cost, great for gifts and they also sell mini chocolate that is very well priced.“

“A lot of places don't live up to the hype. That is not the case with Surreal. From the second we walked in, we were greeted, and asked if it was our first visit. The employee that helped us was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. We were offered samples and suggestions. Our customer experience alone was worth the trip. The Thai milk tea was the best I have ever had. I was offered a sample of the taro ice cream (not something I would have ordered on my own) and WOW. It might have been the best ice cream I have had. Needless to say I ordered one. Check it out, my entire family enjoyed their orders too. Absolutely worth the trip.“

“The flavors were terrific! I ended up having terrible diarrhea while enjoying the ice cream, but luckily I was in my car and was able to get home without anyone noticing. This was of no fault of Beenies Ice Cream or staff, I just have really bad lactose intolerance that I refuse to let control my life. I will be back!“

“Quick stop here for ice cream, on a week night. Great variety of flavors and lots of seating. I got the strawberry buttermilk: roasted strawberries, buttermilk and house sweet strawberry honey balsamic jam...so good, love the jam running through it and not stingy with it. Staff was friendly and helpful. Would definitely come back.“

“Ice cream was amazing! Peanut butter pie! The young girl who helped me was a different experience. I don't know if her house just burned down or some terrible tragedy because she didn't smile, didn't even look at me, nor speak and abruptly walked away right after I paid. No spoons. She looked very upset and something was obviously very wrong. Very very bad customer service but it was that bad I can only assume something horrible happened to the staff person because otherwise there's no way someone acts like that.“

“omg the best decision i made was to chose your bakery, i ordered the barbie cake with red velvet and strawberry buttercream frosting,the cake was sooo good , it was soo moist and daughter absolutely loved it , would definitely come back for more , thank you very “

“Today, I had the BEST Italian ice in my life. It was the best blend of flavors and each bite made me want more. The strawberry-guava was delicious and a great way to end my lunch date. I cannot wait to try the other flavors. One of my friends had the chocolate flavor and was blown away by the flavor. I loved everything about this business(Italian ice, store setup, seating area). The pictures on the wall and the floor tiles reminded me of home and growing up. Summer was tough for me with the loss of my mom and this flavor (plus shop) made me smile. Flavor reminded me of her. Thank you to owners. I will be back. To anyone reading this, just go.“

“We visited while in the area and found both the food and service to be outstanding. The sushi was very fresh and there are some inventive rolls on the menu. They have several tea options, one of which is the Flower Tea, a beautifully fragrant mix of organic leaves of jasmine, rose, lavender, chamomile and marigold which my daughter and I found to be soothing and totally hit the spot on a chilly rainy night. The owner was accommodating and extremely friendly; she made sure to check on us several times during the meal. Highly recommend!“

“I’ve got to say, the best FroYo place around. They have so many flavor options, and so many toppings. Their boba is pretty good. It’s your average boba. I have never tried one of their smoothies, or rolled ice cream. It’s such a popular place with the kids, and it’s also walking distance from the green! I highly recommend.“

“My wife and I have come to fresh tiki bar several times now. I have had their soft serve vanilla which is out of this world. As well as their Italian cookie which if you like Italian rainbow cookies you owe it to yourself to try at least once. The place is fairly small inside but it does have outdoor seating. The menu is a good size for an ice cream place, they don't have 5 million flavors but when the number gets that high they often get real weird. The fun flavors they do have seam limited and on a rotation, but I think this allows them to provide a higher quality product from what I've had. I'm fairly certain this is a husband and wife team and I have only dealt with the wife, but she is always very friendly and has a general chipper demeanor.This is a great place for a small date night treat or to take the kids and get a little ice cream.“

“Super good! Me and my siblings went during the night a few weeks back when it was really nice out and the place was packed!!! The workers were super attentive and very apologetic about the wait time (which we understood since it was INSANE) the ice cream was absolutely delicious. I got the baileys flavor and was blown away by it! I will be coming back as much as my bank account and doctor will allow ? I highly recommend this place to everyone who wants to have great service and amazing ice cream.“

“I've been in here a twice since they opened and this place is great. They have a wide selection of bubble tea options as well as ice cream (rolled) and other snacks. The first time I came, I got the lychee slushie with tapioca boba, which was really good. Next I got the chocolate chip rolled ice cream with m&m's, which was pretty good too. The owner is very friendly and actually remembered me when I came in the second time (maybe a month in between visits). They have a loyalty punch card for ice cream and drinks and several games in their retro seating area. There are some old school games and a little plastic axe throwing area which would be fun for kids. If you're looking for a yummy treat, give this place a try. It's their second location and the owner is very friendly, serving up tasty treats.“

“Most delicious ice cream ever. The owner, is such an upstanding guy. I could chat with him for hours. Staff are polite. A must go to ice cream play this summer.Kid-friendliness: Very much, take pictures with the cow outside.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheel chair ramp is how to get in.“

“This past weekend my husband & I tried this place for the first time through Too Good To Go. We were greeted by a friendly young lady & were asked if we had any allergy restrictions & received our order quickly. The cookies were so soft (even 2 days later)! Definitely would go back again!“

“Love the tomato pie and the funghi pie. Add hot honey and it elevates them even further. I never used to be much of a pizza person. This place has me craving it. The freshness and quality of products are noticeable. Owner and staff are also very kind!“

“On the way home, I accidentally saw the crowd in front of his door and entered. I waited a while for the queue to come, but since the number of employees was high, the turn came quickly. I ate cookie, vanilla and lemon ice cream. Afterwards, the ice cream was delicious among the chocolate biscuits. the employees are friendly and very friendly. I'll be back soon to try other flavors. (masculine)“

“YOU MUST GO HERE FOR DINNER!!!!!!! Not only is this the only place nearby serving East African food, it is so good that it is akin to food heaven! The staff are incredible! And for dessert you can get amazing homemade ice cream! So please please please do yourself a favor and try the Eritrean food! You will not be disappointed!“

“Great ice cream, friendly kids, working there this year, and willing to accommodate food allergies by changing their gloves, opening up a clean container of ice cream and using a clean scooper. We appreciate this very much and will patronize as often as possible.“

“Best soft serve I have ever had!!! Honestly... I can't say enough good things about this place. To say I was pleasantly surprised I'd an understatement. I got a soft serve swirl with cookie dough bites and it was delicious. The ice cream is perfectly creamy, and the vanilla had an almost marshmallow-y taste to it. It also sort of reminded me of the cream inside an Oreo. Perfectly balanced between creamy and cold- it didn't taste watered down or too "Icy". My mom and my 16 month old also agreed. (Ok, my mom agreed. My son was a fan but he doesn't quite understand just how good it was yet.) My son didn't finish his, so we brought it back with us to upstate NY. Yes, it was good enough to save in the freezer at our hotel and then to shlep back home so I could enjoy one more time. And also so my husband could try it since I couldn't stop raving about it. Also worth noting- I'm very impressed at their variety. They have lots of soft serve and hard ice cream flavors. I hope I have another work trip that brings me back, cause I will be dreaming of this ice cream until then!“

“Place is very clean, food is absolutely delicious and their smoothies are amazing. I get this around 3-4 times per week and have only good things to say about this place. Food comes out fast and their delivery prep through Ubereats is very good as nothing is ever spilledParking: Parking is a bit tough as it is on a very busy street. If you go around the block towards supremo supermarket you’ll be able to find a wider variety of parking.“

“This review is seriously overdue, I love coming here! If I could give them more stars I honestly would. I love supporting local businesses vs. corporate places when I can. They have soo many flavors, great service and always very clean. Its also in a really great part of town which is very convenient for me. My personal favorite menu items there are the CUTEST little home made chipwiches and the shakes (I always request Paul make the shake if he’s there) its soo good! Definitely recommend. The cakes are great as well, I got one for my friend’s birthday recently, everyone loved it!“

“We ordered the new Ultimate Cookie Blizzard and it was amazing! We even met the owner, Lou, and his daughter, Donna, and they were great to chat with. We sat outside, enjoying our Blizzards. Plenty of seating indoors and outdoors as well as parking.“

“Shake Shack is a fast food restaurant so I was surprised when I received 5 star customer service thanks in part to one of their workers, Jonathan. He was friendly, helped when I need it and was an overall kind person. The food was also amazing but that’s a given at Shake Shack.“

“While as you like, it doesn't overwhelm with exotic flavors, The ice cream is a good quality, and its location in a walkable part of Raritan, with nearby access to the pedestrian bridge over the river makes it one of the better ice cream destinations in the area.“

“Stone house is a nice restaurant for cocktails and dinner. The ambiance is amazing, service was great. The food was portioned well and reasonably priced for a higher end restaurant. The food itself was good but nothing spectacular. Ordered the porterhouse which was slightly over cooked and the short rib which was a little dry. Would definitely recommend the restaurant, especially in the warmer weather when the patio will be open.“

“I have been working at Dolce Gelato for about 3 months. I really love this job becauseit's a nice little cozy cafe in a nice location in Somerville;these are the smiles of children who are happy that their parents brought them to a cafe to enjoy gelato;it is the aroma of the best Italian coffee that adults come for...I am very happy for every visitor and try to provide the best service from myself. Sorry for my English, I'm learning it every day, but it's still not enough.Everyone is welcome to visit Dolce Gelato for a cup of coffee with a sandwich or a delicious Italian dessert of your choice!I thank all visitors for their comments on this site and said simply in the face! I'm so sorry Emily DOE that I upset you so much by giving you 4 quarters instead of 1 paper dollar. I didn't have any more singles in the cash register at the time. But I gave you and your friend the correct change. I hope you will come again and I will try to find the change in bills that you like. Thank you for your comment!“

“Very good! I got a small cone of the pistachio gelato. It was pricy but the portion was respectable and the flavor was great.I am not picky about pistachio flavor - I love cheap artificial pistachio flavor just as much as authentic pistachio flavor. But I have to give credit, this was proper pistachio. I also liked that the pistachio pieces were small. I prefer small pieces to whole pistachios.I am looking forward to going back and trying other flavors!“

“I’m giving 5 stars although I did not like what I saw tonight. I was in line with my kids and this man with his wife and kid were at a window. The man was yelling at the employee and from the beginning he had a very nasty attitude. Even if something was wrong he had no right to scream at this young girl who was trying to help him. Never in the years i’ve come to this rita’s have I seen someone act this way especially with the amazing workers they have. Props to the other girls inside who tried to laugh it off.“

“What a great ice cream shop!! We live bringing our grandson here when we’re in town! We recently purchased an ice cream cake that was absolutely perfect!! No dry cake filler just ALL ice cream! You can pick two flavors. When ordering, she was very patient and helpful! This is definitely one of our “go to” places!!!“

“We have been enjoying this gem of an ice cream shop for decades. Nick and his family treat you like part of their family. The ice cream is homemade. The cones are homemade. The brownies are homemade. There is a theme here. You are in for a gastronomic desert delight! Get to Magic Fountain today! I promise you will want to come back again and again! So many flavors and so little time. Thank you Nick and family for keeping the tradition alive! God Bless America! God Bless Blue & Gold! Remember Everyone Deployed Everyday!“

“This is a cite place. Didn't know about it. You can be served inside or out. There is a decent size seating area to eat. They have a great selection of ice cream and toppings. I'm usually a sprinkle guy but decided to try the cotton candy and simple soft serve vanilla. It was really good. I do plan on going back for the hard serve ice cream, seeing as there are flavors there I have not seen and would like to try.“

“Forget the rest, Rita's Italian Ice reigns supreme in the world of refreshing, flavorful treats. Here's why Rita's blows the competition away:Flavor Frenzy: Walk into a Rita's and you're hit with a wave of mouthwatering options. They have a ridiculous (in the best way) variety of flavors, from classic mango and cherry to out-there picks like cotton candy watermelon. Plus, they rotate seasonal flavors, so there's always something new to try.Real Fruit Fusion: Unlike some Italian ices that taste vaguely fruity, Rita's packs a punch of real fruit flavor. You can practically taste the sunshine in every single bite.Texture that Tantalizes: Rita's Italian ice is unlike anything else. It's smooth and creamy, but with a delightful, light, and refreshing texture. It's the perfect balance between icy cool-down and flavor explosion.The Custard Combo: Rita's doesn't stop at just Italian ice. They offer delicious frozen custard, and the combo of the two, their signature Gelati, is pure magic. Creamy custard cools down the vibrant ice, creating a textural and taste bud party.Sweet for Every Sweet Tooth: With so many flavors and portion options, Rita's caters to everyone. Want a full-on brain freeze? Grab a large cup. Craving a lighter treat? They have sugar-free options too.Sure, you might find Italian ice elsewhere, but Rita's takes it to a whole new level. It's a delicious experience that keeps you coming back for more. So next time you're craving a cool treat, skip the generic and head to Rita's. Your taste buds will thank you.“

“I saw this place and wanted to try it out. I got the vanilla with peanut butter and caramel add in and graham cracker topping. You can have up to 5 toppings. The ice cream was pretty good. Once he was done it was pretty hard. I had to let it soften a little. I would recommend this place. I definitely want to go back.“

“It's an adorable little spot to get ice cream. Good selection of items and great flavors.Also fun little fact is in the winter, they trun into The Soup Coop.Do note there is no publicly accessible interior. It's only a walk up window.Just a nice spot all around.“

“I ordered chocolate marshmallow ice cream with Oreos on top. Overall, it was a decent ice cream. I was a little disappointed it was not homemade, and they get all of it from Hershey. I originally asked for peanut butter sauce as a topping and they did not have that, which disappointed me. I ordered a small and the portion was generous, so I was pretty happy. I would go back if i was in walking distance, but definety would not drive to come back again.“

“I stopped by on a Saturday and chatted with the lady at the counter for a while - super friendly and glad to have stumbled across this place.The ice cream was fairly standard, being so close to the theatre and center of Dunellen its in a good location“

“I was seen very quickly by the staff and they answered all of my questions about sizes and specials. Kyle happened to be the gentleman who helped me. He was quick and polite. A real pleasure. I felt really bad that I was unable to tip him or the great staff there using my card. Knowing that most don’t carry cash after Covid-19 (because let’s be honest, money was dirty before the pandemic) it seems unfair that the staff is unable to get tips via another method. People who work customer service jobs deserve to be able to receive tips for making sure the customers are taken care of. Thank you so much to the staff for always being polite and quick with every order we requested.“

“I don't know if Mayberry had an ice cream shop in the Andy Griffith show, but if it did it would be called Hi-Tams ice cream. And just like in Mayberry you would get some of the creamiest ice cream, that would be the center of the town's sweet tooth heart. That little walkway out front holds so many memories from generations upon generations of Somerset County residents. And if you get to peek your head inside the little window and see some of the décor on the walls, the old posters, the little television in the corner playing some TV show that nobody can watch because they're always so darn busy... It's a slice of American life, The American ice cream shop.“

“I love Rita's no matter which location, however I need to leave a review for the staff here. Two young ladies, one with a ponytail and a huge smile who was so good with everyone she served. Funny and charming and legitimately enjoys her job.“